I'm sure I'm forgetting a few, but off the top of my head I'd boot
Phil Rizzuto, Red Schoendienst, Rabbit Maranville, Pee Wee Reese, Enos Slaughter, Gaylord Perry, and Don Sutton. Sutton doesn't belong IMO even if he hadn't been caught cheating, and he was.
Pete Rose (and Joe Jackson) don't get in, no way, no how. Whatever you personally feel about betting as a gambler, it cannot be ignored that it is the First Degree Murder crime of baseball-that, in and of itself, is enough to keep that scum Rose out. Now, factor in the fact that he lied like scum for FIFTEEN YEARS in denying that he bet at all. And, to those clueless people who say, "Well, Charlie Hustle never bet against his own team!" I say, whenver he didn't bet ON the Reds (as he did, in an unusually farsighted move, when Mario Soto pitched), he was indirectly betting AGAINST the Reds. And, on over/unders, which he also bet, say the Reds are winning 8-1 in the 9th, the opponents are batting with the bases loaded and two out, and the total is 9.5. You're telling me 'ole Petey wouldn't say, "Hey, this game is all but over and I'd normally take my tiring pitcher out, but, jeez, I only need
ONE MORE RUN to get my total, I'll just leave him in to see if we can squeeze out that lil' old bet winner." Those last few are just another few bricks in the wall, the guy is lower than snake shit. I don't give a shit that Jackson hit .375, he bet against his own and welched, that doesn't earn any credit, either. He was banned for LIFE, and he's been dead more than a half century. When Pete has been taking a dirt nap for that long, get back to me, then we'll talk...