This same CRAP would happen if we went to a CFB playoff

Search

Active member
Joined
Oct 20, 1999
Messages
75,444
Tokens
The FCS(DIV-1AA) is expanding their playoffs...................



The next time Montana plays Albany, it could be in the Division I Football Championship Subdivision playoffs, and it could come the week before Thanksgiving.
That news doesn’t make UM athletic director Jim O’Day happy, but the die has been cast: Last week the NCAA Board of Directors expanded the Football Championship Subdivision playoff field to 20 teams for 2010.
It hands an automatic playoff berth to the Northeast Conference - which Albany, after losing 35-14 to the Griz last September, won in 2007 - and the Big South Conference.
The concurrent increase in at-large and automatic berths (to 10 apiece) keeps the FCS on an even keel, and leaves the door open for more expansion in the future. So says Doug Fullerton, the Big Sky Conference commissioner.
“There’s a guideline,” Fullerton said Friday from the Big Sky offices in Ogden, Utah. “It’s kind of like ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’: It’s more a guideline than a rule.
“But we were afraid that a board of directors was going to say, ‘We’re going to leave your playoffs at 16 teams, but you’re going to have 12 automatic berths.’ This is a commitment not just to expanding the championship now, it’s a commitment to expanding whenever else it is necessary.”
It means another tier of playoff games, budgeted for by the NCAA to the tune of $500,000 per year. O’Day said that added week isn’t necessarily a good thing.
“I don’t know at this point that I’m real in support of this,” O’Day said Friday. “One of the major concerns for us is how are we going to fit this into our schedule. And for us, selfishly, it could mean changes to the Montana-Montana State game being at the end of the year.
“There are teams that are well into scheduling for 2010, so you might have to make buyouts. It also could mean more class time away, which I’m not in favor of.”
The expansion also means the FCS season will remain at 11 games over 12 weeks, allowing for a bye week. The Big Sky, which increased from eight to nine teams in 2006, has been able to keep a bye at the end of the season, and that has allowed the Griz-Cat game to be played as a regular-season finale.
Then the Griz, for the last 15 seasons anyway, have gone into the FCS playoffs on Thanksgiving weekend.
With the FCS not wanting to move its title game any later - it was Dec. 14 last season - and not wanting to start its season in August, something has to give.
In the end the pros outweigh the cons, said Fullerton. The Division I FCS increased its playoff field from 12 to 16 teams in 1987. Since then the FCS, formerly Division I-AA, has added 28 teams and now numbers 122.
That playoff ratio is the lowest in the NCAA, according to Fullerton. The subdivision has gotten around it by not including nonscholarship leagues like the Pioneer and Ivy in the playoff picture. But the Ivy League has an automatic berth into the NCAA basketball tournament, so that argument may not hold up down the road.
Division II uses a 24-team bracket, and the FCS may not be far behind. The Great West is about to add two more teams in North Dakota and South Dakota. It’s possible the Ivy League may want to send a team to the FCS playoffs, and Pioneer power San Diego certainly wanted to go in 2006.
Fullerton helped write a proposal to allow the expansion of the playoff bracket each time an FCS league becomes eligible: In essence, if a conference has six schools that are Division I in all sports, it can lobby for an automatic playoff berth.
 

Active member
Joined
Oct 20, 1999
Messages
75,444
Tokens
We don't need no stinkin playoff at the DIV 1-A level...........ever!!


The current system is terriffic.


By the way, congrats to NORTHERN IOWA on reaching the semi-finals of the FCS...........they will take on Richmond next week and the game will be televised on ESPN2.
 

Conservatives, Patriots & Huskies return to glory
Handicapper
Joined
Sep 9, 2005
Messages
85,758
Tokens
I don't know about that terrific part Fish.

Texas, USC & Penn St can all make compelling arguments for a playoff of some sort. Maybe even Bama, Ohio St, Utah & Boise.

I don't think that encouraging coaches to run up the score is a good system. The coaches with class, Joe Pa?, won't play that game in the final minutes.

I also don't think any system that relies on some RPI type system is practicable. What on earth did last night's game between Hawaii & Cinci have to do with proving who is the best team in the country?

I like also the bowls. How about a four team playoff after the bowls? The four highest rated BCS Bowl winners.
 

New member
Joined
Jan 31, 2007
Messages
2,278
Tokens
we don't need no stinkin playoff at the div 1-a level...........ever!!


The current system is terriffic.


By the way, congrats to northern iowa on reaching the semi-finals of the fcs...........they will take on richmond next week and the game will be televised on espn2.
why conrats to them ? Are they not in a playoff hunt for a champ gm if they keep winning?
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Jan 20, 2002
Messages
6,929
Tokens
Sorry but you are fucked out of your mind to think we don't need a playoff. I have seen you making this statement all season but the current system is a bunch of bullshit. Your statement is like saying the last team left out of the ncaa basketball tournament had a right to bitch about being excluded. With an 8 team playoff system we can all agree that the top of the top will be included. The 9th team (the first team left out) will still bitch but we are not talking about a Penn State, a USC or a Texas. Beyond those teams, who has a real, legitimate beef? Utah will get fucking steamrolled if they play Alabama. Yeah, I know, Boise beat Oklahoma a few years ago but Oklahoma didn't take that game seriously.

Case and point: last year everyone thought Hawaii deserved a chance. Georgia just scored again (unfortunately so did Nebraska on my Gators).
 

New member
Joined
Jun 25, 2005
Messages
7,018
Tokens
There is a common denominator in arguing playoff in college foots and the DH in baseball.

The designated hitter is used in every form of league through out the planet.

Even the NL farm teams use it as these pitchers have never had a bat in their hands when the arrive in the bigs.

Every sport on the planet has a playoff system except for NCAA football.

Actually besides the six conferences that get the lions share of the money pie,we are playing right into the NCAA's hands.

We are typing and jawing about this Pandora's box as are media outlets across the nation keeping the conversations going well after the championship game is over.

Thats like free advertising,it's priceless.
 

Nirvana Shill
Joined
Oct 20, 2001
Messages
28,497
Tokens
We don't need no stinkin playoff at the DIV 1-A level...........ever!!


The current system is terriffic.


By the way, congrats to NORTHERN IOWA on reaching the semi-finals of the FCS...........they will take on Richmond next week and the game will be televised on ESPN2.

Not sure if my word for this system would be terrific. When you play your exhibition games at the end of the season instead of the beginning like every other sport. Why not just use the 4 BCS games now and play them off. How is that not making things better for the sport, instead of all of us all arguing on which 1 loss team should play in big game, and at the same time leave the undefeated teams on the outside. Some of the greatest champions in other sports weren't seeded #1 or #2 going into their particular playoff , but at the end of the playoffs, you didn't have doubt that they were the champion. You have that doubt almost every year in CFB. Thats not terrrific
 
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
20,303
Tokens
We don't need no stinkin playoff at the DIV 1-A level...........ever!!


The current system is terriffic.


By the way, congrats to NORTHERN IOWA on reaching the semi-finals of the FCS...........they will take on Richmond next week and the game will be televised on ESPN2.

You are an idiot
 

New member
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Messages
7,373
Tokens
Sports is supposed to be entertainment at this level and the BCS system is boring as hell.


We don't need no stinkin playoff at the DIV 1-A level...........ever!!


The current system is terriffic.


By the way, congrats to NORTHERN IOWA on reaching the semi-finals of the FCS...........they will take on Richmond next week and the game will be televised on ESPN2.
 

New member
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Messages
7,373
Tokens
I think you made a good argument against having DH in any league. If you did that, you would not get pitchers who can't bat for their life.
Which isn't to say some big league pitchers can't bat...Carlos Zambrano is a better hitter than many position players.


There is a common denominator in arguing playoff in college foots and the DH in baseball.

The designated hitter is used in every form of league through out the planet.

Even the NL farm teams use it as these pitchers have never had a bat in their hands when the arrive in the bigs.
 

Uno

Ban Teddy
Joined
Apr 22, 2006
Messages
7,057
Tokens
i agree with EGD. imagine a final four of UT, USC, OU and FLA...

holy cow what an amazing three weeks we would have if we had an 8 team playoff.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,587
Messages
13,452,618
Members
99,423
Latest member
lbplayer
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com