I think he's one of the, if not the, best hitter/fielder in baseball. His hitting isn't nearly as good as the likes of Pujols, Lee, Manny but his fielding is exponentially better than Manny and while Pujols does fine at 1st and Lee is a gold-glover, Andruw is the #1 defensive center fielder in the game and has been for nearly a decade.
If only he could hit consistently for average...