Maybe, but he has been pretty solid in his 3 starts so far this season, admittedly against 2 of the worst teams of the season (Seattle + Minny) as well as Oakland.
Dice-K on the other hand has been shocking and his confidence must be rock bottom. Personally I really like Toronto here, and as an Underdog (+120 at Pinny when I backed them) I think there is a lot of value here...