If the GB Packers Win the Super Bowl Sunday, Does Aaron Rodgers Rank in the Top 5 Current QB's ?

Betallsports

Member

Joined

Jan 17, 2007

Messages

99,709

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #1

Still think there are 5 or 6 ahead of him... So I so No, but it's close

 

HuskerFan1

Member

Joined

Sep 21, 2004

Messages

4,245

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #2

its close

brady
manning
brees
ben (even though personally id take rodgers over rothlisburger)

then

rodgers (who would have 1 sb ring)
rivers
vick

i rate rivers and vick well above eli even though he has a ring....

 

Betallsports

Member

Joined

Jan 17, 2007

Messages

99,709

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #3

HuskerFan1 said:

its close

brady
manning
brees
ben (even though personally id take rodgers over rothlisburger)

then

rodgers (who would have 1 sb ring)
rivers
vick

i rate rivers and vick well above eli even though he has a ring....

Click to expand...

Yep, I kind of see it the same way.......

 

jb777

New member

Joined

Apr 8, 2010

Messages

2,127

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #4

Manning
Brady
Rodgers
Brees
Big Ben

 

EasyMoney

New member

Joined

Oct 11, 2004

Messages

2,418

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #5

Brady
Manning
brees
rivers

then you get into the big ben, rogers, romo guys. i think the top 4 are pretty much set in stone. imo after that the debate starts

 

steaktartar

powdered milkman

Joined

Aug 4, 2006

Messages

22,984

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #6

brady manning brees rodgers

 

seanm0520

New member

Joined

Oct 26, 2006

Messages

7,718

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #7

I would prefer Rodgers over Rivers, personally. Maybe even over Brees.

 

Albatross

Member

Joined

Feb 2, 2010

Messages

9,660

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #8

HuskerFan1 said:

its close

brady
manning
brees
ben (even though personally id take rodgers over rothlisburger)

then

rodgers (who would have 1 sb ring)
rivers
vick

i rate rivers and vick well above eli even though he has a ring....

Click to expand...

Agree almost...Vick no way.

As a huge Falcon homer, I will have to say that I would much rather have Ryan than Vick. This is coming from a fan that has enjoyed seeing both QBs play for the dirty birds, but no way I would trade Ryan for Vick at this time.

 

Dante

Active member

Joined

Jun 20, 2000

Messages

71,780

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #9

EasyMoney said:

Brady
Manning
brees
rivers

then you get into the big ben, rogers, romo guys. i think the top 4 are pretty much set in stone. imo after that the debate starts

Click to expand...

Brady 3 rings
Manning 1 ring
brees 0 rings
rivers 0 rings

Big ben 2 rings and you rank him lower then rivers?? just do not get that

 

Betallsports

Member

Joined

Jan 17, 2007

Messages

99,709

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #10

Dante said:

Brady 3 rings
Manning 1 ring
brees 0 rings
rivers 0 rings

Big ben 2 rings and you rank him lower then rivers?? just do not get that

Click to expand...

Do you Want to Rethink the Above Statement @)

 

cincy_

New member

Joined

Nov 21, 2000

Messages

8,834

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #11

1. Brady and Manning : if they dont play well, team loses.

2. Brees, Rodgers and Rivers: they don't play well, team prolly loses, but team still has a shot

3. Ben the Rapist and Sanchez the Booger: they can suck, and team might still win

 

Dante

Active member

Joined

Jun 20, 2000

Messages

71,780

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #12

Betallsports said:

Do you Want to Rethink the Above Statement @)

Click to expand...

OPPS 1 ring... shot me mr perfecto mirage man

 

hybrid

New member

Joined

Sep 11, 2009

Messages

1,502

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #13

I think the top 3 are set in stone, after that it can go many ways.
manning
brady
brees
ben
rivers
rogers
vick
romo
shaub
ryan

 

doubledeuce22

Member

Joined

Jan 14, 2007

Messages

8,229

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #14

why is drew brees so great?

 

hybrid

New member

Joined

Sep 11, 2009

Messages

1,502

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #15

doubledeuce22 said:

why is drew brees so great?

Click to expand...

have you watched him the last 5 years?

 

doubledeuce22

Member

Joined

Jan 14, 2007

Messages

8,229

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #16

hybrid said:

have you watched him the last 5 years?

Click to expand...

yes, thats why i ask the question.

 

hybrid

New member

Joined

Sep 11, 2009

Messages

1,502

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #17

in his last 5 yrs he's thrown for over 4300 yrds in each and has 155 TD to 79 ints....
hes been to 5 pro bowls won the superbowl and was the MVP was also offensive POY.....I dont think many compare to that.

 

HuskerFan1

Member

Joined

Sep 21, 2004

Messages

4,245

Tokens

• Jan 31, 2011

• #18

the bottom line is this

we are arguing over apples and oranges, those top 7 are the class of the class,

what people should be arguing about is the next 7 b/c thats where it really gets dicey....id rate Ryan #8 and after that, who cares....

 

Huckel

New member

Joined

Feb 11, 2008

Messages

1,842

Tokens

• Feb 1, 2011

• #19

im not a rivers basher but hes basically schaub,ryan,romo with a better team and record but not player his team cant run at all so he puts up big numbers and his team has been very solid over the years especially on D.

But i agree with the list just not high on rivers its basically a top 4 with rodgers, brees making a case to be in there

 

Willie99

Conservatives, Patriots & Huskies return to glory

Handicapper

Joined

Sep 9, 2005

Messages

85,766

Tokens

• Feb 1, 2011

• #20

great season, sensational post season. If he continues to play like this, yes