Does Penn st deserve to be in the playoffs?

bookiereport · Dec 3, 2016

Big 10 champ. What do you think?
1. Alabama
2. Clemson
3. Washington
4. ????

tulah · Dec 3, 2016

RunLeeRun · Dec 3, 2016

tulah said:
No.
Washington deserves to be in

I think he means instead of Ohio State. I say yes.

tulah · Dec 4, 2016

RunLeeRun said:
I think he means instead of Ohio State. I say yes.

right.

I typed the wrong team

Soccerguru · Dec 4, 2016

Alabama, Clemson, Washington, Penn State

tulah · Dec 4, 2016

I hope for chaos so the committee takes heat and they get forced to expand to 6 or 8 teams.
that would be sweet.

also does it even matter who gets in. Alabama will beat anyone by 14+.

Albatross · Dec 4, 2016

Penn st

Yes they do.

Willie99 · Dec 4, 2016

Bama, Clemson, Ohio St all appear to be in

Michigan, Penn St & Washington are all in the mix

Truth is, maybe only Bama is an absolute mortal lock. You can find a flaw in everybody else, you can make an argument for or against all the other teams

Be a great year to have 8 teams in the playoffs, which I think is the perfect number

SunDodger · Dec 4, 2016

I think they did enough. Penn St. beat Ohio St. SU, and won the Big 10.
　
My Vote:
　
1. Alabama 13-0
2. Washington 12-1
3. Clemson 12-1
4. Penn St. 11-2
5. Ohio St. 11-1
　
　
　
But, I've never seen a team get more favoritism than Ohio St. They probably won't even drop from the #2 spot. ESPN will spend all night telling us why they are more deserving.

WinOne · Dec 4, 2016

I'd drop Ohio St. They did not win the B10 and looking at the PSU conference body of work, beating the top 3 teams from the B10 West (Wisky, Iowa, Minny) and splitting with Mich and Ohio St, they should get in. Drop Ohio St, go with Bama, Clemson, Wash, PSU

EveryGamblersDream · Dec 4, 2016

I understand they have 2 losses compared to one but how can you reward Ohio State for having 1 less loss when they not only failed to win their conference much less a division within it & lost to the team that actually won a division & overall conference title.

tulah · Dec 4, 2016

Sun Dodger said:
I think they did enough. Penn St. beat Ohio St. SU, and won the Big 10.
　
My Vote:
　
1. Alabama 13-0
2. Washington 12-1
3. Clemson 12-1
4. Penn St. 11-2
5. Ohio St. 11-1
　
　
　
But, I've never seen a team get more favoritism than Ohio St. They probably won't even drop from the #2 spot. ESPN will spend all night telling us why they are more deserving.

agreed. OSU gets all the love.
CHAOS:toast:

WinOne · Dec 4, 2016

EveryGamblersDream said:
I understand they have 2 losses compared to one but how can you reward Ohio State for having 1 less loss when they not only failed to win their conference much less a division within it & lost to the team that actually won a division & overall conference title.

It's time the Committee talks about the 13th data point. They killed TCU and Baylor a couple years back. Drop Ohio St now. And dont drop Washington. Despite their non conference schedule, they played 11 P5 teams (10 in conference + 1 non con).

Bad_Cat · Dec 4, 2016

They will not jump Michigan. Michigan embarrassed them this year.

Bad_Cat · Dec 4, 2016

Winning your conference does not matter. It's the 4 best teams and penn state is not one of them

Bad_Cat · Dec 4, 2016

If you had 8 teams there would be more chaos. Think about it. It will be Alabama, Ohio State, Clemson and Washington, period.

RunLeeRun · Dec 4, 2016

Bad_Cat said:
They will not jump Michigan. Michigan embarrassed them this year.

Mich lost 2 of 4 in november. PS won 9 straight. Mich ends up 6th.

RunLeeRun · Dec 4, 2016

Bad_Cat said:
Winning your conference does not matter. It's the 4 best teams and penn state is not one of them

All playoff teams have won conferences to date, no?

cigar · Dec 4, 2016

ohio st shouldve been eliminated tonight

SunDodger · Dec 4, 2016

ESPN is acting like Ohio St. is a lock, and Washington is on the bubble with Michigan and Penn St. That is corrupt bullshit.
　
No fucking way the Big 10 deserves two spots.
　
I have to turn the channel now, as listening to this will drive me crazy.

Does Penn st deserve to be in the playoffs?

Member

Member

New member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Conservatives, Patriots & Huskies return to glory

New member

RX Old-Timer

Member

Member

RX Old-Timer

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Member

New member

Forum statistics

Share this page