Using your fav. mlb team's players from last 20 years, compile the best team

BillBrasky · Jun 2, 2007

Take any players from your team since 1987, give me your starters, rotation, and closer.

My favorite Atlanta Braves team would be this, however, there would be many ways to make a better lineup to add some speed. I'm sure I'm leaving out some guys, this is just off the top of my head.

1B- Fred McGriff
2B- Marcus Giles
SS- Jeff Blauser/Furcal
3B- Chipper Jones
OF- Dale Murphey
OF- Andruw Jones
OF- Dave Justice
C- Javy Lopez

Starting Rotation- Gregg Maddux, Tom Glavine, John Smoltz, Steve Avery, Tim Hudson

Closer- Mark Wohlers

Salsa · Jun 2, 2007

I'd have to put Andres Galarragga in there instead of Fred McGriff. I'd firm up Furcal instead of Blauser or maybe reconsider Brett Butler. I'd also be forced to add John Rocker as a closer. The best single inning I've ever seen pitched in my life was by John Rocker.

Timetopay · Jun 2, 2007

Ok here goes

1b Mark Grace
2b Ryne Sandberg
SS Shawon Dunston
3b Aramis Ramirez
OF Moises Alou
OF Sammy Sosa
OF Andre Dawson
C Jody Davis
SP Greg Maddux,Carlos Zambrano,Jamie Moyer,Kevin Tapani,Mark Prior/Kerry Wood
Closer Rod Beck or Randy Myers

No wonder this damn team always sucks. I couldnt put 5 good Starters together in 20 years. Maddux is it.

I cant think of a decent catcher. DamonBerryhill, Ric Wrona, Michael Barrett

The closers are a couple years of good stats and than thats it. Man this was depressing.

5teamparlay · Jun 2, 2007

MY CHICAGO WHITE SOX

1B- FRANK THOMAS
2B- Joey CORA GYH
SS- OZZIE GUILLEN
3B- ROBIN VENTURA
OF- CARLOS LEE
OF- BOJACKSON
OF- MAGLIO ORDONEZ
C- CARLTON FISK
DH- HAROLD BAINES
Starting Rotation- JACK McDOWELL, JASON BERE, MARK BUHRLE, ALEX FENANDEZ, Jon Garland

SET-UP - ROBERTO HERNANDEZ
Closer- BOBBY THIGPEN

Would like to see a ROYALS list -- DAMON, DYE and BELTRAN makes a nice OF.

Timetopay · Jun 2, 2007

5teamparlay said:
MY CHICAGO WHITE SOX

1B- FRANK THOMAS
2B- Joey CORA GYH
SS- OZZIE GUILLEN
3B- ROBIN VENTURA
OF- CARLOS LEE
OF- BOJACKSON
OF- MAGLIO ORDONEZ
C- CARLTON FISK
DH- HAROLD BAINES
Starting Rotation- JACK McDOWELL, JASON BERE, MARK BUHRLE, ALEX FENANDEZ, Jon Garland

SET-UP - ROBERTO HERNANDEZ
Closer- BOBBY THIGPEN

Would like to see a ROYALS list -- DAMON, DYE and BELTRAN makes a nice OF.

Think i would go with Alverez over Bere.

royboy_3831 · Jun 2, 2007

Texas Rangers

Pitching staff... bwahahahahahahahaha nevermind

PublicsMoney · Jun 2, 2007

For your World Champion Minnesota Twins.

1B Justin Morneau
2B Luis Castillo
3B Gary Gaetti
SS Greg Gagne
LF Shannon Stewart
CF Kirby Puckett
RF Tom Brunansky
DH Kent Hrbek

Starting Rotation Bert Blyleven, Frank Viola, Johan Santana, Brad Radke, Jack Morris

Set Up...Joe Nathan
Closer....Jeff Reardon

Manager...Tom Kelly

Timetopay · Jun 2, 2007

PublicsMoney said:
For your World Champion Minnesota Twins.

1B Justin Morneau
2B Luis Castillo
3B Gary Gaetti
SS Greg Gagne
LF Shannon Stewart
CF Kirby Puckett
RF Tom Brunansky
DH Kent Hrbek

Starting Rotation Bert Blyleven, Frank Viola, Johan Santana, Brad Radke, Jack Morris

Set Up...Joe Nathan
Closer....Jeff Reardon

Manager...Tom Kelly

Stewart over Hunter???

PublicsMoney · Jun 3, 2007

I tell you what, Stewart during his career has come up with more clutch hits, but I would say that Hunter has been alot better defensively. Not a big Torri Hunter fan, gets paid alot of money and continually grounds into double plays.

5teamparlay · Jun 3, 2007

Bere was 12-5 in '93 and 12-2 in '94 (had good K #'s as well)t hen after the strike fizzled like WOOD and PRIOR. Other notables were an ALL STAR year by Cal Eldred (10-2) and Loaiza (21-9).

Loved the McDowell, ALAVAREZ, Fernandez, Bere Rotation back in '94.

steaktartar · Jun 3, 2007

PublicsMoney said:
For your World Champion Minnesota Twins.

1B Justin Morneau
2B Luis Castillo
3B Gary Gaetti
SS Greg Gagne
LF Shannon Stewart
CF Kirby Puckett
RF Tom Brunansky
DH Kent Hrbek

Starting Rotation Bert Blyleven, Frank Viola, Johan Santana, Brad Radke, Jack Morris

Set Up...Joe Nathan
Closer....Jeff Reardon

Manager...Tom Kelly

same except lets have a catcher joe mauer batting champ looks like good choice

Timetopay · Jun 3, 2007

steak tartar said:
same except lets have a catcher joe mauer batting champ looks like good choice

LLOLOLOLL. Dont ruin alot of threads u drunk bitch with your shit.....

Ruin every thread.:aktion033

billhill999 · Jun 3, 2007

New York Yankees
(favorite, not best, right?)

C - Joe Girardi
1B - Tino Martinez
2B - Willie Randolph
SS- Derek Jeter
3B - Wade Boggs
RF - Paul O'Neill
CF - Bernie Williams
LF - Hideki Matsui
DH - Scott Brosius (I used Boggs at 3B already)
SP - Mike Mussina
SP - Jimmy Key
SP - Roger Clemens
SP - Andy Pettitte
SP - Tommy John
RP - Mo

Best Team

C- Jorge Posada
1B - Don Mattingly
2B - Alfonso Soriano
SS - Derek Jeter
3B - A - Rod
RF - Paul O'Neill
CF - Bernie Williams
LF - Ricky Henderson
SP - Andy Pettitte
SP - David Cone
SP - Roger Clemens
SP - Ron Guidry
RP - Mo

theticket_22 · Jun 3, 2007

Florida Marlins:
C Pudge Rodriguez
1b Carlos Delgado
2b Luis Castillo
3b Miguel Cabrera
ss Hanley Ramierez
of Cliff Floyd
of Juan piere
of bobby bonnila
bn/dh Moises Alou
sp Josh Beckett
sp A. J Burnett
sp Livan hernandez
sp Al Leiter
sp Brad penny

cl Bryan Harvey

* didnt add Piazza since he only played a few games...

ChrisParadise · Jun 3, 2007

Cincinnati Reds

1B Sean Casey
2B Jeff Treadway (horrible)
3B Chris Sabo
SS Barry Larkin
C Benito Santiago
LF Adam Dunn
CF Ken Griffey Jr.
RF Eric Davis

SP Jose Rijo
SP Tom Browning
SP Danny Jackson
SP Aaron Harang
SP Jack Armstrong
RP Rob Dibble

Most of this team is from the '90 world champs. This is depressing. The franchise has been pretty bad the past 20 yrs

VIEJODINOSAUR · Jun 3, 2007

My Phils All Time..
1B..Ryan Howard
2B..Pete Rose
SS..Larry Bowa
3B..Mike Schmidt
OF..Von Hayes
Garry Maddox
Greg Luzsinski
SP..Steve Carlton
Rick Wise
Chris Short
Jim Bunning
RP..Tug McGraw
Honorable Mention...Johnny Callison,Jimmy Rollins,Davey Cash
Manager...Dallas Green

Boxslayer · Jun 3, 2007

Florida Marlins

C - Pudge Rodriguez
1B - Derek Lee
2B - Luis Castillo
SS - Hanley Ramirez
3B - Miguel Cabrera
RF - Gary Sheffield (has a chance to be the 1st Marlin in the HOF)
CF - Juan Pierre
LF - Moises Alou
DH - Mike Piazza

P - Kevin Brown
P - Josh Beckett
P - Dontrelle Willis
P - Brad Penny
P - AJ Burnett

CL - Trevor Hoffman

ihawk06 · Jun 3, 2007

KC ROYALS

C Bob Boone
1B Mike Sweeney
2B Frank White
3B George Brett
SS Jay Bell
OF Carlos Beltran
OF Johnny Damon
OF Bo Jackson
DH Jermaine Dye

SP Bret Saberhagan
SP David Cone
SP Mark Gubiza
SP Kevin Appier
SP Tom Gordon

RP Dan Quiesenberry
RP Jeff Montgomery

RobFunk · Jun 3, 2007

Gunna borrow your template Boxslayer

Boston RedSox

C - Jason Varitek
1B - Mo Vaughn
2B - Dustin Pedroia
SS - Nomar Garciaparra
3B - Wade Boggs
RF - Dwight Evans
CF - Johnny Damon
LF - Manny Rameriz
DH - David Ortiz

P - Roger Clemens
P - Pedro Martinez
P - Curt Schilling
P - Derrick Lowe
P - Bret Saberhagen

CL - Kieth Foulke

PokerKingJim · Jun 3, 2007

Pirates:

C Jason Kendall
1B Kevin Young - tough call over Bream, Jeff King. Young had a few really good seasons.
2B Tony Womack - Gonna take offense and speed here over the defense of Jose (Chico) Lind
3B Bobby Bonilla
SS Jay Bell
LF Barry Bonds
CF Andy Van Slyke
RF Brian Giles

SP Doug Drabek
SP John Smiley
SP Zane Smith
SP Kris Benson

Better go with a 4 man rotation cause our starters have been brutal over the years. Didnt include Jason Schmidt since (naturally) he sucked or was injured during his Bucs career.

Righty Reliever - Stan Belinda
Lefty Reliever - Bob Patterson
Closer - Mike Williams

All in all a rather sorry team, especially the pitching. Take a few studs from the late 80's/early 90's off the team and it's downright putrid

Using your fav. mlb team's players from last 20 years, compile the best team

New member

Banned

Old School

Member

Old School

I'm all about low expectations

Member

Old School

Member

Member

powdered milkman

Old School

New member

RX

New member

Member

UF. Champion U.

GO HAWKS!!!

RX Senior

Respect My Steez

Forum statistics

Share this page