The best football game EVER is the ESPN 2K5.I have played Madden and NCAA football every year since they started and while they've had some good versions,nothing compares to 2K5! I totally agree with what you guys are saying about too many extras,EA Sports is taking away from whats important(realistic gameplay) by adding whats not important(features nobody cares about)
I really hated to hear that EA bought ALL rights for the football games(and others) which means no ESPN game this year :-( Trust me guys,if you haven't played the 2k5 yet,buy it! Will be very cheap as its a year old and you won't be sorry!
EA also screwed up their NBA Live 2005 this year,it is nowhere even close to NBA 2004.I will never throw out 2004,it is that good!