McGwire and Palmeiro...HOF , Yes or No, please give your vote?

Journeyman · Apr 11, 2005

I will still be voting for both once eligible

Big Mac Yes

Raffy Yes

Ego74 · Apr 11, 2005

Journeyman said:
I will still be voting for both once eligible

Big Mac Yes

Raffy Yes

you're a member of the media, J Man??

royalfan · Apr 11, 2005

mcgwire for sure
palmeiro probably also

Dawoofdaddy · Apr 11, 2005

Big Mac For Sure
Palmeiro No Opinion

stomie · Apr 11, 2005

<TABLE cellSpacing=1 cellPadding=0 width=573 bgColor=#333333 border=0><TBODY><TR class=textSm align=middle bgColor=#666666><TD width=34> </TD><TD width=35>G</TD><TD width=35>AB</TD><TD width=35>R</TD><TD width=35>H</TD><TD width=30>2B</TD><TD width=30>3B</TD><TD width=30>HR</TD><TD width=35>RBI</TD><TD width=35>TB</TD><TD width=35>BB</TD><TD width=35>SO</TD><TD width=30>SB</TD><TD width=30>CS</TD><TD width=30>OBP</TD><TD width=30>SLG</TD><TD width=30>AVG</TD></TR><TR class=textXs align=middle bgColor=#999999><TD align=middle bgColor=#ffffff>2005</TD><TD>6</TD><TD>19</TD><TD>1</TD><TD>6</TD><TD>0</TD><TD>0</TD><TD>0</TD><TD>3</TD><TD>6</TD><TD>3</TD><TD>2</TD><TD>1</TD><TD>0</TD><TD>.391</TD><TD>.316</TD><TD>.316</TD></TR><TR class=textXs align=middle bgColor=#999999><TD bgColor=#ffffff>Career</TD><TD>2727</TD><TD>10122</TD><TD>1617</TD><TD>2928</TD><TD>572</TD><TD>38</TD><TD>551</TD><TD>1778</TD><TD>5229</TD><TD>1313</TD><TD>1307</TD><TD>96</TD><TD>40</TD><TD>.372</TD><TD>.517</TD><TD>.289</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>

Journeyman · Apr 11, 2005

How can you not have Raffy, the guys numbers are amzing, and he may end up with 600 homeruns, like i said on here 3 years ago...

600 doubles, 1900+ RBI, 600 HR's, over 3000 hits....He has to be the quietest guy to have great stats in the games history!

Soon to be the 4th member of the 3000 hit/500 HR Club

stomie · Apr 11, 2005

If Ozzie Smith can get in so can Palmeiro

GreenDoberman · Apr 11, 2005

I'd vote in Fred McGriff before I even considered either of them.

Schleppboy · Apr 11, 2005

Yes and yes no doubt, innocent to proven guilty

aceduecetrey · Apr 11, 2005

stomie said:
If Ozzie Smith can get in so can Palmeiro

wtf is your problem with letting the greatest shortstop ever to play the game in the HOF?

aceduecetrey · Apr 11, 2005

GreenDoberman said:
I'd vote in Fred McGriff before I even considered either of them.

Why? Dont tell me because Crime dogg never used roids, because you dont know that for sure.

lander · Apr 11, 2005

No. They're both lower than Joe Jackson and Pete Rose combined.

aceduecetrey · Apr 11, 2005

lander said:
No. They're both lower than Joe Jackson and Pete Rose combined.

Coming from a guy who has Bonds on his fantasy team........

cincy_ · Apr 11, 2005

... because of the steroids crap, I will WATCH baseball but I could care less about the HOF anymore

... and if McGuire gets in, that will really piss me off - especially since people like Jim Rice and Fred McGriff are more deserving.

aceduecetrey · Apr 11, 2005

cincy_hugg said:
... because of the steroids crap, I will WATCH baseball but I could care less about the HOF anymore

... and if McGuire gets in, that will really piss me off - especially since people like Jim Rice and Fred McGriff are more deserving.

How do you know Jim Rice and Fred Mcgriff did not use roids?

Journeyman · Apr 11, 2005

Freddie will make it guys...Why is everyone assuming he wont get in, he still has to wait 5 years...McGriff is a lock.

cincy_ · Apr 11, 2005

aceduecetrey said:
How do you know Jim Rice and Fred Mcgriff did not use roids?

You have a point - and that is why I don't care about the HOF anymore. Baseball is so full of sh!t, its pitiful.

... and before you ask me any more questions, I want you to remember that I don't want to talk about the past.

Kick all those SOBs out and put Pete Rose in - at least we know he didn't use roids because all his phone calls were tapped when they were on him for gambling.

cincy_ · Apr 11, 2005

Journeyman said:
600 doubles, 1900+ RBI, 600 HR's, over 3000 hits....He has to be the quietest guy to have great stats in the games history!

QUIET?

How can a guy pimpin' Viagra be called quiet????

He's probably moaning right now.

Journeyman · Apr 11, 2005

Rice played in the 1970's when 46 homeruns (which he hit in his MVP year) were a ton of homers, of course he did that in Fenway too....

What's amazing about Rice, he never hit more than 20 homers in a season after age 32!

Rice was on the serious decline by age 33....

aceduecetrey · Apr 11, 2005

My argument is that since steroids were invented in 1959 and we have no idea who may have used them since then, it is not fair to bash the guys that are the main suspects. I say we start with Maris who hit 61 two years after steroids were first invented.