well I'm not an oil or gas expert by any means but I think i can say that it shouldn't really matter that this station is an independent station. Fact is almost everybody gets their gas from the same place so he probably is paying the same as everybody else for the gas. In reality in your city the BP, Shell, Exxon, Hess ect. stations all get their gas from the same place. Also alot of the brand name gas stations are really not owned by that company. Most of them are independently owned. Take BP for example. There are over 13,000 BP stations in the U.S. BP currently only owns about 700 of them, and they are activly trying to sell those. The rest are owned by regular independent business guys. This is why when people say they are going to boycott BP it pisses me off. You aren't hurting BP, you're hurting the little guy that owns that station. On top of that the gas that is at a BP station isn't necessarily BP gas. It could very well be Hess of Shell or Exxon gas that is just at a BP station. And the same is also true the other way. You could very well be buying BP gas when you go to that Exxon station trying to boycott BP. Well technically it is BP gas at a BP station. The way it works is this. All these staions buy gas from the same place and then it becomes "their" brand of gas when they put their additives into the gas. So fact is, BP is selling alot of gas to Shell, Exxon or whoever than those companies put their additives into the gas and that make it Shell gas ect. But in reality BP made a profit by selling the gas.
So this guy is probably just making less money to try and build up a loyal customer base. Gas stations don't make a bulk of their money on selling gas anyway. Its all about the business inside.