Who is the greatest shortstop in baseball history?

TheGeneral+ · May 2, 2005

Vote in TheRx.com poll here....

Bottom right corner
<TABLE cellSpacing=1 cellPadding=2 width="100%"><TBODY><TR align=left><TD vAlign=top colSpan=2></TD></TR><TR><TD></TD><TD></TD></TR><TR><TD vAlign=top align=left width=0></B></TD><TD width="100%">Ernie Banks</TD></TR><TR><TD vAlign=top align=left width=0></B></TD><TD width="100%">Honus Wagner</TD></TR><TR><TD vAlign=top align=left width=0></B></TD><TD width="100%">Alex Rodriquez</TD></TR><TR><TD vAlign=top align=left width=0></B></TD><TD width="100%">Cal Ripken</TD></TR><TR><TD vAlign=top align=left width=0></B></TD><TD width="100%">Ozzie Smith</TD></TR><TR><TD vAlign=top align=left width=0></B></TD><TD width="100%">Other (write-in)</TD></TR><TR><TD></TD><TD></TD></TR><TR><TD align=middle colSpan=2></TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>

http://www.therx.com/

aceduecetrey · May 2, 2005

For me it is OZZIE!!

I am just somewhat biased though

JudgeWapner · May 2, 2005

Honus. Shrink told me he was amazing, and he saw him play.

CHOPTALK · May 2, 2005

Arod, when he was playing there.

cadillacman · May 2, 2005

I like Omar Vizquel.

FairWarning · May 2, 2005

No love for Don Kessinger?

kermit16 · May 2, 2005

Judge Wapner said:
Honus. Shrink told me he was amazing, and he saw him play.

LOL

arty:

kermit16 · May 2, 2005

Ozzie by a mile !

MillenniumSportsbook · May 2, 2005

Defensively, there was none better than the wizard!

RPM · May 2, 2005

guess im a homer but i would have to say ripken.

TheGeneral+ · May 2, 2005

Current

<TABLE cellSpacing=1 cellPadding=2 width="90%" align=center border=0><TBODY><TR vAlign=top align=left><TD class=Questions colSpan=3>Who is the greatest shortstop in baseball history?</TD></TR><TR vAlign=top align=left><TD class=Answers width="33%">Ernie Banks</TD><TD width="7%">

</TD><TD class=Percentages width="62%">

(17.86%)</TD></TR><TR vAlign=top align=left><TD class=Answers width="33%">Honus Wagner</TD><TD width="7%">

</TD><TD class=Percentages width="62%">

(32.14%)</TD></TR><TR vAlign=top align=left><TD class=Answers width="33%">Alex Rodriquez</TD><TD width="7%">

</TD><TD class=Percentages width="62%">

(10.71%)</TD></TR><TR vAlign=top align=left><TD class=Answers width="33%">Cal Ripken</TD><TD width="7%">

</TD><TD class=Percentages width="62%">

(16.07%)</TD></TR><TR vAlign=top align=left><TD class=Answers width="33%">Ozzie Smith</TD><TD width="7%">

</TD><TD class=Percentages width="62%">

(19.64%)</TD></TR><TR vAlign=top align=left><TD class=Answers width="33%">Other (write-in)</TD><TD width="7%">

</TD><TD class=Percentages width="62%">

(3.57%)</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>

http://www.therx.com/

blueedwards · May 2, 2005

no way ripken should be on this list. the guy had a few good offensive years and was never a great defensive player. if it wasn't for the streak...no one would even talk about him.

robin yount was better.

sherman · May 2, 2005

Cal Ripken? Cmon, whoever thinks that hasn't really been watching baseball the past 25 years...

Journeyman · May 2, 2005

that's funny, Cal wasn't a good efensive player...I don't care for Ripken really but he was a great fielder! Whatever hit his glove stayed in it, and he had a great and accurate arm....You won't understand Ripken's greatness unless you watched him daily....He wasn't a great hitter though...

This isn't even close, Honus Wagner is by far the greatest shortstop.

blueedwards · May 2, 2005

Journeyman said:
that's funny, Cal wasn't a good efensive player...I don't care for Ripken really but he was a great fielder! Whatever hit his glove stayed in it, and he had a great and accurate arm....You won't understand Ripken's greatness unless you watched him daily....He wasn't a great hitter though...

he didn't make errors...i'll give you that. but his range was nothing special. and that is the most important thing a shortstop can have.

take guys like ozzie smith and omar vizquel...they take away so many hits/year you could argue that their teams get 5-7 extra wins a season because of their defense.

i'd put ripken's defensive skills around the level of an a-rod...who was moved to third base...just like cal.

Journeyman · May 2, 2005

Cal led the league in assists and chances on several occasions...committed 3 errors for the whole season once, and holds the record for most consecutive games without an error at shortstop....I would never say Ripken is an Ozzie Smith or a Vizquel, but he was a much better hitter than those too...he never seemed to be a great hitter though, he was a much better fielder than most will realize....his brother Billy was an outstanding glove man as well...both with great hands....he did hit 431 homers with over 3000 hits and batted .340 at age 38, and was a two time MVP....I wouldn't put Yount ahead of him but its arguable either way..Yount played half his career in centerfield though.

MrTeaser · May 2, 2005

This is the classic debate on how you measure greatness. Is greatness having a great run for a 8 year period or a good run for a 16 year period? Cal fits the latter. His longevity is what made him. He never put together a string of very good years. I was never a Cal Ripken fan. Take away his 2 best offensive seasons and you have a pretty good offensive player....nothing else. Jman does have a point though his defense was very underrated.

sherman · May 2, 2005

because someone doesnt make errors doesnt mean they are a good fielder..not saying ripken wasnt but that alone means nothing....if your getting to less balls, chances are you are going to make less errors...

one9 · May 2, 2005

Dave Concepcion

sherman · May 2, 2005

jackie gutierrez

just playin....

Who is the greatest shortstop in baseball history?

Another Day, Another Dollar

Member

Member

Member

And so it goes......

Official Rx music critic and beer snob

J-Man Rx NFL Pick 4 Champion for 2005

J-Man Rx NFL Pick 4 Champion for 2005

New member

OG

Another Day, Another Dollar

in your heart, you know i'm right

International Playa

Banned

in your heart, you know i'm right

Banned

New member

International Playa

New member

International Playa

Forum statistics

Share this page