hey jake, rate my final product please...

[anpyanks]

jake, i asked you the other day how i started and this is my finished product... keep in mind that you can start lineup either of two wasy
1) 1qb, 2rb, 2wr, 1te, 1k, 1def or 2) 1qb, 1rb, 3wr, 1te, 1k, 1def
rules: all td's no matter qb or rb 5 pts, qb gets 1 add pt for every 8 completions, rb/wr/te 1 pt per 10 yds, 1 pt per 8 rushing attempts, and 1 pt per reception, k all fgs 3pts any over 50+ 5pts, and def 1pt per turnover, 2pts safety, 1 pt per sack, 8 for a shutout and 4 for 1-9 pts allowed...


qb kitna and cutler
rb gore, benson, and j.lewis
wr holt, s.holmes, hackett, r.curry, a.gonzalez, furrey
te winslow, b.olsen
k rackers
def miami and carolina


grade my team and dont hold back, i can take critisism.. thanks

[fhmesq44]

WRs are awful, you don't even have a #2 WR. 3 of those guys are #3 on their own team and I don't expect much of Holmes yet (if ever). No need to carry 2 TE or D unless required. Also stayed away from Holt myself, he is getting older, they are running more and he had knee surgery during the off season and has himself said he is only 70%.

Who did you draft in the 4th round? 5th? I like Winslow as a TE. RB's are solid with a top tier #1, solid #2 and Lewis as a #3.

[anpyanks]

btw, keep in mind jake a 12 team league


4th was kitna
5th was lewis

[Jake T.]

Doing this quick as I am at work and don't have alot of time for lunch.

I like your QBs alot. Kitna is a certified #1 in my view and Cutler is a very nice backup.

RB is nice although I'd like to see some RBs with more receptions. If Benson gets close to as many receptions as Thomas Jones got, he should be a nice back. J Lew won't catch many passes but is a nice backup in most any league.

WR is iffy although I like the value picks with Gonzalez and Furrey, two guys who can be had in the later rounds who should be more than solid. Holt scares me and I'd reccomend trading him as soon as possible. Only an average unit although the backend guys should fill in nicely if needed. Gonzo and Furrey are both #3's but they are #3's in some of the best passing offenses in teh league that utilize their #3's.

TE is good. Winslow is gonna catch alot of passes.

I think you have a great shot and you made a great value pick with Kitna. I'd try and trade Gore and Holt for LT and another WR though. Those reception points are going to be nice for LT and I'm really just not a Holt fan this year. He's dinged up pretty bad and I see his career going down in a hurry.