ELI Manning Might be The Worst Rookie QB Ever

jjgold · Dec 12, 2004

I have never ever seen such a bad QB, he will be nothing like brother. Payton moved the ball as rookie at least.

Giant head coach made huge mistake ever playing him this year

Warner would of kept them in contention, he has to get fired, actually going to do worse than last years coach

What a disgrace

HacheMan · Dec 12, 2004

I've been saying all along that he will never live up to his expectations, his brother has set the bar much too high for him. I know it's a bit early to me so judgmental, but it's not like he doesn't have any weapons at all to work with....

GAMEFACE · Dec 12, 2004

Coach,

Don't forget Leaf. Leaf was having problems moving the ball in the flag league.

kermit16 · Dec 12, 2004

I heard a report on 1460 am here in Vegas that only two other QB in history had as low of QB rating in their first 3 games. Want to take a guess who they were ? Answer was Terry Bradshaw and Troy Aikman. So I guess I wouldn't be too quick to call him the next Flaky Leaf !

Journeyman · Dec 12, 2004

Give him time... BTW Giants just got a gift touchdown

HacheMan · Dec 12, 2004

Wasn't their only score last week off of a kick return??

Dante · Dec 12, 2004

pitiful....and he went ahead of Big ben....I agree the giants O line sucks..but this guy as no mobility to get out of trouble and makes Horrid decisions so far

MadCapper · Dec 12, 2004

wasnt even that good in college

kermit16 · Dec 12, 2004

Just remember.... Michael Jordan's Bulls didn't win a Championship for quite a few years either and Aikman's Cowboys were 1-15 in his first year.They weren't going to win no Super Bowl with Warner !

wilheim · Dec 12, 2004

Anyone remember Terry Bradshaw's rookie year? 13 games, 83 for 218 - 38.1% 1410 yards (less than 110 yards a game), 6 TDs and 24 INTs. Steelers were 5 and 9 on the season.

wil.

chalkeater · Dec 12, 2004

kermit16 said:
Just remember.... Michael Jordan's Bulls didn't win a Championship for quite a few years either and Aikman's Cowboys were 1-15 in his first year.They weren't going to win no Super Bowl with Warner !

They may not have been able to win a SB with Warner, but Warner made the games somewhat competitive.

Coughlin threw in the flag too soon.

Chalk

TheGeneral+ · Dec 12, 2004

I'm sure Eli will be working out with Big Bro in offseason. If he stays healthy, he will be a good QB in the NFL.

Matt24 · Dec 12, 2004

Starting him while the Giants were 5-4 had to be one of the worst decisions in sports of the year. Just stupid.

FairWarning · Dec 12, 2004

Isn't even the worst rookie to start a game this year. Title goes to Craig Krenzel. Brother Peyton was very ordinary in his rookie year. Giants need to upgrade their OL and receivers.

kermit16 · Dec 12, 2004

I agree with General on this one. Eli will be a very good QB given a little more time. Giants would have been 1 st. round and out anyway even if they did make the playoffs. Why not get the Rookie mistakes out of the way this year and maybe next year when they can upgrade their offensive line they will be a contender ! Was it really a horrible decision to start Aikman and Bradshaw their rookie years ? I think it will turn out to be a great decision in the long run. Time will tell !

jjgold · Dec 12, 2004

Eli does not have it, he is no where near being an NFL QB and he does not have insides to be winner

kermit16 · Dec 12, 2004

JJ
Bradshaw and Aikman were worse according to the report given on the radio show. I guess they didn't have it either ? Take a look at Bradshaw's stats for his first year which Wil just reported included 13 games ! Big Ben just might run into some problems when the playoffs start ! Time will tell.

jjgold · Dec 12, 2004

Kermer he is no Bradshaw.

Dont forget Terry and Troy played with great players which made them better than they really were.

Now Brady is an example of an unreal QB, very little talent around him

TheGeneral+ · Dec 12, 2004

JJ, If I win my $50 nfl wager today, I am going to play the ponies at The Mountains tonight. Will be looking for bombers.

jjgold · Dec 12, 2004

Peter I have never seen a worse performance by a qb today

ELI Manning Might be The Worst Rookie QB Ever

New member

hacheman@therx.com

New member

J-Man Rx NFL Pick 4 Champion for 2005

Banned

hacheman@therx.com

Active member

Veteran

J-Man Rx NFL Pick 4 Champion for 2005

New member

New member

Another Day, Another Dollar

New member

Official Rx music critic and beer snob

J-Man Rx NFL Pick 4 Champion for 2005

New member

J-Man Rx NFL Pick 4 Champion for 2005

New member

Another Day, Another Dollar

New member

Forum statistics

Share this page