Cleveland Browns offer...

cut-paste-hero · Mar 23, 2009

Braylon Edwards to New Yorks Giants for 2nd and 5th round and Steve Smith

Giants counter with Mario Manningham, or Dominick Hickson....

@)

Thoughts?

JakeT. · Mar 23, 2009

Giants should make the move if they want to compete with the Patriots this year. It's a tall asking price for a guy that drops the ball as much as Braylon would he would create some big mismatches in the secondary if New York retains Plax. That offense would be scary and the defense will improve with a healthy Umenyiora. Browns should take the picks since they need quite a few pieces.

I like it for both teams.

Gravy · Mar 23, 2009

Just want the Browns need another Michigan WR in Manningham for Edwards :>(

asufan550 · Mar 23, 2009

Steve Smith will be a very good receiver in the NFL. No reason to give all that up for the very overrated Edwards.

Samhain · Mar 23, 2009

As a Giants, I'm not sure about this deal. Smith has a lot of potential.

As for being worried about the Patriots...They're yesterdays news.
As s Giants fan I'm more worried about the Eagles.