Manning Or Brady?

Search

New member
Joined
Dec 9, 2006
Messages
4,668
Tokens
I'd Have To Say Payton . Unless Brady Gets 6-8 Secs To Throw The He Seems Like Another Very Good Qb But Not In Mannings Class.
Ne Off Line Has Gotten Their Asses Handed To Them Two Weeks In A Row And Now Mr Brady Doesn't Look So Good.
 

New member
Joined
Apr 21, 2002
Messages
28,149
Tokens
I'd take Peyton although you really can't go wrong.
 

New member
Joined
Jun 21, 2004
Messages
4,336
Tokens
3 super bowls, 21 game win streak, possible undefeated season, most 4th qtr comebacks

i will take Brady for the poise,leadership and being a great teammate

Peyton has better ball skills and arm strength
 

A Separate Reality
Joined
Jan 14, 2002
Messages
5,533
Tokens
Brady...

The loser gene too strong in Manning pool...ie Archie and Eli. Payton will revisit that 5 (or was it 6 INT) game again.
 

Rx Senior
Joined
Dec 10, 2002
Messages
8,483
Tokens
Brady
<?xml:namespace prefix = o ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office" /><o:p></o:p>
Won more SB’s… <o:p></o:p>
Has never choked… <o:p></o:p>
Putting up similar/better numbers now that he has same caliber WR’s as Manning…<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
Both looked worse with pressure. Manning looked like crap when he got pressure in his face. i.e KC game and SD game…<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
2,932
Tokens
Brady
<?xml:namespace prefix = o ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office" /><o:p></o:p>
Won more SB’s… <o:p></o:p>
Has never choked… <o:p></o:p>
Putting up similar/better numbers now that he has same caliber WR’s as Manning…<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
Both looked worse with pressure. Manning looked like crap when he got pressure in his face. i.e KC game and SD game…<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
Yes he did last year against the Colts in the AFC championship game and the year before against Denver

All you have to is put pressure on Shady Brady and he will choke again!

Fukk him and his master Belicheat!
 

Rx Senior
Joined
Dec 10, 2002
Messages
8,483
Tokens
Yes he did last year against the Colts in the AFC championship game and the year before against Denver

All you have to is put pressure on Shady Brady and he will choke again!

Fukk him and his master Belicheat!


I have to disagree. Brady lost to colts b/c his shit WR dropped sure Td's.
 

New member
Joined
Oct 11, 2004
Messages
2,418
Tokens
I'd Have To Say Payton . Unless Brady Gets 6-8 Secs To Throw The He Seems Like Another Very Good Qb But Not In Mannings Class.
Ne Off Line Has Gotten Their Asses Handed To Them Two Weeks In A Row And Now Mr Brady Doesn't Look So Good.

I'm not a Pats fan but this Brady has forever to throw argument is getting old. Manning has just as much time to throw. In fact look at how many times both of them have been sacked this year. Manning has been sacked 17 times. Brady has been sacked 16 times. Not a real difference, and Manning is even less moble than Brady so how is it Brady has way more time to throw than Manning. And by the way Drew Brees has only been sacked 11 times. Derek Anderson 11 times. Farve 14 times. Garcia 15, Palmer 16, Romo 16, Rivers 16, and Schaub 16. Now I realize some of those guys are mobile and get away from alot of sacks but Manning, Brees, Rivers and Palmer aren't avoiding the rush to often so they obviously must have time to throw as well. Do you realize that Brady has been sacked more times in his career than Manning has, and Manning has played in about 50 more games than Brady.

Oh by the way you say Brady hasn't looked to good in the last 2 weeks. Well he has 637 passing yards in the last 2 games Thats 318.5 yards a game. And one of them was played in a 30 MPH wind.
 

New member
Joined
Oct 11, 2004
Messages
2,418
Tokens
also look at what happens when WR's leave N.E. Dieon Branch was very good in N.E. Now he's average at best with Seattle. Last years leading WR was Reche Caldwell with 61 catches for 760 yards. This year Caldwell has 8 catches for 69 yards with Washington. These guys were all good WR's while in NE but when they leave so do their stats. I wonder why, maybe because Brady makes them better than they really are.
 

Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2006
Messages
16,073
Tokens
I'd be happy with either. Both are winners.
 

New member
Joined
Dec 9, 2006
Messages
4,668
Tokens
I'm not a Pats fan but this Brady has forever to throw argument is getting old. Manning has just as much time to throw. In fact look at how many times both of them have been sacked this year. Manning has been sacked 17 times. Brady has been sacked 16 times. Not a real difference, and Manning is even less moble than Brady so how is it Brady has way more time to throw than Manning. And by the way Drew Brees has only been sacked 11 times. Derek Anderson 11 times. Farve 14 times. Garcia 15, Palmer 16, Romo 16, Rivers 16, and Schaub 16. Now I realize some of those guys are mobile and get away from alot of sacks but Manning, Brees, Rivers and Palmer aren't avoiding the rush to often so they obviously must have time to throw as well. Do you realize that Brady has been sacked more times in his career than Manning has, and Manning has played in about 50 more games than Brady.

Oh by the way you say Brady hasn't looked to good in the last 2 weeks. Well he has 637 passing yards in the last 2 games Thats 318.5 yards a game. And one of them was played in a 30 MPH wind.

when 90% of your offense is passing, your going to get your stats
 

BEER DRINKER
Joined
Dec 20, 2005
Messages
3,030
Tokens
when 90% of your offense is passing, your going to get your stats

i guess that would be a push then

<TABLE id=result _extended="true"><TBODY _extended="true"><TR _extended="true"><TH _extended="true">Rank</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">Team</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">G</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">Pts/G</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">TotPts</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">Att</TH><TH class="sortable sorted order1" _extended="true">Att/G</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">Yds</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">Avg</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">Yds/G</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">TD</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">Lng</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">1st</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">1st%</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">20+</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">40+</TH><TH class=sortable _extended="true">FUM</TH></TR><TBODY _extended="true"><TR class=over _extended="true"><TD _extended="true">1</TD><TD style="WIDTH: 120px; TEXT-ALIGN: left" _extended="true">Pittsburgh Steelers </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD><TD _extended="true">24.7</TD><TD _extended="true">296 </TD><TD _extended="true">405 </TD><TD _extended="true">33.8 </TD><TD _extended="true">1,660 </TD><TD _extended="true">4.1 </TD><TD _extended="true">138.3 </TD><TD _extended="true">7 </TD><TD _extended="true">45 </TD><TD _extended="true">77 </TD><TD _extended="true">19.0 </TD><TD _extended="true">14 </TD><TD _extended="true">1 </TD><TD _extended="true">6 </TD></TR><TR class=darkerRow _extended="true"><TD _extended="true">2</TD><TD style="WIDTH: 120px; TEXT-ALIGN: left" _extended="true">Tennessee Titans </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD><TD _extended="true">19.3</TD><TD _extended="true">232 </TD><TD _extended="true">395 </TD><TD _extended="true">32.9 </TD><TD _extended="true">1,605 </TD><TD _extended="true">4.1 </TD><TD _extended="true">133.8 </TD><TD _extended="true">13 </TD><TD _extended="true">42 </TD><TD _extended="true">88 </TD><TD _extended="true">22.3 </TD><TD _extended="true">10 </TD><TD _extended="true">1 </TD><TD _extended="true">9 </TD></TR><TR class=whiteBack _extended="true"><TD _extended="true">3</TD><TD style="WIDTH: 120px; TEXT-ALIGN: left" _extended="true">Jacksonville Jaguars </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD><TD _extended="true">22.3</TD><TD _extended="true">268 </TD><TD _extended="true">391 </TD><TD _extended="true">32.6 </TD><TD _extended="true">1,692 </TD><TD _extended="true">4.3 </TD><TD _extended="true">141.0 </TD><TD _extended="true">13 </TD><TD _extended="true">76 </TD><TD _extended="true">92 </TD><TD _extended="true">23.5 </TD><TD _extended="true">11 </TD><TD _extended="true">4 </TD><TD _extended="true">3 </TD></TR><TR class=darkerRow _extended="true"><TD _extended="true">4</TD><TD style="WIDTH: 120px; TEXT-ALIGN: left" _extended="true">Oakland Raiders </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD><TD _extended="true">19.5</TD><TD _extended="true">234 </TD><TD _extended="true">382 </TD><TD _extended="true">31.8 </TD><TD _extended="true">1,620 </TD><TD _extended="true">4.2 </TD><TD _extended="true">135.0 </TD><TD _extended="true">9 </TD><TD _extended="true">48 </TD><TD _extended="true">85 </TD><TD _extended="true">22.3 </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD><TD _extended="true">1 </TD><TD _extended="true">8 </TD></TR><TR class=whiteBack _extended="true"><TD _extended="true">5</TD><TD style="WIDTH: 120px; TEXT-ALIGN: left" _extended="true">Minnesota Vikings </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD><TD _extended="true">23.2</TD><TD _extended="true">278 </TD><TD _extended="true">377 </TD><TD _extended="true">31.4 </TD><TD _extended="true">2,122 </TD><TD _extended="true">5.6 </TD><TD _extended="true">176.8 </TD><TD _extended="true">17 </TD><TD _extended="true">73T </TD><TD _extended="true">105 </TD><TD _extended="true">27.9 </TD><TD _extended="true">16 </TD><TD _extended="true">5 </TD><TD _extended="true">9 </TD></TR><TR class=darkerRow _extended="true"><TD _extended="true">6</TD><TD style="WIDTH: 120px; TEXT-ALIGN: left" _extended="true">Washington Redskins </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD><TD _extended="true">19.1</TD><TD _extended="true">229 </TD><TD _extended="true">371 </TD><TD _extended="true">30.9 </TD><TD _extended="true">1,451 </TD><TD _extended="true">3.9 </TD><TD _extended="true">120.9 </TD><TD _extended="true">9 </TD><TD _extended="true">32 </TD><TD _extended="true">84 </TD><TD _extended="true">22.6 </TD><TD _extended="true">4 </TD><TD _extended="true">0 </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD></TR><TR class=whiteBack _extended="true"><TD _extended="true">7</TD><TD style="WIDTH: 120px; TEXT-ALIGN: left" _extended="true">Indianapolis Colts </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD><TD _extended="true">28.1</TD><TD _extended="true">337 </TD><TD _extended="true">358 </TD><TD _extended="true">29.8 </TD><TD _extended="true">1,423 </TD><TD _extended="true">4.0 </TD><TD _extended="true">118.6 </TD><TD _extended="true">15 </TD><TD _extended="true">23 </TD><TD _extended="true">98 </TD><TD _extended="true">27.4 </TD><TD _extended="true">4 </TD><TD _extended="true">0 </TD><TD _extended="true">1 </TD></TR><TR class=darkerRow _extended="true"><TD _extended="true">8</TD><TD style="WIDTH: 120px; TEXT-ALIGN: left" _extended="true">New England Patriots </TD><TD _extended="true">12 </TD><TD _extended="true">39.1</TD><TD _extended="true">469 </TD><TD _extended="true">356 </TD><TD _extended="true">29.7 </TD><TD _extended="true">1,456 </TD><TD _extended="true">4.1 </TD><TD _extended="true">121.3 </TD><TD _extended="true">13 </TD><TD _extended="true">49 </TD><TD _extended="true">103 </TD><TD _extended="true">28.9 </TD><TD _extended="true">2 </TD><TD _extended="true">1 </TD><TD _extended="true">2 </TD></TR><TR class=whiteBack _extended="true"><TD _extended="true">9</TD><TD style="WIDTH: 120px; TEXT-ALIGN: left" _extended="true">New York Giants </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
 

New member
Joined
Sep 20, 2000
Messages
15,635
Tokens
You gotta be shittin me.Brady has acomplished so much more with so much less.You can see lumpy Manning struggle this year with less to work with.
Lumpy is a great HOF QB that is also SB champion and MVP.

...but who do you want running your offense in the last 5 minutes of game when you are behind?
The guy who looks as though he's ready to slide into Giselle or the the guy who looks like its the last place on earth he wants to be is in a game winning/losing drive situation.
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,615
Tokens
Yes he did last year against the Colts in the AFC championship game and the year before against Denver

All you have to is put pressure on Shady Brady and he will choke again!

Fukk him and his master Belicheat!

He also choked in a snowstorm in 2002 but was bailed out by the refs.
 

New member
Joined
Dec 5, 2007
Messages
129
Tokens
He also choked in a snowstorm in 2002 but was bailed out by the refs.

Bailed out? It was a rule. An official rule in the NFL. Just because it was changed the following year doesn't make it a bail out call.

I am far from a Patriots fan, but after seeing what Brady can do with a great line and play makers forces me to say he is better than Peyton.

If you don't think that Wayne, Clarke, Harrison, and Edge were comparable to what New England has now, you aren't watching the same games I am. Peyton had an incredible season when he threw all those touchdowns, but not even close to the season Brady is having this year. In that year Manning had 49 and 10 with 4557 Yards, a 67% completion rate, and a rating of 121.1.

Brady is projected out to finish this year with 55 Td's 7 Int's, 4928 Yards, 70% completion rate and a rating of 123.4. And take into account Brady plays his home games outdoors and Manning plays his in a dome. That year Manning put up those numbers he got sacked 13 times the whole season, Brady has already been sacked 16 times.

People are just blinded by the fact that Boston fans and the Patriots are such pricks so they refuse to admit that now that Brady has weapons he is proving he is a better overall QB.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,106,815
Messages
13,439,080
Members
99,339
Latest member
billcunninghamhomeloans
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com