OFFSHORE AMERICAN IDOL THREAD (ONLY ONE)

IDENTITY · Feb 15, 2005

Omg Vonzelle!!! (a.i.)

Green Dob - Did ya see Vonzelle sing tonight? OMG!!!!!! i called it!!!! vonzelle and tucker!!!! last 2 standing!!!!!

constantin and underwood will make it far cuz of what they look like.

hope you watched.

GreenDoberman · Feb 16, 2005

Another very solid showing for Vonzelle. She definitely solidified her top 12 status. They didn't show a lot on Tuesday and imagine they are holding some people back for the top 24.

I will have my updated odds of the 44 remaining posted shortly.

GreenDoberman · Feb 16, 2005

Not many surprises of the people eliminated. Of the early contenders, only the overhyped Dezmond Meeks was shown the door.

GreenDoberman · Feb 16, 2005

Updated American Idol Odds to Win: Final 44

Odds to win outright (as of 2/16/05) prior to Wednesday's telecast of final 24.

6/1
David Brown
Vonzell Solomon
Carrie Underwood

7/1
Mario Vazquez

8/1
Anwar Robinson
Amanda Avila

10/1
Travis Tucker
Nathan Herron

15/1
Constantine Maroulis
Anthony Federov
Janay Castine

20/1
Sarah Mather
Nadia Turner
Judd Harris

25/1
Scott Savol
Osborne Smith, Jr.
Jaclyn Crum
Lindsey Cardinale
Tammy Wynette Nash

30/1
Ian Holmes
Rachel Leslie

35/1
Melinda Lira
Aloha Mischeaux

40/1
Yolanda McIntosh
John Zisa
Kim Holloway

50/1
Faith Gatewood
Ivan Ganchev
Bo Bice
Celena Batchelor
Antoine Crymes
Joseph Murena, Jr.

60/1
Donnie Williams
Jessica Sierra
DeAndre Perryman
Warren Nolan

75/1
J.P. Koehler
Gina McFadden
J.R. Aquino
Erinn Furey
Jared Yates

100/1
Mikalah Gordon
Matthew Kester

250/1
Davon Jefferson

aceduecetrey · Feb 16, 2005

Who is the black mail delivery girl?

GreenDoberman · Feb 16, 2005

My picks for the top 23 announced Wednesday, 2/16/05.
(12 male, 12 female) -with percentage chance I think they make top 24

Male-
David Brown (99%)
Mario Vazquez (95%)
Anwar Robinson (95%)
Travis Tucker (90%)
Nathan Herron (80%)
Constantine Maroulis (85%)
Anthony Federov (75%)
Judd Harris (65%)
Scott Savol (75%)
Osbourne Smith, Jr. (70%)
John Zisa (55%)
Ian Holmes (50%)

Female-
Vonzell Solomon (99%)
Carrie Underwood (98%)
Amanda Avila (90%)
Janay Castine (85%)
Sarah Mather (80%)
Nadia Turner (80%)
Jaclyn Crum (75%)
Lindsey Cardinale (75%)
Rachel Leslie (65%)
Tammy Wynette Nash (55%)
Mikalah Gordon (50%)
Celena Batchelor (40%)

As always there will likely be one or two unknowns that make it in towards the bottom of the lists, but those are my best guesses.

ID, can you give me a projected top 24? (Anybody else as well) :suomi:

GreenDoberman · Feb 16, 2005

ADT,

that's Vonzell, she's the odds-on female favorite currently.

GreenDoberman · Feb 16, 2005

And ID's pick to win it all from the beginning.

thesteammaker · Feb 16, 2005

I like the mail girl as well to win.with the spanish guy 2nd

aceduecetrey · Feb 16, 2005

thanks

HacheMan · Feb 16, 2005

Doberman, it still surprises me that you still underestimate Mario Vazquez just a "bit". We've seen none yet this year that can put it out like he can.The guy has serious...... serious talent.........

Kiss1 · Feb 16, 2005

What's the ugly large white kids name .... I think he has a solid shot.

GreenDoberman · Feb 16, 2005

Hache,

I wouldn't say having him as the 2nd chalk is underestimating him at all. He's the #2 male listed and is very talented.

Kiss,
the big kid is Scott Savol, currently at 25/1. He's got some serious chops, but I think his look and his character may hurt him sooner, if not later.

WorldNumberOne · Feb 16, 2005

anwar robinson is the best of the bunch .

but i also thought latoya london should have won last year too..

Kiss1 · Feb 16, 2005

GreenDoberman said:
Kiss,
the big kid is Scott Savol, currently at 25/1. He's got some serious chops, but I think his look and his character may hurt him sooner, if not later.

:monsters-

I think that kid is top 10 .... Maybe higher, his mug might get him some sympathy votes. Where are you getting these odds ?

The last time a played an entertainment prop was at intertops regarding Big Brother, it was a lock but the limits were tiny if I remember right.

HacheMan · Feb 16, 2005

Doberman, sorry about that, I know having him ranked where you do isn't necessarily underestimating him, just meant that I think it's very evident so far that he is easily the most talented, BASED on what we've seen that is. In the end though I suppose it doesn't matter what any of us think as it will be America who decides..............(Well, so they say......:movingeye

assassin · Feb 16, 2005

tonights show is just mean.

aceduecetrey · Feb 16, 2005

I think it is kinda funny. Did you see that black girl flip out? Hilarious.

Lawrence · Feb 16, 2005

"i have no life to go back to...wah wah wah"...really funny

assassin · Feb 16, 2005

It didn't say I wasn't entertained.
It was fun for me, and I'm guessing big ratings, but then again society does seem to relish the hardships of others. Myself included.

Now we are ready for some real competition.