Utah Nurse Arrested Over Refusing to Draw Blood

Search

Member
Joined
May 27, 2007
Messages
39,461
Tokens
The Utah nurse whose videotaped arrest provoked nationwide outrage says Salt Lake City police must work to win back public confidence.

"I'm not here to police the police," Alex Wubbels, 41, said Monday on TODAY. "The police need to do that if they're going to regain any kind of trust by me or, I think, the public."

The Salt Lake City Police Department has been roundly criticized after the release of body camera video showing one of its officers, Det. Jeff Payne, arrest Wubbels when she refused to allow officers to draw a patient's blood.

Payne and a second officer have been placed on paid administrative leavepending the investigation, police said Friday. The second officer wasn't identified.

In bodycam video of the July 26 arrest, Payne demands that Wubbels draw blood from an unconscious patient, the victim of a road accident that left him badly burned. Wubbels refuses, citing hospital protocol. Payne becomes agitated, and Wubbels doesn't back down.

"No, we're done," Payne says abruptly in the video, which may have been edited. "You're under arrest. We're going!"

Payne can then be seen handcuffing Wubbels and dragging her from the hospital. She was later released and not charged.

In a written report obtained by The Salt Lake Tribune, Payne said he needed the blood sample to determine whether the patient had illicit substances in his system at the time of the crash.

Prosecutors have called for a criminal investigation. NBC News has reached out to Payne for comment.

Wubbels said the incident "resonates with people all over."

"I feel a sense of urgency for this conversation," she told TODAY. "We need to make this better. This can't be happening."
"If I have anything to say about it," she added, "it won't happen again."

Her attorney, Karra Porter, added that a civil lawsuit is "not off the table."

At a news conference Monday afternoon, hospital officials praised Wubbels for standing her ground, putting her own safety at risk to uphold hospital policy and defend patient privacy.

"Her actions are nothing less than exemplary," said Gordon Crabtree, the chief financial officer of University of Utah Health.

Hospital officials also announced changes to the facility's protocol with law enforcement. Among the changes, nurses will no longer work directly with law enforcement, Crabtree said.

Wubbels competed as an Alpine skier in the 1998 and 2002 Winter Olympic Games. She has worked at the hospital since 2009.

The inquiry will be run by Salt Lake County's Unified Police. The district attorney's office will review the findings and determine whether they merit criminal charges.

The Supreme Court ruled in 2016 that a blood sample can't be taken without patient consent or a warrant.

Salt Lake City police updated their blood-draw policy "right away" to match the hospital's and the department has already re-trained officers on the updated policy, police spokeswoman Christina Judd said.

Police also met with hospital officials within 24 hours to figure out "what we needed to change to make sure it didn't happen again," Judd said.

"We have a really strong tie to the nurses that we work with. The police interact with nurses multiple times a day sometimes, and we never want to fracture that relationship," she said.

"We took the incident very seriously from the moment we found out about it and have been working really diligently with Wubbels' attorney and ... herself and trying to make sure that no one in the medical profession ever needs to fear a police officer here," she added. "It's so sad that we've had this rift in our relationship with the medical community, and we're working hard to fix that."
 

Member
Joined
May 27, 2007
Messages
39,461
Tokens
Why? The cop was a jerkoff for not following procedure and making it personnel .

To be fair, he was following his police department procedures and she was following hospital procedures. The two policies didn't line up. Sounds like the PD policies were wrong.
 

Active member
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
94,348
Tokens
He was wrong. Other police should have stepped in. Nurses all across US are in uproar about this. I also know many doctors and nurses in ER's that would have stepped in and beat this douche down.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Jan 16, 2010
Messages
17,864
Tokens
To be fair, he was following his police department procedures and she was following hospital procedures. The two policies didn't line up. Sounds like the PD policies were wrong.
Well,his superior has now been suspended as well...

She did the right thing,kuddos to her. The cops I've talked to I know here agree with her as well...
 

Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2007
Messages
12,067
Tokens
He was wrong. Other police should have stepped in. Nurses all across US are in uproar about this. I also know many doctors and nurses in ER's that would have stepped in and beat this douche down.

a dr beat up a cop?
 

New member
Joined
Nov 21, 2013
Messages
5,412
Tokens
Seeing so many incidents of direct malfeasance by police officers nationwide it is ruefully horrifying to consider how often cops break the law when not being recorded and then lie their asses off at the expense of citizens
 

New member
Joined
Nov 21, 2013
Messages
5,412
Tokens
Seems they were very naive.

To play devil's advocate we should note the pertinent federal court rulings which protected the patient's privacy are barely a year old.

But the officer in question was specifically a supposed 'specialist' within the SLPD with regard to obtaining evidence via blood and other human body parts. To that end he is clearly derelict in duty and certainly worthy of the criminal charges brought against him yesterday
 

Member
Joined
May 27, 2007
Messages
39,461
Tokens
To play devil's advocate we should note the pertinent federal court rulings which protected the patient's privacy are barely a year old.

But the officer in question was specifically a supposed 'specialist' within the SLPD with regard to obtaining evidence via blood and other human body parts. To that end he is clearly derelict in duty and certainly worthy of the criminal charges brought against him yesterday

Did you read the article? It seems the department's "blood-draw policy" was incorrect based on the ruling we saw from the Supreme Court. He can use the "I followed department policy" excuse all he wants but if he were a specialist, he would've stepped in months ago to question the department policy to begin with.

The bottom line is the department policy was incorrect.
 

New member
Joined
Nov 21, 2013
Messages
5,412
Tokens
Did you read the article? It seems the department's "blood-draw policy" was incorrect based on the ruling we saw from the Supreme Court. He can use the "I followed department policy" excuse all he wants but if he were a specialist, he would've stepped in months ago to question the department policy to begin with.

The bottom line is the department policy was incorrect.

Yes, I read most of this yesterday.

Not uncommon for police agencies to be "behind the times" and thus worthy of some slack, but certainly less of an excuse in 2017 and seemingly moreso with a major city PD

One sincere upside of such dramatic fuckups in current times is that the news gets transmitted nationwide so quickly it should help prevent such errors in other locales
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Jan 20, 2002
Messages
6,927
Tokens
In some states including Florida the law says that the state has the right to take blood in case of an accident involving a fatality.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,106,765
Messages
13,438,754
Members
99,334
Latest member
mu88forum
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com