One Issue That Has Bothered Me for a While...

Search

For G-Baby
Joined
Oct 22, 2004
Messages
18,919
Tokens
I was discussing this with RobFunk last night, and concluded that I'd make a post about it just to get it off my chest:

As much as I love the forums here, one thing has bothered me from the minute I joined the RX: posters creating threads with picks that include NO RECORD TO DATE. How many threads do you see on a regular basis that are from obscure posters that just say, "I LOVE SACRAMENTO -4.5 TONIGHT!! EASY WINNER!!" Or some bullshit along those lines? Any Joe Blow can come on here and post a play with no record; it's meaningless.

I feel the need to point it out now because it seems like everyday, more and more new posters are joining and tailing others. Also, it seems like everyday some new poster creates a thread asking "who's the best CBB capper?" or something along those lines. Simply forcing people to post a record to date along with their play(s) would ensure that no newbie looking to tail a hot capper would lose $ on some bullshit poster claiming that something is a "lock," and it'd also help maintain some credibility on the forums. If Joe Blow posts "Miami +4.5 is a SURE WINNER!" and they lose, then come back a week later and post the same type of bullshit, no one's gonna remember that past pick. They're just gonna see some large, bold font claiming that for tonight, the Lakers are a sure thing!

If people HAD to post an accurate record to date, it'd be beneficial to all parties. I know the RX has a tracker forum, but lets be realistic here, not many people know about or even look at it on a regular basis. And I know that some great cappers(Action, Kapusta off the top of my head) don't post their record in their thread, but maybe they should too. That way, we wouldn't have a thread a day made asking who the best are; it'd be right in every single thread that has picks for anyone to see. Action and Kapusta are great; their records SHOULD be posted front and center for everyone to see. And if there are any questions regarding the accuracy of someone's record, one can always go back to their previous threads(something that I know people can do now, but honestly, hardly any newbie or anyone else is gonna do that).

This would also help get rid of the extraneous garbage threads that always flood the forum pages.

Am I the only one that is irked by this crap? I know RobFunk agrees, but does anyone else even notice or care? Just felt like throwing it out there...just something I've noticed. Alright, back to the TV, Full House is almost on!!! Holler!
 

in your heart, you know i'm right
Joined
Mar 21, 2002
Messages
14,785
Tokens
people pad their records all the time...then you have other guys coming in and saying, "your went 3-4 yesterday...not 4-3...". then they argue about how it was a lean and not a play...or they got a better line from their local, etc.

posted records mean nothing. everyone knows who the good cappers are.
 

" Thanks for tip Bricktop "
Joined
Jun 28, 2005
Messages
11,367
Tokens
Record posting to date

0-0

:dancefool

If that was my record with my bookie however, I'd be much better off right now.

:cryingcry
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
28,775
Tokens
We do have the tracker forum for those who would like to document their records.

As far as the sports forums, I'd hate to see anything that would cut down on the free flow of information. There are a lot of threads that contain great info and angles that many others may not be aware of. When people post this kind of stuff, do we really want to force them to decide whether it's an "official play" for them? I don't think so. Everyone is welcome to include their YTD records in their threads.

If people are jumping on picks from Joe Newbie just because he says that it's a lock, there isn't really much that we can do for them. Like everything else in life, you live & learn who is legit & who is full of shit.

Just my (vocal as usual) opinion

Keep picking those winners Skins!!
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,305
Tokens
Man oh man!!!!! Do I agree with this!!!!!!!!!!!

To have any cred whatsoever you must post your record!!! Anyone who does not post a record does not get one thought from me.

Another thing I cant stand is a newbie comes in and says hes 29-5 on his last 34 plays and decieded to start helping people out because hes so hot. The next day when they post there record they ad the 29-5 part that was never posted on the forums.



I think what THERX should do is post the YTD records from the tracker forum as a sticky at each respective sports forum insteed of having one thread in the tracker room.

In the Baseball forum put the Tracker records at the top of the baseball forum. BASKETBALL,FOOTBALL, etc.... Where everyone is viewing them. And come up with some way to encourage everyone to post in the Tracker Room. Maybe a $300 dollar bonus from a sportsbook or something to the winner. Anything to encourage turnout.
 

Active member
Joined
Oct 20, 1999
Messages
75,444
Tokens
Every couple days I mention the TRACKER FORUM in one of the respective sports forums.

On that note, I agree with what TTinCO said in his previous post.

-FISH-
 

New member
Joined
Jun 20, 2001
Messages
4,398
Tokens
wouldn't be good for RX traffic to post records. Most would be unpleasently surprised how bad they are and either quit posting or comeback with a new NAME.:puppy:
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,305
Tokens
Fishhead said:
Every couple days I mention the TRACKER FORUM in one of the respective sports forums.

On that note, I agree with what TTinCO said in his previous post.

-FISH-


What about putting a sticky in each respective forum? This would create traffic and encourage everyone to post in the tracker room.
 

Rx. Junior
Joined
Jun 24, 2005
Messages
4,632
Tokens
Raj i see you point.

But just for argument's sake...

Why should a known solid capper like Kap, micelli, action, railbird, Ace Ace, etc...be or even feel obligated to do so? They don't even have to post plays if they don't want. But they do, to help others out.

Like Blue mention, it can cause problems and unnecessary arguments for htese guys because people consider a lean of theirs a play, or the line or whatever.

It might suck for a newbie to come see a "Lock" post like you described and get burned on it. But I guess you gotta learn from your mistakes, rather than have people feel obligated to all the record keeping and whatever else that goes along with posting a record.

Not really saying i agree or disagree with you...just wanted to point out my view of the other side.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,305
Tokens
jwunderdog said:
wouldn't be good for RX traffic to post records. Most would be unpleasently surprised how bad they are and either quit posting or comeback with a new NAME.:puppy:

Good riddance. Weed out the trash. There are about about 8 to 10 good cappers in each sport. You have about 100 different people posting plays in each sport. I think the lurkers would much prefer reading 8 to 10 good people insteed of weeding through the trash.

The 300 post min for the tracker forum helps eliminate the ghost problem.
 

Self appointed RX World Champion Handicapper
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
15,052
Tokens
why would anything anybody does in public gambling forum bother anybody else ?

in the grand scheme of things , who really gives a shit..

roll with it ...

the only threads in this forum that truly matter are the ones that discuss slow pays and which books are struggling.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,305
Tokens
roach23 said:
Raj i see you point.

But just for argument's sake...

Why should a known solid capper like Kap, micelli, action, railbird, Ace Ace, etc...be or even feel obligated to do so? They don't even have to post plays if they don't want. But they do, to help others out.

Like Blue mention, it can cause problems and unnecessary arguments for htese guys because people consider a lean of theirs a play, or the line or whatever.

It might suck for a newbie to come see a "Lock" post like you described and get burned on it. But I guess you gotta learn from your mistakes, rather than have people feel obligated to all the record keeping and whatever else that goes along with posting a record.

Not really saying i agree or disagree with you...just wanted to point out my view of the other side.


Every single really good capper at this forum that I know of post there YTD record. All the above people you mentioned do this.

You never see Bucsfan,Tommorows Newspaper, ACE-ACE, Kapusa,Action, Journeyman, Fishhead, OMT not post a year to date record. Why, because they are good. They have nothing to be ashamed of.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,305
Tokens
World Number One said:
why would anything anybody does in public gambling forum bother anybody else ?

in the grand scheme of things , who really gives a shit..

roll with it ...

the only threads in this forum that truly matter are the ones that discuss slow pays and which books are struggling.

This place gets more traffic from people making picks than any other thing on this forum. This place would die if it was not for the cappers. Thats the problem with the new place accross the street. There picks forum is dead. Therefore there forum is dead.

The picks forums are the lifeblood of this site.
 

Active member
Joined
Jun 20, 2000
Messages
71,780
Tokens
roach23 said:
Raj i see you point.

But just for argument's sake...

Why should a known solid capper like Kap, micelli, action, railbird, Ace Ace, etc...be or even feel obligated to do so? They don't even have to post plays if they don't want. But they do, to help others out.

Like Blue mention, it can cause problems and unnecessary arguments for htese guys because people consider a lean of theirs a play, or the line or whatever.

It might suck for a newbie to come see a "Lock" post like you described and get burned on it. But I guess you gotta learn from your mistakes, rather than have people feel obligated to all the record keeping and whatever else that goes along with posting a record.

Not really saying i agree or disagree with you...just wanted to point out my view of the other side.
post of the year! the sheer bottom line is WE all choose WHO we follow and WHEN and if it wins or loses its OUR FAULT that we followed them NO ONE ELSE to blame...its very simple but as fishface said there is the tracker forum alrady for those that want to go that route
 

Triple digit silver kook
Joined
Mar 1, 2005
Messages
13,697
Tokens
Unless somebody is crowing about how great they are, I dont give a rats ass whether or not posters provide their YTD.

Usually, the posters who flame about how great they are find plenty of critics here. Thus, their threads are soon thereafter sent to the rubber room.

I didnt post a ytd in football and had a great year. Anyone who read my weekly threads would know that. I have maintained ytd for hoops and am slightly under 50%.

Regular posters here know who is winning, losing, and padding their capping skills. As long as posters are not allowed to past post games and/or bullshit lines, anything else should be acceptable.

:realtongu
 

Self appointed RX World Champion Handicapper
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
15,052
Tokens
World Number One said:
why would anything anybody does in public gambling forum bother anybody else ?

in the grand scheme of things , who really gives a shit..

roll with it ...

the only threads in this forum that truly matter are the ones that discuss slow pays and which books are struggling.



disagree dante .. this is the post of year..
 

New member
Joined
Jun 20, 2001
Messages
4,398
Tokens
"Every single really good capper at this forum that I know of post there YTD record. All the above people you mentioned do this.

You never see Bucsfan,Tommorows Newspaper, ACE-ACE, Kapusa,Action, Journeyman, Fishhead, OMT not post a year to date record. Why, because they are good. They have nothing to be ashamed of."

Kapusta posted a record up until about 3 weeks ago, when someone pointed out how off the record was. Haven't seen him post a record since. Action wasn't posting a record last year, don't know if he does this year or not.<!-- / message -->
 

New member
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
6,480
Tokens
While I agree with SkinsRaj28 and Ttinco makes excellent points you simply cannot force anyone to do anything.

When the tracking folder was started I thought the idea was to post picks in the tracker and commentary in the relevant sports folder. A few do this.

So the tracking folder speaks for itself while elsewhere, in the sports forums, its caveat emptor.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,623
Messages
13,453,005
Members
99,426
Latest member
bodyhealthtechofficia
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com