Eli not as good as peyton?

primetime21+ · Nov 13, 2005

I know its early, but peyton was far more impressive his first 2 years. Manning always had his completion Pct above 60 percent and had a 4,000 yard passing season in his second year. Eli still looks lost out there for large chungs of the game. And outside of a couple of late game winning drives he hasnt been all theimpressive in most of the giant wins.

Dante · Nov 13, 2005

today I agree Eli is very shakey...looks like Dog poop

RobFunk · Nov 13, 2005

Peyton is a much fiercer competitor. Even his dad said it.

primetime21+ · Nov 13, 2005

He has looked like that in alot of games this year. But then he comes back and pulls a big drive out of his ass to win. Again, it may not be fair, but any comparison to peyton looks like a joke at this point.

RobFunk · Nov 13, 2005

wow that last pass attempt to wide open burress was just awful. not even close

RobFunk · Nov 13, 2005

this giants game is just excruciating to watch

primetime21+ · Nov 13, 2005

and his second pickoff down by the goal line today. He just looks a little too lost for a second year QB against a minnesota team that is doing its best to give away the game.