goodcall said:
I'd take Abreu over Howard or Utley if we're picking one from Philly
You obviouslly haven't been watching the Phillies this year.
Utlely and RyHow are hitting better than Bobby. Both for average and power. Bobby has about 5 more RBI's that Utley but Utley is batting int he 2 spot. And the Phillies have a leadoff hitter with one of the worst OBPs in the league.
Bobby is a dog in the field. He doesn't run hard after fly balls and is a puss who's afraid to go into the wall to make a play. And Bobby has ARod #s...as in Bobbys stats are inflated by hitting homers and getting RBIs when the Phillies are already winning by a few runs. Besides for the game winning homer vs the Dodgers...Bobby hasn't had a clutch hit this season. He looks to walk first, hit second....even in the clutch.
The reason i pick Utley over RyHow is that Utley is the leader of the team. He hustles. He's clutch (not saying RyHow isnt). He's a better fielder. He'd have better RBI #s if he was batting 3rd or 4th, but he accepted the 2 spot (something Abreau wouldn't do when he was asked to bat lead off....he doesn't want to hurt his personal stats by batting anywhere but the 3 or 4 spot, even if it'll help the team win).