Peyton Manning or Tom Brady old thread '06

gynecologist

Banned

Joined

Jan 19, 2006

Messages

30,208

Tokens

• Nov 5, 2006

• #1

OR

 

HinesWard86

Last night I drank enough to kill a small Asian fa

Joined

Jan 25, 2005

Messages

6,839

Tokens

• Nov 5, 2006

• #2

To cover the spread......Peyton Manning

For anything else (including win in January)......Tom Brady

 

gynecologist

Banned

Joined

Jan 19, 2006

Messages

30,208

Tokens

• Nov 5, 2006

• #3

If Manning had Belichick and Co on the sidelines,and the previous great Pats defense I truly believe Manning would have a few Super Bowls himself...

 

Journeyman

Banned

Joined

Sep 20, 2004

Messages

80,046

Tokens

• Nov 5, 2006

• #4

Wobbler...

 

royboy_3831

I'm all about low expectations

Joined

Feb 3, 2006

Messages

7,210

Tokens

• Nov 5, 2006

• #5

brady is GREAT, but i'll take manning everytime, think he'll go down as the greatest of all time by many people when he's done...

 

Stickie

New member

Joined

Dec 13, 2004

Messages

661

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #6

My 5 year old son is named Peyton, my choice is clear.

 

skoda

Member

Handicapper

Joined

Sep 21, 2004

Messages

9,853

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #7

Are we talking about Peyton Place or the Brady Bunch?

Or who is the wealthiest?
My vote is a veto, or is it my veto is a vote

 

Railbird

The Great Govenor of California

Joined

Feb 21, 2001

Messages

15,972

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #8

brady much better

 

skoda

Member

Handicapper

Joined

Sep 21, 2004

Messages

9,853

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #9

okay I'll be serious for a minute! In front of every good QB is a great line! Now on the otherhand if Chicago was to have Manning or Brady some might think Da-Bears would be 8-0, instead of the Colts? New England lost to Denver who also lost to Indy so does this make Miami who beat Chicago @ Home, Indy's only loss?

 

royboy_3831

I'm all about low expectations

Joined

Feb 3, 2006

Messages

7,210

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #10

Railbird said:

brady much better

Click to expand...

shocking, this coming from the same guy who said jim harbaugh was better than manning... solid

 

The_Man

ball dont lie

Joined

Sep 21, 2000

Messages

6,757

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #11

you see manning whining like a school girl when things dont go his way.

guy gets rattled under pressure to easily whereas brady is locked in.

 

Railbird

The Great Govenor of California

Joined

Feb 21, 2001

Messages

15,972

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #12

HArbaugh did much more with much less than Manning did.

 

X-Files

fbi

Joined

Feb 20, 2002

Messages

24,349

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #13

Why choose...i take them both...but not at the same time.

I think Brady is cuter, though.

 

Fishhead

Active member

Joined

Oct 20, 1999

Messages

75,444

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #14

Peyton

 

mj23

Member

Joined

Oct 18, 2004

Messages

5,109

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #15

TOM BRADY just look at their fingers!!

 

WVU

New member

Joined

Jan 20, 2000

Messages

11,648

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #16

Tom has more rings, but Peyton has more commercials

 

Fishhead

Active member

Joined

Oct 20, 1999

Messages

75,444

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #17

mj 23 said:

TOM BRADY just look at their fingers!!

Click to expand...

I guess Brad Johnson is better than Peyton Manning too.

 

dougstewart

New member

Joined

Oct 15, 2004

Messages

1,839

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #18

not really fair because PM has much better receivers, but TB has a better defense. I could live with either

 

gynecologist

Banned

Joined

Jan 19, 2006

Messages

30,208

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #19

mj 23 said:

TOM BRADY just look at their fingers!!

Click to expand...

Trent Dilfer won a Superbowl..

Ben Rothlisberger won a Superbowl with these stats

9/21 123 yds 0 TD 2 INT...


11 players on each side of the ball fellas.. 1 player doesn't make a team..
Basketball it's like that but not football..

 

royboy_3831

I'm all about low expectations

Joined

Feb 3, 2006

Messages

7,210

Tokens

• Nov 6, 2006

• #20

wow... it's a landslide, 22-9 peyton right now, suprising results...