OT: Is there a "rule of thumb" when making an offer on a house?

Search

Home of the Cincinnati Criminals.
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
19,500
Tokens
I have heard 20% below asking prices. Which I think sounds reasonable, since you can also go up, but not down.

BB
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
888
Tokens
perhaps it depends on the purchase price to begine with? we just bought a house and bid 5% below which was counteroffered...im sure your house would be way more expensive than ours, so i dont know. if a house was 100,000 and u bid 80,000, theres no way that would even be considered. and if it was 500,000 and you bid 400,000 would that be ok? i dunno. i thought it might be 10%. we bid higher cause it was a great house and we had seen so much crap...we didnt want anyone else seeing it (they were having an open house that weekend) we still paid under asking and knew we would pay the asking if it came down to it. it was a by owner house so no realtor fees.
 

New member
Joined
Jan 10, 2005
Messages
824
Tokens
Depends on how long the house has been on the market...

If it's a new listing, the seller usually THINKS their house is worth what they are listing it for and won't come down much.

If it's been on for awhile, the 20% rule will usually work, and you generally meet in the middle on price.
 

Gunga galunga... gunga, gunga-galunga.
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Messages
4,196
Tokens
Anyone know anything about a trust sale of a home?

I am looking at a place in LA where you have to submit a sealed bid by the end of this month. I think I want to submit a bid that says....I will pay $5000 more than the next highest offer up to a maximum of ___________ ... are you allowed to do that (vs. just submitting a regular offer)?
 

Rx Senior
Joined
Oct 14, 2004
Messages
9,807
Tokens
DNoonan said:
Anyone know anything about a trust sale of a home?

I am looking at a place in LA where you have to submit a sealed bid by the end of this month. I think I want to submit a bid that says....I will pay $5000 more than the next highest offer up to a maximum of ___________ ... are you allowed to do that (vs. just submitting a regular offer)?


you do that and then you just named your price buddy. Think about it.


All they have to do is get an offer so they can get your highest offer.
 

Rx Senior
Joined
Oct 14, 2004
Messages
9,807
Tokens
Bigbet, I am in the housing market right now but I am on the selling end. When I put a house on the market I will set it so that I have room to come down. For instance, I am setting the one I have right now at 108,000. I will go down to 100,000 if thats what it takes.


Remember this one qoute that has saved me tons in the past "He who speaks first, loses."

Now that may not help you in this case because he has already marked his price. However, don't be afraid to go to low. Go crazy first if you want, you never know if they are wanting to get rid of that house. How long has it been on the market? If its been awhile they may be itching to dump it. Are there other buyers looking at the house?


The last house I bought I offered the full asking amount the day I saw it because I knew there were 4 other cars there that day looking at the house. Had that not been the case I could have saved myself a few thousand or though.


It all depends on the situation, but realize with your offer you are going to have to have a $1,000 earnest check which will solidify your offer. Meaning, if they accept your offer and then you decide you don't want it. . you can say goodbye to that $1,000.

Go low first, they can always counter offer with you.
 

Rx Wizard
Joined
Oct 25, 2005
Messages
11,731
Tokens
I bought a house a year ago and my agent said it was common practice to ask 6% below listed price and they will meet you in between. They did.
 

Do you like my new avatar?
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Messages
7,502
Tokens
I see the Mrs has chimmed in on this subject, so I may as well ...

I think that 20% is a crazy number, our agent told us the general rule of thumb of 6-9% which sounds reasonable. Think about it, know one is gonna price their house 20% more then the market calls for unless it's a very unusaul situation such as the LA market, which is insane, there are no rules there. Put it this way, we were looking in the 125's range so we would cut our target shopping level at 135-140 (at the very most) + you have to take into account taxes(if you get raped like us in NY State) typical taxes in WNY are 2500-5500 for a price range of 125 and below, it's gets worse as you move up the bracket. Anyway, if your looking at 125 your certaintly not gonna look at a house selling for 150,just out of your bugdet. Let's say I'm selling a house and I'm told it's worth 130 or so, so I put it on the market for 156 or say 155 I've just eliminated alot of potential buyers... I guess it's how you feel the house will sell and the market in your area. Good luck BB .
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
3,447
Tokens
There is no rule for how low to ask. Some people list their houses way over market. If two identical houses are for sale and one owner asks for 800 and the other asks for 750 would you give a different offer on each house because of a 10 or 20 percent rule?

Just do a ton of research in the area to see what the true values are. Then ask below what people tell you to ask. you NEVER want to ask for too much and start negotiating from a higher level.
 

Gunga galunga... gunga, gunga-galunga.
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Messages
4,196
Tokens
Kruser6 said:
you do that and then you just named your price buddy. Think about it.


All they have to do is get an offer so they can get your highest offer.

I was thinking that since all bids have to be submitted by the 31st and are sealed till then, there would not be an opportunity for them to get a fake bid to bump mine up once they saw how it was structured?

Say for example I bid $5,000 higher than the next highest bid up to $775,000, listing is $799,000 and the next highest bid submitted is $750,000, they wouldn't have a way to get another bid packet in with a fake bid of $770,000 since all the bids are sealed...no?

But you are right that it is possible and thanks for the heads up...I need to learn more about this thing. I have a family member flying down from Palo Alto to look at the house and speak with the listing agent today.

It seems like a steal though...needs a bit of work but comprable homes in the neighborhood are going for like $550 - $600 a square foot and this one, based on the listing price is like $375 per sq ft...

I am still stressed out just thinking about it...I need like a 60 year mortgage or for my fiance to never have kids so she will make a ton of cash!
 

Gunga galunga... gunga, gunga-galunga.
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Messages
4,196
Tokens
#1cheater# said:
I see the Mrs has chimmed in on this subject, so I may as well ...

Think about it, know one is gonna price their house 20% more then the market calls for unless it's a very unusaul situation such as the LA market, which is insane, there are no rules there. .

Couldn't agree more man...I am trying to buy my first home and the LA market is ridiculous...evertything I read says values are likely to go down 5 - 10% over the next 5 to 10 years in LA too...what to do?
:nohead:
 

Do you like my new avatar?
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Messages
7,502
Tokens
DNoonan said:
I was thinking that since all bids have to be submitted by the 31st and are sealed till then, there would not be an opportunity for them to get a fake bid to bump mine up once they saw how it was structured?

Say for example I bid $5,000 higher than the next highest bid up to $775,000, listing is $799,000 and the next highest bid submitted is $750,000, they wouldn't have a way to get another bid packet in with a fake bid of $770,000 since all the bids are sealed...no?

But you are right that it is possible and thanks for the heads up...I need to learn more about this thing. I have a family member flying down from Palo Alto to look at the house and speak with the listing agent today.

It seems like a steal though...needs a bit of work but comprable homes in the neighborhood are going for like $550 - $600 a square foot and this one, based on the listing price is like $375 per sq ft...

I am still stressed out just thinking about it...I need like a 60 year mortgage or for my fiance to never have kids so she will make a ton of cash!


I hate to say it, but there "may be" a reason why it's priced so low, don't get to excited until you have the house inspected.
 

Do you like my new avatar?
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Messages
7,502
Tokens
DNoonan said:
Couldn't agree more man...I am trying to buy my first home and the LA market is ridiculous...evertything I read says values are likely to go down 5 - 10% over the next 5 to 10 years in LA too...what to do?
:nohead:



I think your fine in the LA market, those are just speculations because people think the LA market has to top off at some point; speculations are just that, speculations.
 

Gunga galunga... gunga, gunga-galunga.
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Messages
4,196
Tokens
Certainly crossed my mind...was thinking it could be:
1) there is a house (based on google earth) that is snuggled up right to the back of it...look off the porch one way...beeeuuutifull...look out the other way....neighbors roof + kind of looks like a prison from the outside and needs some updating

2) since it is essentially an auction, they put the list price low to get everyone to look at it (come up in their searches) and in fact it will go for much more

3) since it is a trust sale, you have a bunch of siblings or a charity that this was left to and they just want the cash quick (I am hoping)

Either way, someone I trust very much is looking at it today so we will know whether it is worth flying out there/scrambling to sell everything I own to make a bid. I still can't believe how much houses cost out in LA!

<TABLE style="BORDER-RIGHT: #efefef 1px solid; BORDER-TOP: #efefef 1px solid; BORDER-LEFT: #efefef 1px solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #efefef 1px solid" cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 border=0><TBODY><TR><TD align=middle bgColor=#ffffff>
06_113057.jpg
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
Bright and spacious 3+2 with city-lights views in hip XXXXXX. Moderne-style architecture with a contemporary vibe featuring walls of glass leading to a private interior courtyard and a large park-like almost-flat yard. Tlc will make this eclectic star shine. Trust sale. No court confirmation required. Offers to be written on contract provided by seller. Ask listing agent for package including required paperwork & terms of sale. Sealed offers due by july 31 at 5:00 pm
 

Gunga galunga... gunga, gunga-galunga.
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Messages
4,196
Tokens
#1cheater# said:
I think your fine in the LA market, those are just speculations because people think the LA market has to top off at some point; speculations are just that, speculations.

Based on history you are spot on...it is just getting in the damn market without being in the middle of 18th street gang territory that is tough. I lived off Hollywood blvd last time around and it was a great place to party but no place to raise a family which is what I have think about now....fucking responsibility!
 

Do you like my new avatar?
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Messages
7,502
Tokens
Have you thought of having that person take a cam-corder with them and make a DVD/VHS movie of the whole house and mailing it to you? That may be a good idea and maybe get a inspection done before you get to seriuos?
 

Gunga galunga... gunga, gunga-galunga.
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Messages
4,196
Tokens
good idea, but this is such short notice that she is just using a digital camera and taking a ton of photos (I have 11 or so pics right now). luckily she has bought a few fix'er uppers in the past and knows a lot more than I do...if it passes her test, my fiance and I will fly out there (fiance will be there next week to sit for the Cali bar exam next week).

Inspection is a good idea too, any idea what that would cost?
 

Rx. Veteran
Joined
Apr 22, 2006
Messages
3,699
Tokens
Try to find out as much as you can about the seller and his/her motivations for selling, and look it up on the public property tax records to see what they paid for it. This will give you a better idea of what kind of an offer to make.
 

WVU

New member
Joined
Jan 20, 2000
Messages
11,648
Tokens
The local housing market would dictate a rule of thumb for a house offer. If you are looking in a relatively quick turnover market like South Florida then offering 20% below asking price would not even get consideration. The Realtor will even get pissy as they know it is their job to submit your offer no matter how low it is.

The art of negotiations in the real estate world is not trivial and can be very complex. If you start too low you will lose your upper hand. You really have to study the local market and know the averages and the turnover times. When the market was super hot here before this year the average selling price in Dade and Broward counties were actually 1-2% above the list price. Now you would probably see that drop to about 3-4% below the list price.

Know the neighborhood, know the sales history, and know the regional averages before you consider an offer. The best offer is one that is accepted without a counter offer. Often people make the mistake of thinking well maybe you offered too much. If you offered 10 grand less they may have countered with a number higher then what you would have originally offered. In this case you lose.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,625
Messages
13,453,025
Members
99,426
Latest member
bodyhealthtechofficia
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com