NFL Instant REPLAY is VERY GOOD

Fishhead · Nov 28, 2004

Without question it is needed and a good thing for the NFL.

These officials need all the help they can get.

HacheMan · Nov 28, 2004

Exactly Fish, I cannot see the game without it now or in the future, and there's no need for teams to even vote on it anymore, it should be mandatory.....

Journeyman · Nov 28, 2004

It should be viewed in the booth instead of down on the field...the Big 10 does a better job

HacheMan · Nov 28, 2004

Journeyman said:
It should be viewed in the booth instead of down on the field...the Big 10 does a better job

J~Man, I believe firmly that the final decision always comes from upstairs anyhow. If you notice, the ref peeping into the replay screen is always talking with someone else, which I'm sure is upstairs. They get a better look at it anyhow up high I'm sure. Just no doubt in my mind the reviewing ref has no say on whether the plays stand or are reversed.......

Journeyman · Nov 28, 2004

If that's the case Hache then they could save alot of time, it makes absolutely no sense, the NFL has to trust the guy upstairs to get it right, its not that hard.

MrTeaser · Nov 28, 2004

How many college football games did we watch this year where you heard the phrase uttered "if this was the big ten the wrong call just made would have been changed"