Who's the Better QB, Tony Romo ? Donovan McNabb ?

Betallsports · Nov 6, 2009

I think this is a Tough question....Neither one is "Great" IMO

But They Meet this week......

Who's a Better QB ?

LostBankroll · Nov 6, 2009

I think McNabb IS GREAT. Romo could be great if he could win in the postseason. Both have attributes that other QBs wished they had.

OccamsRazor · Nov 6, 2009

McNabb has been there and done that. Romo claim to fame was a dumb blond girlfriend with big , what has he done?

Most NFL purists would say the question is offensive.

Betallsports · Nov 6, 2009

What's Great about McNabb ? Compare him to which Great QB ?

Where does he stand on the All time Greatest QB's ?

HacheMan · Nov 6, 2009

I personally don't think Romo is in McNabb's league.

If only McNabb would have had the receivers he currently has now to help him when they had a more completle team in recent years past, he would have won a Super Bowl already.....

viking611 · Nov 6, 2009

not even comparable. Mcnabb is far ahead of romo. Let me know when Romo takes his team somewhere in the playoffs.

STACKSONDECK · Nov 6, 2009

why do people compare mcnabb to qbs like vick and tarvaris jackson that is so dumb. they also say he is a running qb which is also dumb. being able to run if need be and looking to run first are two different things.

Betallsports · Nov 6, 2009

STACKS ON DECK said:
why do people compare mcnabb to qbs like vick and tarvaris jackson that is so dumb. they also say he is a running qb which is also dumb. being able to run if need be and looking to run first are two different things.

Did I miss something ? Who's comparing him to Vick or Jackson ?

s fr as "Running" QB.....ther are "Pocket" Qb's, and Everything else.

STACKSONDECK · Nov 6, 2009

Betallsports said:
Did I miss something ? Who's comparing him to Vick or Jackson ?

s fr as "Running" QB.....ther are "Pocket" Qb's, and Everything else.

i wasnt saying you or the title of you thread i meant people in general. they're threads when his name comes up that posters have said this. not you

Betallsports · Nov 6, 2009

STACKS ON DECK said:
i wasnt saying you or the title of you thread i meant people in general. they're threads when his name comes up that posters have said this. not you

I Totally Understand (<)<

HPark1 · Nov 6, 2009

I like McNabb but Romo is a better QB and will have a more successful career when all said and done.

McNabb has too many stretches were he is simply inaccurate.

texansfan · Nov 6, 2009

HPark1 said:
I like McNabb but Romo is a better QB and will have a more successful career when all said and done.

McNabb has too many stretches were he is simply inaccurate.

Well, he's at least 4 NFC championships and 1 SB behind. Romo has never done anything past November.

RobFunk · Nov 6, 2009

Well, my Giants beat Romo but not Mcnabb So I give Donovan the nod. We were pretty banged up when we faced the Eagles though.

And as texasfan states "Romo has never done anything past November." IS another reason I will go with Mcnabb. To me Donovan is the better pure athlete, clear cut.

VIEJODINOSAUR · Nov 6, 2009

Betallsports said:
I think this is a Tough question....Neither one is "Great" IMO

But They Meet this week......

Who's a Better QB ?

I really don't know why you asked....should have said Romo, Stafford, or Sanchez....

How many playoff games has Romo won?

99steak · Nov 7, 2009

mcnabb easily beats romo but i wouldnt say mcnabb belongs in the same list as all time greats.

VIEJODINOSAUR · Nov 7, 2009

How many other QB's have been to the conference finals 5 out of the last 9 years....McNabb has...

oldirtyku · Nov 7, 2009

mcNasty 2 nasty...

Birdman · Nov 7, 2009

Pleeeeease. Thread must have started with Cowboy lover.

celticGreen+ · Nov 7, 2009

Mcnabb = 2nd tier QB (behind peyton, brees, and brady)
Romo = something lower than 2nd tier for sure

braddllee2 · Nov 7, 2009

My man Tony Romo !

Who's the Better QB, Tony Romo ? Donovan McNabb ?

Member

Rx Junior

A Separate Reality

Member

hacheman@therx.com

www.youtubecom/hubbardsmusic

MY HEART IS A HOME AND FEAR DONT LIVE HERE

Member

MY HEART IS A HOME AND FEAR DONT LIVE HERE

Member

New member

Member

RX Senior

Member

Medium Rare

Member

Rx Senior

New member

New member

New member

Forum statistics

Share this page