Should The Eagles start Kolb over McNabb?

Mr_Mark · Oct 21, 2009

Game 1 vs Panthers (WIN) 10/18 79 yards - inj
Kevin Kolb 7/11 23 yards

Game 2 vs Saints (LOSS) Kevin Kolb 31/51 391 yards

Game 3 vs Chiefs (WIN) Kevin Kolb 24/34 327 yards

Game 4 vs Bucs (WIN) McNabb 16/21 264 yards

Game 5 vs Raiders (LOSS) McNabb 22/46 269 yards

McNabb
tds - 5
int - 1
total yards - 612
rating 93.8

Kolb
tds - 4
int - 3
total yards - 741
rating 88.9

Both have played well but even without the numbers did the Eagles look more impressive with Kolb in there instead of McNabb?

beejmi · Oct 21, 2009

You play McNabb. Kolb has had one good game in his career and vs a subpar team (KC)

Vick hasn't shown a thing.

Nothing to think about honestly.

ProPokerPlayer · Oct 21, 2009

McNabb could QB a winning team. This isnt a winning team.
I dont think they bench him until attendance drops or that QB rating gets around the low 80's..

maxdemo · Oct 21, 2009

Kolb will be a stud in this league if given the chance...JMO

WharfRat+ · Oct 21, 2009

Huge HUGE Eagles Fan. And I hate McNabb. Not sure Kolb is the answer though. I was hoping for Cutler for Mcnabb this past off season.

TempleU22 · Oct 21, 2009

hahahahahahahahahahahaha... This was made as a joke right?

Just in case it isn't, Kolb will never have what it takes to be a good quarterback in this league. He'll be a decent backup, but watching him play makes me want to poke my eyes out.

It would have been pure comedy to see him play last week with the way that offensive line played. Now that we have lost the game, I really wish he did play for pure entertainment value.

EstebanOchocinco · Oct 21, 2009

saints are the best team in the nfl or only the best offensive team? because kolb put up 9 yards short of a 400 yard passing game. he seems to be good enough to be a starter to me. eagles dont have any probowl recievers, possibly desean jackson in the future but him and mcnabb dont have great depth at wr position

3peet · Oct 22, 2009

Feagles fans throwin in the towel already? Gimmie a break man. McNabb easily over sorry ass Kolb.

FZA · Oct 22, 2009

i like both mcnabb and kolb but with mcnabbs experience he gets the starting job

2PLAYSMAX · Oct 22, 2009

Got to go with McNabb. It's not like they are 1-4. A lot of issues stem with the all too predictable play calling.

1st and 10 dump pass to Westbrook for 2 yard gain
2nd and 8 incomplete pass
3rd and 8 sacked
4th PUNT

Boxer22 · Oct 22, 2009

McNabb will start the rest of this season. If by any chance they fall short of the playoffs, McNabb will be released and they will develop Kolb. If they make the playoffs it will most likely be the same shit next year. That's my opinion on this anyways.

eaglezzz · Oct 23, 2009

When the Eagles win the Super Bowl this year and they will, all the McNabb and Reid haters will turn into McNabb and Reid fans. Kinda like what Eli and Coughlin did when they won the super bowl. McNabb is the man in my opinion, all that he does is win for this team and is critizised every year. I know he hasn't won a Super Bowl yet and if and when he does I think people start to recognize McNabb as one of the Elite QB's to ever play in the NFL. As for Philly fans once this guy is out of the league you will realize how great you really had it with McNabb, he will go down as the greatest QB in Eagles history easy.

I do think Kolb has all the tools to be a solid starting QB in the future, but really he is setting him self up for a great career. If it is in Philly or somewhere else he will be a top ten starting QB, as for now he is a backup learning the ropes.

eaglezzz · Oct 23, 2009

One more thing on this subject Yes the Eagles lost to the Raiders which is more than embarrasing and now people are writing this team off - what a joke. With the next 3 games all division games if the Eagles win in Washington on Monday night and then the next week win at home to the Giants and then beat Dallas the following week at home as well the Eagles will be sitting at 6-2 and in First place in the division. That Raiders loss might turn out to be the best thing that could happen to this team. Watch out the Eagles will get their shit together and in the weeks you will be bitching about how bad Eli Manning and Tony Romo are looking. Anything can happen any week, and we are only in week 7 so lets not get ahead of ourselves and write McNabb and the Eagles off just yet.

Should The Eagles start Kolb over McNabb?

Search

Who To Start

McNabb

Kolb

Vick?

Mr_Mark

Member

beejmi

Member

ProPokerPlayer

I'll be in the Bar..With my head on the Bar

maxdemo

And if the Road Warrior says it, it must be true..

WharfRat+

Stumblin' around, drunk on burgundy wine.

TempleU22

New member

EstebanOchocinco

New member

3peet

L5Y, USC is 4-0 vs SEC, outscoring them 167-48!!!

FZA

New member

2PLAYSMAX

I think I want my money back!

Boxer22

New member

eaglezzz

New member

eaglezzz

New member

Forum statistics

Share this page