Tom Brady tops NFL starting QBs against the spread
David Purdum
Mike Phipps isn't included on many lists of all-time great NFL quarterbacks, but the 1970s signal-caller for the Cleveland Browns and Chicago Bears tops this one.
No quarterback in the Super Bowl era with at least 48 starts covered the spread more frequently than Phipps, according to ESPN Stats and Information research. In Phipps' 71 career starts, his teams covered the spread 62.0 percent of the time (44-24-3) during the regular season, despite a 55-108 touchdown-to-interception ratio. When it comes to exceeding the betting market's expectations, Phipps, the No. 3 overall pick in the 1970 NFL draft out of Purdue, is a top-tier quarterback.
Joe Montana is right behind behind Phipps. The San Francisco 49ers and Kansas City Chiefs covered the number in 61.6 percent of Montana's 101 starts during his Pro Football Hall of Fame career. Stan Humphries, who guided the San Diego Chargers to the 1995 Super Bowl, also is in the top tier of covering QBs at 60.5 percent, as is Tom Brady. The New England Patriots have covered the spread in 59.8 percent of Brady's 251 regular-season starts.
On the other side of the spectrum, Tony Eason, who quarterbacked the Patriots off and on in the 1980s, covered the spread in only 35.3 percent of his 51 starts (18-33 ATS). Rick Mirer and Jay Cutler join Eason on the bottom tier of covering QBs.
Using the point spread as a barometer, we separated every NFL starting QB into tiers based on performance against the number (minimum of 40 starts).
Elite tierNo quarterback in the Super Bowl era with at least 48 starts covered the spread more frequently than Phipps, according to ESPN Stats and Information research. In Phipps' 71 career starts, his teams covered the spread 62.0 percent of the time (44-24-3) during the regular season, despite a 55-108 touchdown-to-interception ratio. When it comes to exceeding the betting market's expectations, Phipps, the No. 3 overall pick in the 1970 NFL draft out of Purdue, is a top-tier quarterback.
Joe Montana is right behind behind Phipps. The San Francisco 49ers and Kansas City Chiefs covered the number in 61.6 percent of Montana's 101 starts during his Pro Football Hall of Fame career. Stan Humphries, who guided the San Diego Chargers to the 1995 Super Bowl, also is in the top tier of covering QBs at 60.5 percent, as is Tom Brady. The New England Patriots have covered the spread in 59.8 percent of Brady's 251 regular-season starts.
On the other side of the spectrum, Tony Eason, who quarterbacked the Patriots off and on in the 1980s, covered the spread in only 35.3 percent of his 51 starts (18-33 ATS). Rick Mirer and Jay Cutler join Eason on the bottom tier of covering QBs.
Using the point spread as a barometer, we separated every NFL starting QB into tiers based on performance against the number (minimum of 40 starts).
Highly profitable tier
- Andy Dalton, Cincinnati Bengals (61-44-4 ATS, 56.0 percent)
- Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers (79-61-2 ATS, 55.6 percent)
- Russell Wilson, Seattle Seahawks (53-41-2 ATS, 55.2 percent)
Still profitable tier
- Cam Newton, Caolina Panthers (59-47-2 ATS, 54.6 percent)
- Matt Ryan, Atlanta Falcons (85-71-2 ATS, 53.8 percent)
- Drew Brees, New Orleans Saints (133-108-7 ATS, 53.6 percent)
- Kirk Cousins, Minnesota Vikings (30-27-0 ATS, 52.6 percent)
No longer profitable tier (below 52.3 percent cover percentage)
- Ben Roethlisberger, Pittsburgh Steelers (103-92-3 ATS, 52.0 percent)
- Eli Manning, New York Giants (110-102-2 ATS, 51.4 percent)
- Blake Bortles, Jacksonville Jaguars (31-30-0 ATS, 50.8 percent)
Flip of the coin tier
- Derek Carr, Oakland Raiders (31-29-2 ATS, 50 percent)
- Philip Rivers, Los Angeles Chargers (96-93-3 ATS, 50 percent)
- Sam Bradford, Arizona Cardinals (40-40-0 ATS, 50 percent)
- Tyrod Taylor, Cleveland Browns (21-19-2 ATS, 50 percent)
Sinking ship tier
- Josh McCown, New York Jets (36-35-2 ATS, 49.3 percent)
- Joe Flacco, Baltimore Ravens (74-76-4 ATS, 48.1 percent)
- Marcus Mariota, Tennessee Titans (20-21-1 ATS, 47.6 percent)
- Ryan Fitzpatrick, Tampa Bay Buccaneers (56-61-2 ATS, 47.1 percent)
Bottom tier
Quarterbacks with fewer than 40 starts:
- Patrick Mahomes, Kansas City Chiefs (1-0-0 ATS, 100 percent)
- Jimmy Garoppolo, San Francisco 49ers (6-1-0 ATS, 85.7 percent)
- Deshaun Watson, Houston Texans (5-1-0 ATS, 83.3 percent)
- Teddy Bridgewater, New York Jets (22-6-0 ATS, 78.6 percent)
- AJ McCarron, Buffalo Bills (2-1-0 ATS, 66.7 percent)
- Carson Wentz, Philadelphia Eagles (18-11-0 ATS, 62.1 percent)
- Dak Prescott, Dallas Cowboys (18-12-2 ATS, 56.3 percent)
- Case Keenum, Denver Broncos (21-13-4 ATS, 55.3 percent)
- Mitchell Trubisky, Chicago Bears (6-4-2 ATS, 50 percent)
- Nick Foles, Philadelphia Eagles (16-22-1 ATS, 41.0 percent)
- Jared Goff, Los Angeles Rams (9-13-0 ATS, 40.9 percent)
