elie manning : no hall of fame !

barrystevensa90 · Jan 11, 2020

he's better than average, can't put everyone in hall of fame, it would get too big, lose it's meaning; thanks

r.a. · Jan 11, 2020

barrystevensa90 said:
he's better than average, can't put everyone in hall of fame, it would get too big, lose it's meaning; thanks

'elie' won't but Eli might ... quarterbacks who win 2 Superbowl's tend to get in.

Cireboy · Jan 11, 2020

r.a. said:
'elie' won't but Eli might ... quarterbacks who win 2 Superbowl's tend to get in.

Idk, I'm hoping 'elie' makes it too.

mango · Jan 11, 2020

r.a. said:
'elie' won't but Eli might ... quarterbacks who win 2 Superbowl's tend to get in.

Except Jim Plunkett.

DrJimmy · Jan 11, 2020

2-3 really good years. Shouldn’t get in but probably will.

Cireboy · Jan 11, 2020

It's not even a question, 2 super bowls seals the deal. Move on.

ashack1 · Jan 11, 2020

mango said:
Except Jim Plunkett.

Excellent example. I never was an Eli fan, but if they elected Kurt Warner, Eli should be an easy entrance.