Gary Sheffield: Hall of Fame?

artiesliver · Jul 30, 2008

21 seasons in the Bigs, will probably get to 500 HR next year, .293 avg, 9-time All Star, 248 SB, played on a WS Champ, Batting Title, Top 100/30 in several major categories (HR, Hits, RBI). Just a thought that came to mind.

ELMO75 · Jul 30, 2008

Doc Gooden's cousin! Also has a little league world series apppearence.
Has the same batting stance at age 12.

artiesliver · Jul 30, 2008

Admitted to using "the Clear".

ELMO75 · Jul 30, 2008

Well at least he didn't Marion Jones about it. More likeable probally not a first ballot guy but has been on several winning teams. Probally has 2 or 3 good years left if he can stay away from the DL.

Harvey Dent · Jul 30, 2008

God No

fletchisrhsm · Jul 31, 2008

I wouldn't vote him in. Not only is he a POS, but he is also a roid eating bastard, he dont deserve it.

Boxer22 · Jul 31, 2008

I think he will absolutely 100% be in the Hall of Fame, and deservingly so. Come on Andre Dawson just made the Hall. Not saying he didn't deserve it but Sheffield is a better player then Dawson.

Numbers: Dawson's after 21 seasons and this is Sheffield's 21st season.

Dawson - All-star Games 8, Homeruns 438, Hits 2774, RBI's 1591, OBP .323, career average .279

Sheffield - All-star Games 9, Homeruns 488, Hits 2573, RBI's 1604, OBP .395, career average .293

wallybell · Jul 31, 2008

Do they have a Hall of Fame for running your mouth? If so, he's a first ballot lock.

artiesliver · Jul 31, 2008

wallybell said:
Do they have a Hall of Fame for running your mouth? If so, he's a first ballot lock.

Good one:missingte

caseymcgillis · Jul 31, 2008

i think the steroid taint will keep alot of guys out of the hall and he will be one of them.

palmeiro, mcgwire, sosa, giambi, clemens, pettite etc etc

Kegler · Jul 31, 2008

Nooooooooooooooooo

Noooooooooooooooooo

Dafinch · Jul 31, 2008

Boxer22 said:
I think he will absolutely 100% be in the Hall of Fame, and deservingly so. Come on Andre Dawson just made the Hall. Not saying he didn't deserve it but Sheffield is a better player then Dawson.

Numbers: Dawson's after 21 seasons and this is Sheffield's 21st season.

Dawson - All-star Games 8, Homeruns 438, Hits 2774, RBI's 1591, OBP .323, career average .279

Sheffield - All-star Games 9, Homeruns 488, Hits 2573, RBI's 1604, OBP .395, career average .293

Andre Dawson just made the Hall? Really? I must've done a Rip Van Winkle and missed that one. As for Sheffield, don't hold your breath:

1) Black and preceived as surly (see Jim Rice and Albert Bell, with the latter being, like Sheffield, a troublemaker to boot)

2) Suspected Juicer

3) Ratted on Bonds for something he, Sheffield, was doing. Not cool, and that all adds up to, no shot...

Boxer22 · Jul 31, 2008

Dafinch said:
Andre Dawson just made the Hall? Really? I must've done a Rip Van Winkle and missed that one. As for Sheffield, don't hold your breath:

1) Black and preceived as surly (see Jim Rice and Albert Bell, with the latter being, like Sheffield, a troublemaker to boot)

2) Suspected Juicer

3) Ratted on Bonds for something he, Sheffield, was doing. Not cool, and that all adds up to, no shot...

Shit. Your right I don't know why I thought Dawson got in. Anyways I think Shef gets in.

Gary Sheffield: Hall of Fame?

Search

artiesliver

Member

ELMO75

New member

artiesliver

Member

ELMO75

New member

Harvey Dent

Banned

fletchisrhsm

New member

Boxer22

New member

wallybell

New member

artiesliver

Member

caseymcgillis

New member

Kegler

God didn't create man. Man created god.

Dafinch

Member

Boxer22

New member

Forum statistics

Share this page