I may be crazy but I like Ari with Petit vs SD with Peavy! Ari is hot, while SD is cold. Also, a look at Petit's last 5 away starts compared to Peavy's last 5 home starts offers some support. Petit had 28.1 IP and allowed 8 ER. Peavy had 30 IP and allowed 16 ER. A good value at +201 IMO. Good luck!