My Directv vs. Comcast comparison

Search

And if the Road Warrior says it, it must be true..
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
15,481
Tokens
My Directv vs. Comcast comparison..

I have had Directv for over 4 years now. Just recently the place where I live switched from TV-max to Comcast, and I decided to try Comcast Digital Preferred package for a special price of $39.99 per month/ 1st month $25.00. I went ahead and contacted Directv and suspended my service for 2 months. This was April 1st.


Reception:

Directv: In the 4 years I have had Directv i was never out of service for more than 12 hours. The service would go out during some hard rain storms but it would restore its self quick. Sometimes under 15 min.

Comcast: After 2 weeks of Comcast the service went out for 3 days. When i called to ask what was up they acted like there was no problem in my area. They then wasted an hour of my time rebooting and re-powering their converter box....during this time I was disconnected from the service tech. When I called back they then told me that they had a service outage in my area and that they had technicians in the area working on the problem....even though it was after midnight.

Winner: DirecTV

Picture Clarity:

I have a Sony Projection TV
proj-700280.JPG




Directv: IMO on my TV the picture was always clear and crisp. The Audio was excellent. The music channels would sound great on my surround sound system

ComCast: The picture was not as crisp and some channels the color was off. Audio was not that great. The music channels were not great sounding and their selection was kinda limited....IMO

Winner: DirecTV


Customer Service:

Comcast: Please read reception above for my experience.

Directv: I never had a problem w/ Directv customer service and could always get discounts if you threaten to stop service.

Winner: DirecTV


Channel Line up and selection:

Comcast Digital Preferred

* 150 channels
* Encore channels and On Demand programming



Digital Starter

1 Channel 1 On Demand
119 Lifetime Movie Network*
129 Comcast Sports Southwest
340 Style* - ON
800 - 845 Music Choice Channels - ON
Expanded Basic Service

21 USA*- ON (ECON)
22 Cartoon Network* + - ON (ECON)
23 A&E- ON*
24 Hallmark Channel
25 CNN- ON*
26 Headline News
27 The Weather Channel
28 QVC
29 Discovery* - ON (ECON)
30 MTV- ON
31 FX* - ON
32 ABC Family*
33 ESPN*
34 ESPN2*
35 Golf Channel* - ON
36 TNT- ON*
37 Fox Sports Houston*
38 FOX News*
39 Turner Classic Movies
40 Lifetime - ON*
41 Disney Channel- ON*
42 Animal Planet- ON*
43 Nickelodeon- ON*
44 E!- ON*
45 CNBC
46 BET- ON
47 HGTV* - ON
48 Spike TV* - ON (ECON)
49 Versus- ON*
50 Galavisión
51 TBS* - ON
52 Food Network- ON*
56 C-SPAN
57 AMC- ON*
58 History- ON*
59 Comedy Central- ON
60 SyFy* - ON
61 VH1 - ON
62 Travel Channel- ON*
63 TLC* - ON
64 HSN
65 Bravo
66 Discovery Health- ON
67 truTV (ECON)
80 MSNBC
Basic Service

2 KNWS
3 KZJL
4 KTXH - My Network TV*
5 KIAH - CW*
6 KTMD - Telemundo
7 KPXB - ION
8 KUHT - PBS*
9 KRIV - FOX*
10 KXLN - Univision
11 KHOU - CBS* - ON
12 KPRC - NBC* - ON
13 KTRK - ABC* - ON
14 KETH - TBN
15 KFTH - Telefutura
16 Municipal Channel
17 Houston Media Source
18 Houston ISD
19 HCC TV
20 KLTJ - Day Star+
53 KAZH TuVision
54 WGN
55 KTBU - The Tube
74 KUVM - Azteca
75 Leased Access+
76 Leased Access+
310 11 NOW+
315 13NOW+
319 Universal Sports
320 THIS - TV+
321 KPRC - LA TV+
322 KLTJ+
323 KUHT2 PBS+
324 KUHT - V - ME+
325 KHLM - TV Informa+
326 KVQT - Vision Celestial+
604 KTXH - My Network TV HD*
605 KIAH - CW39 HD
607 KPXB - ION HD
608 KUHT - PBS HD
609 KRIV - FOX HD
611 KHOU - CBS HD
612 KPRC - NBC HD
613 KTRK - ABC HD
Digital Preferred

100 TV Guide Network (ECON)
101 NBA TV - ON*
102 Reelz TV
103 Hallmark Movie Channel*
106 CBS College Sports
107 Current TV
108 MLB Network*
109 ESPN Classic
110 Fox Soccer Channel
113 NFL Network
116 ESPNews
117 WE - ON
118 Ovation
124 NHL Network
125 ESPNU
126 Fit TV
128 PBS Kids Sprout- ON
141 MTV Tr3s - ON
149 MoviePlex - ON
160 LOGO- ON
167 Indieplex
168 Retroplex
170 Flix
172 Gospel Music Channel - ON
173 TV One- ON
174 Jewelry TV (ECON)
175 Shop NBC
202 Inspiration Network
204 EWTN
205 NASA Channel
208 CSPAN 2 (ECON)
209 CSPAN 3
211 DIY- ON
212 G4 - ON
213 Investigation Discovery- ON
218 Great American Country
219 VH1 Classic Rock
220 MTV2 - ON
221 Fuse - ON
222 Country Music Television - ON
223 Centric
225 Fine Living
226 BBC America- ON
228 Biography*
229 History International
230 Texas Cable News
234 Fox Business*
235 Bloomberg
238 Si TV
239 Mun2 - ON
240 The Africa Channel
241 ImaginAsian TV
250 Fox Reality
252 tvK
327 Oxygen- ON
328 Planet Green*
329 Soapnet
335 National Geographic* - ON
336 Discovery Kids- ON
337 Science Channel* - ON
338 Military Channel - ON
339 Game Show Network
341 Disney XD- ON
342 Nick Jr. - ON
343 Boomerang - ON
346 TV Land
347 TeenNick - ON
348 Nicktoons
349 Cartoon Network
397 Fox Movie Channel
398 Sundance - ON
399 Independent Film Channel- ON
400 Encore- ON*
402 Encore Love
403 Encore Westerns
404 Encore Mystery
405 Encore Action
673 HDNet*
674 Palladia*
675 Universal HD*
696 Encore HD - ON*


The placements of the channels was confusing. The guide also lacked the functionality of the DirecTV guide.

Directv Choice Extra:

210+ digital channels

Print channels for ZIP Code 77079
A&E 265
ABC Family 311
American Movie Classics (AMC) 254
Animal Planet 282
BBC America 264
BYU TV 374
Big Ten Network 610
Biography Channel 266
Black Entertainment Television (BET) 329
Bloomberg Television 353
Boomerang 298
Bravo 273
CMT 327
CNBC 355
CNBC World 357
CNN 202
CSPAN 1 350
CSPAN 2 351
Cartoon Network (East) 296
Cartoon Network (West) 297
Centric 330
Chiller 257
Christian Television Network (CTN) 376
Church Channel 371
Comedy Central 249
Current TV 358
DIY Network 230
Daystar 369
Discovery Channel 278
Discovery Health 279
Discovery Kids 294
Disney Channel (East) 290
Disney Channel (West) 291
Disney XD 292
Documentary Channel 263
E! Entertainment 236

ESPN 206
ESPN U 614
ESPN2 209
ESPNEWS 207
EWTN 370
Enlace Christian Television 448
FX 248
Fine Living 232
Fit TV 261
Food Network 231
Fox Business Network 359
Fox Movie Channel 258
Fox News Channel 360
Fox Reality 250
Fuel 618
Fuse 339
G4 310
GEM NET (Global Expansion Media Network) 2068
GOD TV 365
GSN, the network for games 309
Galavision 404
GemsTV 233
Golf Channel 218
Gospel Music Channel 338
Great American Country 326
HD Theater 281
HDNet 306
HITN 438
Hallmark Channel 312
Headline News 204
History Channel 269
History International 271
Home & Garden Television (HGTV) 229
Home Shopping Network 240
Hope 368
INSP 364

ION Television 305
ION Television West 347
Independent Film Channel (IFC) 559
Investigation Discovery (ID) 285
Jewelry Television 313
Jewish Life Television 366
Lifetime 252
Lifetime Movie Network 253
LinkTV 375
Logo 272
MHz WORLDVIEW 2183
MLB Network 213
MSNBC 356
MTV 331
MTV2 333
Military Channel 287
NASA TV 283
NBA TV 216
NFL Network 212
NHL Network 215
NRB 378
National Geographic Channel 276
Nick Jr. 301
Nickelodeon (East) 299
Nickelodeon (West) 300
Nicktoons Network 302
ONCE México 447
Ovation TV 274
Oxygen 251
PBS 0
PBS Kids Sprout 295
Planet Green 286
QVC 275
RFD TV 345
ReelzChannel 238
SOAPnet 262

Science Channel 284
ShopNBC 316
Sleuth 308
Speed Channel 607
Spike 241
Style 235
Syfy Channel 244
TBS 247
TCT Network 377
TNT 245
TV Guide Network 237
TV Land 304
TV One 328
TeenNick 303
Tennis Channel 217
The 101 Network HD 101
The Learning Channel 280
The Sportsman Channel 605
The Word Network 373
Travel Channel 277
Trinity Broadcasting Network (TBN) 372
TruTV 246
Turner Classic Movies (TCM) 256
USA Network 242
Univision 402
V-me 440
VH1 335
VH1 Classic 337
Versus 603
WE: Women's Entertainment 260
WGN America 307
Weather Channel 362
World Harvest Television 367
CBS College Sports 613

TVG - The Interactive Horseracing Network 602


FSN Southwest 676 676



SONICTAP: 60's Revolution 803
SONICTAP: 70's Hits 804
SONICTAP: 8-Tracks 840
SONICTAP: 80's Hits 805
SONICTAP: 90's Hits 806
SONICTAP: Adult Alternative 832
SONICTAP: Adult Contemporary 821
SONICTAP: Alternative 834
SONICTAP: Bailamos! 869
SONICTAP: Be-Tween 867

SONICTAP: College Rock 831
SONICTAP: Dance 859
SONICTAP: Familiar Favorites 880
SONICTAP: Fiesta Tropical 870
SONICTAP: Flashback/New Wave 839
SONICTAP: Folk Rock 813
SONICTAP: Full Metal Jacket 830
SONICTAP: Gospel Glory 827
SONICTAP: Great Standards 855
SONICTAP: Groove Lounge 824

SONICTAP: Jazz 852
SONICTAP: Latin Hits 871
SONICTAP: Latin Jazz 879
SONICTAP: Light Classical 866
SONICTAP: Love Songs 819
SONICTAP: Malt Shop Oldies 802
SONICTAP: Mariachi 876
SONICTAP: Metro Blend 853
SONICTAP: Modern Country 814
SONICTAP: Modern Workout 860

SONICTAP: Salsa 874
SONICTAP: Showtunes 823
SONICTAP: Silky Soul 843
SONICTAP: Silver Screen 822
SONICTAP: Singer-Songwriters 836
SONICTAP: Smooth Jazz 851
SONICTAP: Soft Hits 849
SONICTAP: Spike 841
SONICTAP: SubTerranean 858
SONICTAP: Symphonic 864

SONICTAP: Beautiful Instrumentals 820
SONICTAP: Big Band/Swing 801
SONICTAP: Bluegrass 812
SONICTAP: Blues 854
SONICTAP: Classic Hits Blend 837
SONICTAP: Classic Jazz Vocal Blend 850
SONICTAP: Classic R&B 842
SONICTAP: Classic Rock 833
SONICTAP: Classic Rock Workout 862
SONICTAP: Coffeehouse Rock 848

SONICTAP: Hair Guitar 829
SONICTAP: Hallelujah 828
SONICTAP: Hit Country 809
SONICTAP: Honky Tonk Tavern 811
SONICTAP: Hot Jamz 825
SONICTAP: Hottest Hits 818
SONICTAP: Hurbano 875
SONICTAP: Hype 847
SONICTAP: Ink'd 835
SONICTAP: Irish 883

SONICTAP: Musica De Las Americas 872
SONICTAP: New Age 856
SONICTAP: Old School Funk 844
SONICTAP: PUMP! 861
SONICTAP: Rat Pack 807
SONICTAP: Reality Bites 838
SONICTAP: Red, Rock and Blues 810
SONICTAP: Reggae 863
SONICTAP: Retro Disco 845
SONICTAP: Rock en Espanol 878

SONICTAP: The Boombox 846
SONICTAP: The Playground 868
SONICTAP: The Spirit 826
SONICTAP: Today's Hits 816
SONICTAP: Traditional Country 808
SONICTAP: Y2k Hits 817
SONICTAP: Zen 857
KFTH (Telefutura) 67
KHOU (CBS) 11
KIAH (CW) 39
KNWS 51

KPRC (NBC) 2
KPXB (PAX) 49
KRIV (FOX) 26
KTMD (Telemundo) 47

KTRK (ABC) 13
KTXH (MNT) 20
KUHT (PBS) 8
KUVM 34

KXLN (Univ) 45
KZJL 61


You get more channels w/ Directv....and IMO the channel line up and placement of the channels is more easy to figure out.

Winner: DirecTV



On-Demand Service:

Comcast: The selections of movies and shows is great....lots of stuff. But getting to the on-demand page takes 15 seconds and you cant toggle between the live channel and the on-demand channel...this drives me crazy.

Directv: They do not offer an on-demand service

Winner: Comcast


MLB Extra Innings and sports channels in general.

Comcast: They offer the same games as Directv but that's where the similarities end. The mosaic channel sucks and you cant select the game you want to watch from that channel. They don't offer a score guide like Directv.

Directv: Their MLB mix channel is great. You can toggle between the game you want to watch. Their Score guide is also a must have and is great when you just want to know the score w/ out watching the game. Their Masters and similar live pages are also cool.

Winner: Directv



IMO Directv is by far better than Comcast in every category. For the price and the service I am switching back at the end of the month. Again this is just my opinion...
 
Joined
Jan 14, 2007
Messages
8,229
Tokens
directv blows the competition away.

and if you are a sports fan, it is the ONLY choice.
 

Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2008
Messages
12,197
Tokens
I have had Directv for 12 years and will never go back to cable.
 

Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2002
Messages
4,805
Tokens
I have had Directv for 9 years and would never go back to cable.
I have never had one problem.

If you guys like baseball, the MLB Extra Innings is a must.
 

New member
Joined
May 20, 2007
Messages
6,559
Tokens
i dream of dtv someday... been a renter up to this point in life, so its never really been a good option.
 

RX Senior
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
47,431
Tokens
The price on DTV DVR boxes has come down thinking of getting one
 

And if the Road Warrior says it, it must be true..
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
15,481
Tokens
i dream of dtv someday... been a renter up to this point in life, so its never really been a good option.

I'm a renter....and just have them move the dish...they do it for free.
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
32,861
Tokens
Directv here for 10 yrs and it a must for sports, would never go back to cable.Directv and online viewing, what more could you need........ck
 

Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2009
Messages
9,683
Tokens
Well...until I cut down trees around my house I will never have directv. Cant get an HD signal. Booooo
I have Fios, service is incredible, picture is incredible, never had my TV go out on me, very fast Internet, but EXTREMELY high bill :(
 

New member
Joined
Mar 2, 2006
Messages
17,562
Tokens
DirectTV since 1998. I only wish we could go back to the days of THE CARD. Directv is still great, but when I had the Card it was unreal.
 

And if the Road Warrior says it, it must be true..
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
15,481
Tokens
DirectTV since 1998. I only wish we could go back to the days of THE CARD. Directv is still great, but when I had the Card it was unreal.

That was the greatest...the old card with the NFL helmet on it....would go out once every couple of months....but every channel.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 9, 2005
Messages
6,676
Tokens
Like most people are saying. It is no comparison. DTV is the best. I don't have it right now But I will go back and get it asap when I get a job.
 

RX Dream Team
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
8,019
Tokens
I'd have DirectTv if it wasn't for one bad experience.

Buddy is throwing a big party for College football saturday and, in the 4th Q of a close game I had a nice chunk of change on, a thunderstorm knocks out the reception.

Everyone got pissed and went to the bar.

Comcast is bad but I deal with them. I always talk them down in price because I tell them I'm switching.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,591
Messages
13,452,735
Members
99,423
Latest member
lbplayer
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com