The official "Should i make this trade" thread

honkee · Aug 29, 2007

Everybody asks, why not put it all in one.

Just got offered deshaun foster+terry glenn for carson palmer

This is in a 40 dollar cbs league that i got autodrafted in.
My running backs are clinton portis,warrick dunn and adrian peterson(bears)
My back up qb is shittyberger for pitt

backup recievers are chad johnson,Coles,bouldin

JakeT. · Aug 29, 2007

Who are you giving up?

GreenDoberman · Aug 30, 2007

Don't know why you'd give up a top 3 QB for a RB who may not end up starting or will platoon at best and an injury-prone receiver.

LineTamer+ · Aug 30, 2007

I have Lamont Jordan and Mike Turner

He has LT and Rhodes.

He offers Rhodes for Turner......thoughts?

also, due to computer problems I got stuck with 7 WRs...
Keeping..Steve Smith, Roy Williams

Trade Bait: V JAckson, Coles, Holmes, Bennett and Porter.

I will probably have to start 3 WRs as my RBs suck, but i want to improve them by trading some WRs, maybe even Roy Williams/Jackson for a proven number 1 back.

Current RBs are Gore, Lamont, Foster and Turner. WE start 2 rbs 2 wr and 1 rb/wr.

GreenDoberman · Aug 30, 2007

Interesting there as Turner has zero value, but tons if LT gets hurt. Obviously he want Turner as an insurance policy. Rhodes isn't great even if he plays or Jordan gets hurt. I'd hold out for a little more on that one.

LineTamer+ · Aug 30, 2007

ha,, i declined his trade offer, and he went ahead and dropped Rhodes to sign Leon WAshington.

So know do i drop Poter or Bennett and sign Rhodes? Or stick it out a while to see if Bennett/Porter do well?