5 dimes HR Derby props..how do you think they would grade this

If two guys tie for the most HR's in first round (say puk and howard both get 20 and tie)..do you think they would pay the full yes price on both players??? as it is written? Same quesiton on the No? would you lose full price on both..what do you guys think? there is certaintly some shot at a tie 10% or so? thinking of playing Pujols and Howard and Fielder all YES..then if one wins you have a small profit but if two happen to tie big profit...and if a long shot wins so be it...

these are all from 5 dimes..shoping around as I think ive seen Fielder 1st round as high as 3-1 also..


<TABLE class=module borderColor=#111111 cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width=800 border=0 rgfloat="440,600"><TBODY><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=bottom bgColor=#f6f6f6><TD noWrap>Mon 7/13</TD><TD noWrap>401 </TD><TD noWrap>A.Pujols has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M1_36> +250 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=top bgColor=#f6f6f6><TD noWrap>8:00PM (EST) </TD><TD noWrap>402</TD><TD noWrap>Field has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M2_36> -300 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=bottom bgColor=#e9eeee><TD noWrap>Mon 7/13</TD><TD noWrap>403 </TD><TD noWrap>R.Howard has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M1_37> +250 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=top bgColor=#e9eeee><TD noWrap>8:00PM (EST) </TD><TD noWrap>404</TD><TD noWrap>Field has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M2_37> -300 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=bottom bgColor=#f6f6f6><TD noWrap>Mon 7/13</TD><TD noWrap>405 </TD><TD noWrap>A.Gonzalez has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M1_38> +600 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=top bgColor=#f6f6f6><TD noWrap>8:00PM (EST) </TD><TD noWrap>406</TD><TD noWrap>Field has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M2_38> -900 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=bottom bgColor=#e9eeee><TD noWrap>Mon 7/13</TD><TD noWrap>407 </TD><TD noWrap>J.Mauer has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M1_39> +650 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=top bgColor=#e9eeee><TD noWrap>8:00PM (EST) </TD><TD noWrap>408</TD><TD noWrap>Field has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M2_39> -1000 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=bottom bgColor=#f6f6f6><TD noWrap>Mon 7/13</TD><TD noWrap>409 </TD><TD noWrap>P.Fielder has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M1_40> +250 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=top bgColor=#f6f6f6><TD noWrap>8:00PM (EST) </TD><TD noWrap>410</TD><TD noWrap>Field has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M2_40> -300 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=bottom bgColor=#e9eeee><TD noWrap>Mon 7/13</TD><TD noWrap>411 </TD><TD noWrap>N.Cruz has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M1_41> +600 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=top bgColor=#e9eeee><TD noWrap>8:00PM (EST) </TD><TD noWrap>412</TD><TD noWrap>Field has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M2_41> -900 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=bottom bgColor=#f6f6f6><TD noWrap>Mon 7/13</TD><TD noWrap>413 </TD><TD noWrap>B.Inge has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M1_42> +800 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=top bgColor=#f6f6f6><TD noWrap>8:00PM (EST) </TD><TD noWrap>414</TD><TD noWrap>Field has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M2_42> -1250 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=bottom bgColor=#e9eeee><TD noWrap>Mon 7/13</TD><TD noWrap>415 </TD><TD noWrap>C.Pena has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M1_43> +500 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR><TR style="HEIGHT: 28px" vAlign=top bgColor=#e9eeee><TD noWrap>8:00PM (EST) </TD><TD noWrap>416</TD><TD noWrap>Field has most HR in round 1</TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap><INPUT id=editx maxLength=5 size=4 name=M2_43> -700 </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD><TD noWrap> </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>

Not sure how they will grade it but I like the price on Gonzalez.

Is this a juice free contest. I see AROD isn't entered.

It would be more exiting if they allowed juicers

I think they should pay both at +125

It should be a push if they finish tied and the money should be refunded. Not sure how they would grade it though.

What if it were a horse race ?

dead heat for 1st and 2nd

pool is split, right ?

I disagree with a refund on all bets. The other players lost, so split between the two that tied, IMO.

If you played Pujols, Fielder and Howard all for 100 and they all lost you lose 300

if one wins you still only win 50 bucks...to win 1/6 of what you put up on that scenario isn't worth it IMO...if you are going to do this I would at least do it with three longshots

This one isn't even very debatable, IMO. Try should know to treat this like a dead-heat in horses, since he bets horses. I'd fully expect Tony ( or any other bookie) to split the pot... return stake, pay at 50% on winnings, if two tie... you only had a half win, the way I see it.

Pretty clear to me, and the guy that thinks all bets should push is just wrong.

Problem is that the rule doesn't say what happens if there is a tie. I know in a lot of circumstances the rule may say that it will be graded as a dead heat.

This would be a tie I believe

Push and no bet.

how was the tie graded ?

i did not play it so I dont know..found a much better price on Howard at another shop and keyed on that one..