The lack of respect for 1AA Football

Search
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
20,303
Tokens
I am hoping that by time the season is over, people as a whole will respect 1AA football more. I am amazed at how everyone from fans to announcers on major networks pencil in automatic wins for any 1A team when facing a 1AA squad.

I understand that 1AA teams get nowhere near the media attention that 1A teams do. However if people are so called "experts", why can't they acknowledge or even understand that these games aren't cupcake W's anymore.

I guess they haven't gotten the memo when teams like Maine, Montana, New Hampshire, Portland St, etc... have gone on the road & beat teams including ones from the so called big 6.

The arguement will be well they didn't beat the best teams. However years ago even the worst 1A teams would trounce the best 1AA teams. So this reasoning does not fly with me. The truth is the talent level between the top 20-30 1AA schools is getting closer & closer to even the average 1A schools. Maybe within the next decade we will see some upsets of the bigger powerhouse schools. I doubt it will happen only because the powerhouses won't schedule these teams.

Maybe the 2006 season will be the huge wakeup call to the fans, media & the like about the rise of 1AA football. These victories or close calls aren't flukes, these teams are taking the big boys punch & fighting right back. Years ago they would be happy to show up, now they go expecting to win.

The talent is coming from better recruiting because of better spending on facilities along with picking up players that were recruited by good or top 1A schools but weren't eligible for academic reasons. The transfer factor is also a big one as talented players wanting playing time are switching over because of the loopholes available when transferring between the two divisions.

I am in no way shocked by some of the results of this season especially today. UMass was a team I thought had a great shot to beat a good Navy team. They fell short by 1 point but if you look at the game, UMass outplayed them. UMass beat themselves, not Navy.

The Minutemen D held Navy's rushing attack under 300 yards, won the time of possession, had fewer turnovers, & outgained them in total offense. Unfortunately they shot themselves in the foot when they didn't capitalize on the 7 fumbles by Navy which they recovered 3 of them. The big momentum turner was when they were down by 4 & got picked off at the Navy 3.

I feel bad for the Minutemen as they did not deserve to lose this game!


New Hampshire: Well they showed why they are one of the favorites to win the national title. The #2 marched into Northwestern & whipped them by double digits.


Hofstra while still early in the game is up by 14 on Marshall. I mean when will 1AA get the respect they deserve? Watch how in the future 1A teams will stop scheduling the better 1AA squads. I think some coaches are wising up that the day of cupcake W's against 1AA teams are over.
 

LA Clippers Junkie
Joined
May 14, 2005
Messages
11,323
Tokens
I enjoy 1AA football. I played and coached D1 and also coached 1AA.

When I was coaching, we went on the road and beat New Mexico State.

The upper teams in 1AA are solid. They can compete/beat some of the lower tier D1 teams.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
20,303
Tokens
Do you think the upper teams could beat some of the mid D1 teams? I think they have clearly reached that level the last 2-3 seasons. I'm excited for the future of 1AA football.
 

LA Clippers Junkie
Joined
May 14, 2005
Messages
11,323
Tokens
I still remember a while ago (94 or 95) when Idaho was 1AA and they went into Utah and won.

These games are like the Super Bowl for the 1AA teams and they are normally scheduled right before a big game because the D1 team wants an easy week. They are often overlooked.

I don't think they could compete if they played a full schedule of D1 opponents because the talent level is a drop off. Usually the biggest differences are in the offensive/defensive lines.

But the 1AA teams can definitely jump up and bite D1 teams if they don't take them seriously.
 
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
20,303
Tokens
I agree they might not hold up at first to a full D1 schedule. However I think they are getting closer & closer to being able to do it. I wish a few teams would take the jump up to 1A including Massachusetts, Montana to name a couple.
 

LA Clippers Junkie
Joined
May 14, 2005
Messages
11,323
Tokens
I think Montana could do it. They already have the facilities (which is usually another draw back to 1AA teams). They also are in a state without a pro team so the support is huge in the community.
 

FreeRyanFerguson.com
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
13,308
Tokens
You must have missed the IL St- K State game. ISU dominated them, gave up two special teams touchdowns, and missed a two point conversion that would have won it in the closing minutes. Dipshit coach went for two when they were obviously the best team on the field that night. ISU might be the very best team in 1AA, as they might have been last year as well.
 

LA Clippers Junkie
Joined
May 14, 2005
Messages
11,323
Tokens
There are a lot of factors when deciding whether or not a team could make it on the D1 level. There are several teams that could make the jump. They would also start landing better talent just by making the jump to D1.

But there are stadium size requirement and other factors on whether or not a team can make it financially as a D1 school.
 

Their undisputed masterpiece is "Hip to be Square.
Joined
Dec 29, 2005
Messages
6,178
Tokens
The elite D1 AA football teams will never be able to compete with the upper quarter of D1 schools like they occasionally do in basketball.
-Until then, no respect.

-Although, I would never schedule an away game against top tier D1AA school if I was a coach of a big time school-just to be on the safe side.
 

FreeRyanFerguson.com
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
13,308
Tokens
Clip Joint- I know you are somebody famous, and I'm just trying to figure out who the hell you could possibly be. Played D1 hoops, D1 football, coached D1 and 1AA football, has $100K swings on Clippers-Suns playoff games. You are a legend. I'm going to continue my research and find out who you are.
 

LA Clippers Junkie
Joined
May 14, 2005
Messages
11,323
Tokens
Illini said:
Clip Joint- I know you are somebody famous, and I'm just trying to figure out who the hell you could possibly be. Played D1 hoops, D1 football, coached D1 and 1AA football, has $100K swings on Clippers-Suns playoff games. You are a legend. I'm going to continue my research and find out who you are.

:lolBIG:

Far from it...don't waste your time. :missingte

I've met a couple guys from here. I'm no one worthwhile. :toast:
 
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
20,303
Tokens
The Falls said:
The elite D1 AA football teams will never be able to compete with the upper quarter of D1 schools like they occasionally do in basketball.
-Until then, no respect.

-Although, I would never schedule an away game against top tier D1AA school if I was a coach of a big time school-just to be on the safe side.


Why do you feel they will never compete? Also how could you not respect the fact 1AA teams are competing & even defeating 1A teams when even in last decade, such results were almost next to impossible?
 

FreeRyanFerguson.com
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
13,308
Tokens
Clip Joint said:
:lolBIG:

Far from it...don't waste your time. :missingte

I've met a couple guys from here. I'm no one worthwhile. :toast:
I thought you might be Tom Tolbert for awhile. I guess you are just a good but not great athlete that made or inherited a shitload of money to bet with.
 
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
20,303
Tokens
WildBill said:
Who really cares which division some of these teams play in?


It is a respect issue. If people would take more notice of IAA football, it could give the sport an even bigger shot in the arm.

The one big reason I love the 1AA over 1A is because they actually have a legit playoff system in place. I won't hold my breath as to why the NCAA can have playoffs in place for 1AA, II, & III but not for its highest level.
 

LA Clippers Junkie
Joined
May 14, 2005
Messages
11,323
Tokens
Illini said:
I thought you might be Tom Tolbert for awhile. I guess you are just a good but not great athlete that made or inherited a shitload of money to bet with.

No inheritance...I am definitely self made. Just not anyone famous. :toast:

I wouldn't mind being Tom Tolbert though. I love that guy. :missingte
 

Their undisputed masterpiece is "Hip to be Square.
Joined
Dec 29, 2005
Messages
6,178
Tokens
EveryGamblersDream said:
Why do you feel they will never compete? Also how could you not respect the fact 1AA teams are competing & even defeating 1A teams when even in last decade, such results were almost next to impossible?

I said top tier teams
-Not much difference from a lower level D1 school and top D1AA school.
-Athleticism and size are, and will always be, the difference.
 
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
20,303
Tokens
The Falls said:
I said top tier teams
-Not much difference from a lower level D1 school and top D1AA school.
-Athleticism and size are, and will always be, the difference.

I can understand why you feel that way. I'll just respectfully disagree. The top 1AA teams are getting even better recruiting classes & transfers of good players from top D1 schools.
 

LA Clippers Junkie
Joined
May 14, 2005
Messages
11,323
Tokens
There is a drastic talent difference in top D1 programs and top 1AA. The 2nd and 3rd stringers at the top D1 schools can go down and start right away at 1AA.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,591
Messages
13,452,739
Members
99,425
Latest member
StarryInsider1
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com