Do playoff teams have an obligation to try?

Search

New member
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
75,154
Tokens
On the final Sunday night of the 1988 season, Phil Simms sat in his New Jersey home watching the Los Angeles Rams thrash the San Francisco 49ers 38-16, putting the Rams into the playoffs and knocking Simms and the Giants out.



''I'm sitting here watching the 49ers lie down like dogs,'' Simms told a caller as the 49ers played ... well, like pooches, allowing Joe Montana to be sacked nine times.

That is the scenario that is developing for next weekend, the final one of the 2004 regular season. Even if teams that have clinched everything play regulars, how motivated will they be?

It applies especially to two games.

1. Indianapolis at Denver. The Colts are locked in as the third-seeded team in the AFC playoffs, and Peyton Manning has his record for touchdown passes in a season. If the Broncos win, they make the playoffs, but if the Colts play less than their best, are they being fair to the teams with whom Denver is competing the Bills, Jaguars, Jets and Ravens?

2. Pittsburgh at Buffalo. The Steelers have clinched home-field in the AFC, have a bunch of injuries Ben Roethlisberger hurt his ribs Sunday and have nothing to play for. The Bills can make the playoffs if (see above) the Broncos lose and also could win a tiebreaker if the Jets should they lose in St. Louis.

In other words, what are the obligations of the Colts and Steelers? To ensure they are ready for the playoffs? Or to preserve the integrity of the playoff system by using their best players?

In most cases, it's the former the ''Me First'' attitude.

On Sunday, Atlanta rested Michael Vick, Alge Crumpler and T.J. Duckett in New Orleans after it had locked itself into the second seed in the NFC. With rookie Matt Schaub at QB for the Falcons, the Saints won 26-13 and remained alive in the NFC playoff hunt at 7-8, a result that can impact the Panthers, Vikings and Rams.

All three players were hurt, but might have played if the game meant something.

And while coach Jim Mora was very displeased on Monday, he did talk about Schaub, who had a chance to get his first NFL action always a positive with young quarterbacks.

Back when Simms was so miffed at the 49ers, the NFC dominated, and five teams in the conference finished 10-6. Two of them, the Giants and Saints, missed the playoffs.

When the 49ers played the Rams that Sunday night, they had clinched the NFC West and were the second-seeded team. They took the prudent approach and it worked they went on to win the Super Bowl.

''It didn't cost us any more than just a game,'' said Montana, who a month later led a late drive capped by a 10-yard TD pass to John Taylor with 34 seconds left to beat Cincinnati in the Super Bowl.

Momentum is one factor coaches consider.

In 1996, Denver was 12-1 when it clinched home-field advantage in the AFC with three games to go. It rested regulars, including John Elway and lost momentum its first game after the clinching was a 41-6 loss in Green Bay.

The Broncos then lost their first playoff game at home to Jacksonville, a second-year team that had lucked into the playoffs at 9-7 when Atlanta's Morten Andersen, who never missed in those days, missed a medium-range field goal.

The next season, Denver got in as a wild-card team ... and ended up winning the Super Bowl (just as those 1988 Giants won two years later, getting a measure of revenge by winning the NFC championship game in San Francisco.)

Some coaches play it straight both to keep momentum and, presumably, to be fair.

''We are playing too well to go up there and not win that football game,'' Pittsburgh coach Bill Cowher said of next week's game in Buffalo.

''We don't want to go into the playoffs with that sour taste in your mouth,'' he added.

The sour taste San Francisco got translated into an NFL title.

</WIRE_BODY>Dave Goldberg, Associated Press, 12/27/2004 16:17
 

Another Day, Another Dollar
Joined
Mar 1, 2002
Messages
42,730
Tokens
I think the thought and pressure of dealing with the fans, media, and maybe the front office IF a star player is injured in a meaningless game is to overwhelming for a coach to ignore.
 

Professional At All Times
Joined
Dec 3, 2003
Messages
42,732
Tokens
I think when a team has played itself into a position where it has earned the opportunity to protect many of it's starters from injuries prior to the playoffs and rest many of it's currently dinged players, it's obligation is to itself to do everything possible to be in the best physical position to make a run at the championship. Those teams that have struggled or are struggling to make the playoffs must take responsibility for their own predicament. The NFL is a profession not a charity.
 

hacheman@therx.com
Staff member
Joined
Jan 2, 2002
Messages
139,166
Tokens
oldmanTED said:
I think when a team has played itself into a position where it has earned the opportunity to protect many of it's starters from injuries prior to the playoffs and rest many of it's currently dinged players, it's oblipossible to be in the gation is to itself to do everything best physical position to make a run at the championship. Those teams that have struggled or are struggling to make the playoffs must take responsibility for their own predicament. The NFL is a profession not a charity.

No other way to put it besides the way Ted did above. Besides, I'm counting on Philly to do that exact thing tonight!:103631605
 

RX Senior
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
47,431
Tokens
The General said:
I think the thought and pressure of dealing with the fans, media, and maybe the front office IF a star player is injured in a meaningless game is to overwhelming for a coach to ignore.
I agree with this 100%. couldnt change a word. they would never hear the end of it.

im suprised reid isnt catching more flack for the owens debacle. only thing letting andy off the hook was dal was the clinching game.
 

There's always next year, like in 75, 90-93, 99 &
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
15,270
Tokens
Yes, but that doesn't mean you have to send it your superstars.
I'd expect these guys to compete any game, any time anywhere.
 

Another Day, Another Dollar
Joined
Mar 1, 2002
Messages
42,730
Tokens
I think the bench guys will try hard as they have alot to gain and little to lose, but the fact is the bench guys are typically just not as good as your starters, but the effort to win will be there. When the back-ups get down a TD or so though, they tend to realize they aren't that good and lose faith to early in the games.
 

Banned
Joined
Jun 25, 2002
Messages
4,684
Tokens
General just made a very profitable point.

Whichever team is losing at the half tonight is the team to bet against for a second half play.

I bet general did not even realize the little gold nugget he just posted. :suomi:
 

Another Day, Another Dollar
Joined
Mar 1, 2002
Messages
42,730
Tokens
No, I don't have many nuggets in NFL as displayed by my 20% win rate the last few years. :drink:
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,474
Messages
13,451,852
Members
99,417
Latest member
go789click
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com