Lets make a list........
NFC West.........Hasselbeck.......Warner
NFC North.......Cutler......jury still out on Rodgers
NFC East.......Romo......McNabb....Manning
NFC South.....Ryan.......Brees.......Delhome
AFC West......Rivers
AFC North......Rothlesburger.....Palmer
AFC East......Brady
AFC South....Manning....Garrad
That makes 15.........what's your list?
NFC West.........Hasselbeck.......Warner
NFC North.......Cutler......jury still out on Rodgers
NFC East.......Romo......McNabb....Manning
NFC South.....Ryan.......Brees.......Delhome
AFC West......Rivers
AFC North......Rothlesburger.....Palmer
AFC East......Brady
AFC South....Manning....Garrad
That makes 15.........what's your list?
think Vick at his best (before all this mess) was better than an avg NFL qb...
no team wanted to face him...what he lacked in accuracy, he more than made up for in speed, creativity and mobility....
of that list above, i would consider Vick (prior to this mess) better than Hasselback , Cutler, Romo, Ryan, Delhomme, Rivers, and Garrad...
now that being said, some of those guys may eventually prove to be better than he was, but taking what those guys give me right now, and what Vick gave you BEFORE his arrest, i would take him as my starter....
no team wanted to face him...what he lacked in accuracy, he more than made up for in speed, creativity and mobility....
of that list above, i would consider Vick (prior to this mess) better than Hasselback , Cutler, Romo, Ryan, Delhomme, Rivers, and Garrad...
now that being said, some of those guys may eventually prove to be better than he was, but taking what those guys give me right now, and what Vick gave you BEFORE his arrest, i would take him as my starter....
That's easy to look at when all you doing is picking up a paper and looking at stats. Ask the defensive lines and linebackers, they will tell you they prefer to face anybody but Vick. A defensive coach can't defend what Vick was bringing to the game. Plus Vick brought excitement that only 1 or 2 people in the league could generate. He was a QB that could go the distance from 70 or 80 yards out which most RB can't do except for Peterson and Reggie Bush. Damn! I miss that excitement.
Is 7.3 yards per rush better than average?
While it is true he could really only do one thing well, he did it better than anyone else in history. Most teams in the NFL would have been able to move the ball more efficiently if they had Vick when he was at his best. The question is how much did he slip in his years away from the game. There really isn't a long history of athletes going away at the top and coming back a full three years later. If I was a GM I would consider him outside the top half of starting QBs. That means almost half the teams in the league should consider signing him
take off hasselbeck. he is no good anymore, seahawks looking to dump him for awhile. I'd add Rodgers to the list. I'd take off Delhomme and Palmer. Palmer is too injury prone and I don't see him doing much again. And take off Garrard.
So yea I'd take 12 over Vick. The rest are mediocre like Vick, except they can't run.
