Clip Joint said:Lidge hands down...not even close.
CHOPTALK said:I think he has a very strong mental makeup, and thats the most important thing that a closer can have.
Clip Joint said:I disagree completely...his mental make up is why he was a great set up man. He has never proven he had the mental make up to be a closer. He had 1 good season and melted under pressure.
He has never been the same. He can't get an out.