If Payton Manning gets a second ring this year , is he the best ever ?

WorldNumberOne · Dec 17, 2009

Is 2 rings for Manning enough to vault him over Montana as the greatest QB ever ?

Or over whoever is considered the best ?

Do we rate the greatest ever by the number of rings ?

badbeat1015 · Dec 17, 2009

He still has to break the records.

HacheMan · Dec 17, 2009

If I had to choose between Peyton Or Favre as being the best ever or who I would rather have as a young, franchise QB, I'd just throw their names in a hat & draw one out.

I like Joe Montana and used to think he was the best ever, but now I look back and believe he had more to work with over his career in San Francisco who was also a top notch organization who knew what they were doing.

It's no coincidence that Steve Young had so much success there also......

sumday · Dec 17, 2009

I believe Manning is the best ever already.

oldmanTED · Dec 17, 2009

Nope!

awmllc2000 · Dec 17, 2009

easily the best ever!

Indifference · Dec 17, 2009

Last time I checked 2 is less then 3 or 4.

steaktartar · Dec 17, 2009

rings are not the only criteria for greatness.......manning if he gets another ring or not is in the aikman/tarkenton era and very possibly joe montana like rememberance.....he is one of the best ever as is marino who has no rings.......

WorldNumberOne · Dec 17, 2009

Indifference said:
Last time I checked 2 is less then 3 or 4.

so the number of rings defines for you the greatest qb ever ?

does that make franco harris the greatest running back ever ?

tooran · Dec 17, 2009

If this were the 40's, Manning would be a legendary WWII general. I have nothing but respect for him.

doubledeuce22 · Dec 17, 2009

Hache Man said:
If I had to choose between Peyton Or Favre as being the best ever or who I would rather have as a young, franchise QB, I'd just throw their names in a hat & draw one out.

I like Joe Montana and used to think he was the best ever, but now I look back and believe he had more to work with over his career in San Francisco who was also a top notch organization who knew what they were doing.

It's no coincidence that Steve Young had so much success there also......

or maybe steve young was pretty good too :think2:

ChrisParadise · Dec 17, 2009

i often wonder where charles woodson rates in the greatest ever arguments....

Seymour · Dec 17, 2009

Manning is the best QB to ever play already - this ain't hoops - he's only on the field about 47% of the time

celticGreen+ · Dec 17, 2009

I love me some Pats and Brady, but I'd still say Manning is the best ever... If Farve were to get another ring this year we might have to revisit this.

red007 · Dec 18, 2009

montana is the greatest qb i've ever seen.

lifexpired · Dec 18, 2009

montana best qb, though marino and elway are close imo (was born in 79, so not commenting on those i didnt see in years prior)

barman · Dec 18, 2009

Payton Manning will have a hard time eclipsing the historical greatness of Walter Peyton.

:drink:

cincy_ · Dec 18, 2009

Unless any QB can win 5 titles over their career, they won't be the best ever (for me).

Manning, and 10 other QBs are "in the debate" right now but nobody stands out among them.

Babe Ruth, Gretzky, and Pele are undoubtedly the best ever. There is nobody like that on football.

primetime21+ · Dec 18, 2009

Chris Paradise said:
i often wonder where charles woodson rates in the greatest ever arguments....

Somewhere behind Darrelle Revis.

Railbird · Dec 19, 2009

Pressure Peyton thru the A gap and guard Clark and he aint shit. He will fail in January just like always.

If Payton Manning gets a second ring this year , is he the best ever ?

Self appointed RX World Champion Handicapper

New member

hacheman@therx.com

Rx. Junior

Professional At All Times

RX Prophet

Member

powdered milkman

Self appointed RX World Champion Handicapper

New member

Member

New member

Member

New member

New member

New member

Honey Badger Don't Give A Shit

New member

New member

The Great Govenor of California

Forum statistics

Share this page