Which NFL player would you start a team with?

PatsFan1283 · Sep 29, 2015

Here is the kicker: Can't be a QB

Assume the rest of the team is all league average players to make everything relatively equal. If your QB sucks then there is less incentive to have Gronk or Julio since you can't maximize them. If your OL can't run block then having AP might not be as valuable, etc...

Only for this season.

beefdiesel · Sep 29, 2015

JJ Watt

seldomseen · Sep 29, 2015

JJ Watt

wabashwonders · Sep 29, 2015

Mr_Mark · Sep 29, 2015

rex ryan

The Guesser · Sep 30, 2015

JJ Watt. Far distant 2nd is Justin Houston.

slapshot · Sep 30, 2015

Sherman

mibokhee · Sep 30, 2015

sam bratfort

Vlad the Impaler · Sep 30, 2015

Whoever the best young corner is. Revis or someone like that but not sure of his age. Besides qb, they are the most rare to come along and get right. Watt hasn't meant anything to the Texans in terms of win/ loss. You get 1 great corner, you can be average at the other 3 secondary spots.

doubledeuce22 · Sep 30, 2015

Anyone mention of a rb or wr in today's nfl is way off. JJ or Sherman.

wabashwonders · Sep 30, 2015

doubledeuce22 said:
Anyone mention of a rb or wr in today's nfl is way off. JJ or Sherman.

Why would you need a top defensive player if the offense is just average? My selection of Beckham is based on the fact he plays on an average team with an average qb, yet he still puts up top numbers. So, his value shouldn't decrease in this scenario described.

MantisToboggan · Sep 30, 2015

Watt or Justin Houston. The way I see it is the only way to beat a top QB is to have a one yourself or have someone who can get after him.

RenoChazz · Sep 30, 2015

Tim Tebow.

bases80 · Sep 30, 2015

Patrick Peterson

FairWarning · Sep 30, 2015

Either a tackle that can protect the QB blindside, a stud in the middle of the defensive line or a lockdown CB.

JustinCruise · Sep 30, 2015

Every gm in the league would say Andrew luck

MantisToboggan · Sep 30, 2015

PatsFan1283 said:
Here is the kicker: Can't be a QB

Assume the rest of the team is all league average players to make everything relatively equal. If your QB sucks then there is less incentive to have Gronk or Julio since you can't maximize them. If your OL can't run block then having AP might not be as valuable, etc...

Only for this season.

JustinCruise said:
Every gm in the league would say Andrew luck

They playing him at strong safety?

Vlad the Impaler · Sep 30, 2015

Mantis Toboggan said:
They playing him at strong safety?

He could probably play that position the way he goes after people after turnovers. Everyone has seen the tape when he layed a USC linebacker out. Turn the ball over in the NFL, just fall down.

<iframe src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/RF9PFJI_t5I" allowfullscreen="" frameborder="0" height="315" width="560"></iframe>

JustinCruise · Sep 30, 2015

Non qb - Adrien Peterson

Vlad the Impaler · Sep 30, 2015

JustinCruise said:
Non qb - Adrien Peterson

Are you serious?

1. He is a running back that has not made a difference in win/ losses
2. He is 30 and likely has a shitload of carries on him

How many playoff games has even been in? If anything, I would trade that guy in a second. I wish you and I were GM's right now. I could prob. got 5 1st and 2nd round picks for an overated running back.

Which NFL player would you start a team with?

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

New member

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Member

New member

Official Rx music critic and beer snob

New member

Member

Banned

New member

Banned

Forum statistics

Share this page