Will Brady be known as the greatest NFL player ever in 20 years?

Biggamer3 · Oct 14, 2007

3 championships already and he is only getting better which is scary

1650 yards and 20 TD's in the first 5 and a half games so far, could shatter every QB single season record this year!

jjgold · Oct 14, 2007

He already is the best ever

whalewager · Oct 14, 2007

He is certainly making a case for it.

I would still rather have Manning but he is definitely top 6 or 7 right now with his accomplishments so far.

Seymour · Oct 14, 2007

He or Manning is the greatest of all time.

Timetopay · Oct 14, 2007

Cedric Benson

royboy_3831 · Oct 14, 2007

1. Manning
2. Brady

Biggamer3 · Oct 14, 2007

He is making every pass for a TD look so damn simple
5 TD's so far today

His calmness is killing me

steaktartar · Oct 14, 2007

yelberton abraham tittle

manning brady

ButI'mTedBell · Oct 14, 2007

Just curious. Not a fan of either team. Just wonder why anyone would put Manning ahead of Brady. In my eyes, it's not even close. Insight please...

whalewager · Oct 14, 2007

But I'm Ted Bell said:
Just curious. Not a fan of either team. Just wonder why anyone would put Manning ahead of Brady. In my eyes, it's not even close. Insight please...

why wouldnt someone?

because Brady has more rings?

nah...

I would feel more comfortable with Manning taking the snap on a last drive

royboy_3831 · Oct 14, 2007

But I'm Ted Bell said:
Just curious. Not a fan of either team. Just wonder why anyone would put Manning ahead of Brady. In my eyes, it's not even close. Insight please...

not close in my eyes either... only i think manning is better

both are great

ButI'mTedBell · Oct 14, 2007

steak tartar said:
yelberton abraham tittle

manning brady

ButI'mTedBell · Oct 14, 2007

whalewager said:
why wouldnt someone?

because Brady has more rings?

nah...

I would feel more comfortable with Manning taking the snap on a last drive

Fair enough....I'd rather have Brady..can't go wrong either way...

whalewager · Oct 14, 2007

I agree Ted...

Both are great and we are lucky to be seeing them.

Biggamer3 · Oct 14, 2007

royboy_3831 said:
1. Manning
2. Brady

Eli has been great so far but he hasnt done enough to surpass Brady IMO

VaultedTreehouse · Oct 14, 2007

He's the best I've ever seen. Whining Manning with his head down when he throws his 3rd pick against a real defense is not in the Top 5. Regular season stats aren't much.

honkee · Oct 14, 2007

Brady is not even in the same league as manning.
Put Brady with the colts and they run the board, put manning with the pats and theyll probably be 12-4

Brady is a fuckin stud, even before this year for you bandwagon jumpers

honkee · Oct 14, 2007

Humongous difference between a great qb and an elite qb

valdosta · Oct 14, 2007

Both are great QB's but I'd rather have Brady in the clutch. Even last year when Manning finally got his ring he didn;t play that great in the playoffs.

trytrytry · Oct 14, 2007

he and Rice close. but with QB as the position in the game Id say he is right there.

Will Brady be known as the greatest NFL player ever in 20 years?

We didn't lose the game; we just ran out of time

New member

AIG Bonus Recipient

Member

Old School

I'm all about low expectations

We didn't lose the game; we just ran out of time

powdered milkman

Optimist

AIG Bonus Recipient

I'm all about low expectations

Optimist

Optimist

AIG Bonus Recipient

We didn't lose the game; we just ran out of time

New member

New member

New member

Member

Member

Forum statistics

Share this page