if new england wins the super bowl and tom brady never plays another down would ...

WorldNumberOne · Jan 4, 2005

he still get into the hall of fame ?

another one would be kobe bryant . say this is his last year , would he get into the hall of fame ?

JimFiestSux · Jan 4, 2005

Kobe would be inducted into the "HALL OF SHAME"!

sherman · Jan 4, 2005

depends why brady didn't play again...

if it's cause he chose to be an actor or go smoke with ricky williams than no...

if he had a career ending injury, then yes........

winkyduck · Jan 4, 2005

NO

too short a career

he has to play about another 6-8 years-ish to make the HOF

WorldRunner · Jan 4, 2005

sherman said:
depends why brady didn't play again...

if it's cause he chose to be an actor or go smoke with ricky williams than no...

if he had a career ending injury, then yes........

That logic doesn't make any sense to me.

Retirement is retirement.

The reason for the retirement shouldn't have anything to do with it.

Also... The rule of thumb for the Hall is...If you have to debate whether or not someone belongs, they don't.

sherman · Jan 4, 2005

WorldRunner said:
That logic doesn't make any sense to me.

Retirement is retirement.

The reason for the retirement shouldn't have anything to do with it.

Also... The rule of thumb for the Hall is...If you have to debate whether or not someone belongs, they don't.

World Runner...it may not make sense, but if you go back and look you'll see that I am right....

WorldNumberOne · Jan 4, 2005

probably too short of a career . but what a run ..

WorldRunner · Jan 4, 2005

sherman said:
World Runner...it may not make sense, but if you go back and look you'll see that I am right....

Go back and look at what?

sherman · Jan 4, 2005

WorldRunner said:
Go back and look at what?

Look at the history of HOF.....some people have been voted in even though their numbers may not have justified it, but because their careers were cut short due to injury......

sherman · Jan 4, 2005

Three come to mind, I'm sure I can think of more....

Kirby Puckett
Dizzy Dean
Sandy Koufax

WorldRunner · Jan 4, 2005

sherman said:
Look at the history of HOF.....some people have been voted in even though their numbers may not have justified it, but because their careers were cut short due to injury......

Ok, I wasn't saying that you were wrong...I was just saying it shouldn't be that way.

It shouldn't matter why a player retires IMO.

jjgold · Jan 4, 2005

Brady is in Hall already even if he quit today

sherman · Jan 4, 2005

WorldRunner said:
Ok, I wasn't saying that you were wrong...I was just saying it shouldn't be that way.

It shouldn't matter why a player retires IMO.

World Runner....I agree with you 100%

sherman · Jan 4, 2005

jjgold said:
Brady is in Hall already even if he quit today

shouldn't be.

docmercer--banned · Jan 4, 2005

This is ridiculous ...

Brady in the hall of fame ... for what?

Ghees, one of the dominant rb of his time in his prime won a few SB rings and cant even sniff the Hall ....

Roger Craig of the 49ers

if new england wins the super bowl and tom brady never plays another down would ...

Search

WorldNumberOne

Self appointed RX World Champion Handicapper

JimFiestSux

Banned

sherman

International Playa

winkyduck

I am sorry for using the "R" word - and NOTHING EL

WorldRunner

Tireless Rebuttter

sherman

International Playa

WorldNumberOne

Self appointed RX World Champion Handicapper

WorldRunner

Tireless Rebuttter

sherman

International Playa

sherman

International Playa

WorldRunner

Tireless Rebuttter

jjgold

New member

sherman

International Playa

sherman

International Playa

docmercer--banned

Banned

Forum statistics

Share this page