My guess is they would have won 2 of the 3 they did win. He is at his best in a all or nothing game where he will take off and lay it out for yardage, not great for a long career but good for cashing the game. They have a playoff team most likely and he needs to hold back until his team needs him to take the hits.
Vick couldn't have taken over for Trent Dilfer and won a Super Bowl.
Also, once you take a BIG chunk of the salary cap and put it in your pocket, don't cry about not having the players around you. If the Pats had Vick (with his salary), they might not have had Corey Dillon or Rodney Harrison or Will McGinest.
Also, once you take a BIG chunk of the salary cap and put it in your pocket, don't cry about not having the players around you. If the Pats had Vick (with his salary), they might not have had Corey Dillon or Rodney Harrison or Will McGinest.
CHOPTALK said:
Michael Vick = ALL GAS AND NO EXPLOSION = the most overrated player in the NFL.
What can Vick do well?
Can he read blitzes? Not until last year - see how the Eagles made his head spin.
Can he throw a 15-20 yard pass consistantly? No. He will overthrow a receiver by 10 yards sometimes.
Can he call his own offense during a 2 minute drill? No.
So he runs well - whoopie - so could Barry Sanders.
Would Baltimore have won a Super Bowl with Barry Sanders at QB?
Wake me up when Vick wins a big game.
i dong think it would have happened...i think part of brady's success is his mindset...he seems to take every game like a game that he has to prove his worth...vick is the opposite, i love vick, but watch the way he carries himself, and you see his ego in everything he does...i just think brady's success is his approach!
cincy_ said:
Beats Green Bay at Green Bay when the Pack was picked by many to go to the SuperBowl.
Wake me up when Manning wins a big game. College or Pro. Just because you dont win it all does not mean you are no good.
Does this mean that Trent Dilfer is a better QB than Dan Marino?
CHOPTALK said:
Marino is better than Dilfer - but let me assure you that Michael Vick is not even close to being a Dan Marino. If you want to talk about a QB who is like Vick, please bring someone up in the same class - Vick will never be half the QB that Marino was.
As for Manning, he can't win because he didn't have a defense - and he didn't have a defense because his cap number was $18 million. Brady signed for close to a $8 million cap number this year, so in my eyes, if you take the contract into consideration, I would take Brady over Manning EVERYDAY because I would get 2 starters and a Pro-Bowler for that extra $10 million.
I won't even compare Vick to Manning or Brady until Vick shows me something besides quick feet. Like I said, ALL GAS AND NO EXPLOSION.
