Roberto Alamar or Joe Morgan - Who is the better Player???

wilheim · Apr 29, 2004

Bucky · Apr 29, 2004

Toy Cannon was a winner in my book.

barman · Apr 29, 2004

Is this a trick question?

Man, Bobby gets higher BA, but then you look at difference in OBP and you realize how Morgan made pitchers work so much harder....Double the power, double the class (sorry, one incident with the ump just lasts and lasts and lasts when it comes to PR).

wilheim · Apr 29, 2004

Barman, in a way it is a trick question. When I made the post, I figured that it would not get many (if any) replies because the thread actually has something to do with sports (but not gambling). Testing the waters if you know what I mean. I really hate to sell-out completely and start threads about medical conditions, or ways to spend disposable income etc.

wil.

jimbutorac · Apr 29, 2004

Gotta go with Joe Morgan. Robbie Alomar has done a fast fade at the tail end of his career. He had the talent to be a Hall of Famer, now I think he's borderline with odds on him not making it. Especially cause of his negative publicity.