Dave Malinsky - 5*
PICK: Virginia (-16.5)
REASON FOR PICK: 5* VIRGINIA over DUKE
Here’s the thing about bad teams – they are bad. That might not sound all that brilliant, so let’s rephrase in a way that really matters in the work that we do - Most genuinely bad teams are even worse than scores and statistics show. And that is part of the story behind this one.
Duke is the prototype of being a bad team, and carrying a 21-game losing streak should have most thinking they are fully aware of how bad the Blue Devils are. But when you are bad at an extreme level, you get a reprieve on both the scoreboards and in the stat columns. Almost all of the opponents end up taking it easy against you, and you rarely have to take their best punch. You do not have to face the other team’s starters for the entire game, and instead of having an aggressive opponent attacking on offense in the second half, many games find them backing off instead, and just trying to work the clock and get the game over with. As such, bad teams can still cover a fair share of pointspreads, not so much because of any particular skill that they brought to the event, but rather because the other side was not trying very hard.
So what happens on those rare occasions when someone attacks a bad team with their full arsenal? What happened to Duke last week, and what will happen to Duke here.
On Saturday the Blue Devils thought they had a real chance to end the nation’s longest losing streak, facing a mediocre Connecticut team from the Big East. And when they caught a break by returning a kickoff for a touchdown, they actually went into the locker room ahead 14-11 at halftime. But all that did was lead to coach Ted Roof’s worst nightmare – having to face an opponent that was going to come out of the locker angry and ready to go hard the rest of the way. And it was ugly. The Huskies went on a dominating 34-0 run after intermission, and when all of the counting was over it was 45-14 on the scoreboard, 23-10 in first downs and 487-169 in total offense. Now the even worse news for Roof is that his team will get a full game of that treatment this week.
Off of a dismal opening loss at Wyoming there is a real sense of urgency for Al Groh here. In a season in which big things are expected it means a “no prisoners” attitude, especially as he catches flack from the local media in what could be his final season, if things do not turn around. And perhaps the best way to measure Groh for this setting is to look at his own history a bit, both as a big home favorite in a conference game, and against this Duke program. That is what cements the play. Groh has been favored more than a TD five times in the last six seasons vs. A.C.C. oppponents, and got the money every time. The last four seasons his Cavaliers have whipped the Blue Devils by a combined 139-23, for 29 points per game, and in the last two it has been 75-7. That is exactly what we want to see.
Although the Virginia offense is indeed nothing special, it does not have to be in this spread range. The Cavalier defense has a chance to be one of the 20 best in the nation this season, and there is every reason to believe that they can pitch a shutout this week. They did LY, holding the Duke offense to 100 yards, and two years ago it was 31-0 in the fourth quarter before the Blue Devils were able to score against the reserve defenders. And because of some other key circumstances, this is one game in which we can confidently use defense to cover a double-figure spread, which is the final piece of the puzzle.
As bad as the Blue Devils are on both sides of the ball, there is a key element in which they are particularly horrendous – the punting game. It was so bad on Saturday that they used three different punters, two freshmen and a sophomore, and they combined for an awful 28.7 yards on seven punts. That is correct, 28.7. That means plenty of favorable field position opportunities for the Cavalier offense to get untracked, and they make up for last week’s awful showing by breaking this one wide open
PICK: Virginia (-16.5)
REASON FOR PICK: 5* VIRGINIA over DUKE
Here’s the thing about bad teams – they are bad. That might not sound all that brilliant, so let’s rephrase in a way that really matters in the work that we do - Most genuinely bad teams are even worse than scores and statistics show. And that is part of the story behind this one.
Duke is the prototype of being a bad team, and carrying a 21-game losing streak should have most thinking they are fully aware of how bad the Blue Devils are. But when you are bad at an extreme level, you get a reprieve on both the scoreboards and in the stat columns. Almost all of the opponents end up taking it easy against you, and you rarely have to take their best punch. You do not have to face the other team’s starters for the entire game, and instead of having an aggressive opponent attacking on offense in the second half, many games find them backing off instead, and just trying to work the clock and get the game over with. As such, bad teams can still cover a fair share of pointspreads, not so much because of any particular skill that they brought to the event, but rather because the other side was not trying very hard.
So what happens on those rare occasions when someone attacks a bad team with their full arsenal? What happened to Duke last week, and what will happen to Duke here.
On Saturday the Blue Devils thought they had a real chance to end the nation’s longest losing streak, facing a mediocre Connecticut team from the Big East. And when they caught a break by returning a kickoff for a touchdown, they actually went into the locker room ahead 14-11 at halftime. But all that did was lead to coach Ted Roof’s worst nightmare – having to face an opponent that was going to come out of the locker angry and ready to go hard the rest of the way. And it was ugly. The Huskies went on a dominating 34-0 run after intermission, and when all of the counting was over it was 45-14 on the scoreboard, 23-10 in first downs and 487-169 in total offense. Now the even worse news for Roof is that his team will get a full game of that treatment this week.
Off of a dismal opening loss at Wyoming there is a real sense of urgency for Al Groh here. In a season in which big things are expected it means a “no prisoners” attitude, especially as he catches flack from the local media in what could be his final season, if things do not turn around. And perhaps the best way to measure Groh for this setting is to look at his own history a bit, both as a big home favorite in a conference game, and against this Duke program. That is what cements the play. Groh has been favored more than a TD five times in the last six seasons vs. A.C.C. oppponents, and got the money every time. The last four seasons his Cavaliers have whipped the Blue Devils by a combined 139-23, for 29 points per game, and in the last two it has been 75-7. That is exactly what we want to see.
Although the Virginia offense is indeed nothing special, it does not have to be in this spread range. The Cavalier defense has a chance to be one of the 20 best in the nation this season, and there is every reason to believe that they can pitch a shutout this week. They did LY, holding the Duke offense to 100 yards, and two years ago it was 31-0 in the fourth quarter before the Blue Devils were able to score against the reserve defenders. And because of some other key circumstances, this is one game in which we can confidently use defense to cover a double-figure spread, which is the final piece of the puzzle.
As bad as the Blue Devils are on both sides of the ball, there is a key element in which they are particularly horrendous – the punting game. It was so bad on Saturday that they used three different punters, two freshmen and a sophomore, and they combined for an awful 28.7 yards on seven punts. That is correct, 28.7. That means plenty of favorable field position opportunities for the Cavalier offense to get untracked, and they make up for last week’s awful showing by breaking this one wide open