Vote: Who Is the Greatest Yankee Hitter of All Time?

Search

Who is the Greatest Yankee Hitter of All Time?

  • Joe DiMaggio

    Votes: 6 20.7%
  • Lou Gehrig

    Votes: 6 20.7%
  • Derek Jeter

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • Mickey Mantle

    Votes: 4 13.8%
  • Babe Ruth

    Votes: 10 34.5%
  • Other

    Votes: 2 6.9%

  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .

New member
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
75,154
Tokens
Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter is back on the pitch and inching closer to the 3,000-hit plateau.

The legendary Yankee captain returned on Monday afternoon in Cleveland but failed to make ground on the milestone and is stuck at 2,994 career hits as of Tuesday morning.
If he were on nearly any other MLB team, Jeter would already be regarded as the franchise's top player, but this is the New York Yankees we're talking about, where there are almost as many retired numbers as their are pinstripes in their uniforms.


Where does Jeter rank among the Yankees' all-time best hitters? The competition is pretty stiff, dating back to the days when Babe Ruth used to make the Old Yankee Stadium look like a little league park.


Poll copied from one being run at NESN.com
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,302
Tokens
Lou Gehrig
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,302
Tokens
Jeter is clearly #5 on that list with a huge gap between him and #4

As a matter of fact, he is #6 on that list.

other is #5
 

New member
Joined
Dec 21, 2008
Messages
14,873
Tokens
started to go other with a really old timer - Earle Combs .... but went with the Yankee Clipper.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,302
Tokens
Besides the expansion teams and a few others, I cant think of many teams that Jeter would be the all time greatest hitter for any organization.
 

Conservatives, Patriots & Huskies return to glory
Handicapper
Joined
Sep 9, 2005
Messages
85,760
Tokens
Lou
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
2,898
Tokens
Ist 7 are pretty simple:
1) Ruth
2) Gehrig
3) DiMaggio
4) Mantle
5) Berra
6) Dickey
7) Combes

then comes 8-20 and one could put #20 over #8 as they are all relatively fine players from different eras
 

New member
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
75,154
Tokens
According to a guy that might know - Ted Williams (list compiled in 1994) Babe Ruth is the best hitter anywhere ever...

Top 20 Hitters by Ted Williams (1994) Ted humbly leaves himself off the list.
In 1994, Ted Williams opened his Hitters Hall of Fame in Hernando, Florida. He celebrated the event by inviting hundreds of former ballplayers and one current player — Tony Gwynn.

Williams enshrined the top twenty all-time hitters using his own "secret formula" which he stated was a combination of on base percentage and slugging average. Here are the top twenty hitters chosen by The Splended Splinter as the first members of the Ted Williams Hitters Hall of Fame.

Rank Name
20. Ralph Kiner
19. Mike Schmidt
18. Frank Robinson
17. Harry Heilmann
16. Mel Ott
15. Johnny Mize
14. Al Simmons
13. Tris Speaker
12. Mickey Mantle
11. Hank Greenberg
10. Willie Mays
9. Hank Aaron
8. Joe Jackson
7. Stan Musial
6. Ty Cobb
5. Joe DiMaggio
4. Rogers Hornsby
3. Jimmie Foxx
2. Lou Gehrig
1. Babe Ruth


I should add Williams though he left himself off the list was no shrinking violet about his own abilities to hit a baseball as one can tell by his famous quote from long ago.

"If there was ever a man born to be a hitter, it was me."

Ted when discussing Joe DiMaggio:

"Joe
DiMaggio was the greatest all-around player I ever saw. His career cannot be summed up in numbers and awards. It might sound corny, but he had a profound and lasting impact on the country".


Source The Baseball Almanac.
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
34,790
Tokens
Seems like AROD who's final numbers will be staggering as an RX THREAD TITLES get no love --- will nevr be considered a real Yankee. Yank fans would vote for O'Neil, Bernie, or Mattingly B4 him....
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,302
Tokens
19. Mike Schmidt

way way way too high

Closer to 190 then 19
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
2,898
Tokens
Top 20 Hitters by Ted Williams (1994) Ted humbly leaves himself off the list.
In 1994, Ted Williams opened his Hitters Hall of Fame in Hernando, Florida. He celebrated the event by inviting hundreds of former ballplayers and one current player — Tony Gwynn.

Williams enshrined the top twenty all-time hitters using his own "secret formula" which he stated was a combination of on base percentage and slugging average. Here are the top twenty hitters chosen by The Splended Splinter as the first members of the Ted Williams Hitters Hall of Fame.

Rank Name
20. Ralph Kiner
19. Mike Schmidt
18. Frank Robinson
17. Harry Heilmann
16. Mel Ott
15. Johnny Mize
14. Al Simmons
13. Tris Speaker
12. Mickey Mantle
11. Hank Greenberg
10. Willie Mays
9. Hank Aaron
8. Joe Jackson
7. Stan Musial
6. Ty Cobb
5. Joe DiMaggio
4. Rogers Hornsby
3. Jimmie Foxx
2. Lou Gehrig
1. Babe Ruth


I should add Williams though he left himself off the list was no shrinking violet about his own abilities to hit a baseball as one can tell by his famous quote from long ago.

"If there was ever a man born to be a hitter, it was me."

Ted when discussing Joe DiMaggio:

"Joe
DiMaggio was the greatest all-around player I ever saw. His career cannot be summed up in numbers and awards. It might sound corny, but he had a profound and lasting impact on the country".


Source The Baseball Almanac.


Williams if included would definitely be #2 behind Ruth. Glad to see he gave Foxx, Simmons, Greenberg & Big John Mize respect. Great list can't think of anyone he didn't include that should be up their, possibly only Lefty O'Doul if he only didn't originally fancy himself as a pitcher
 

New member
Joined
Apr 21, 2002
Messages
28,149
Tokens
A-Rod, IMO, is the best hitter to ever play for the Yankees. Others have better resumes if we are talking only about stats accumulated while with the Yankees though.
 

New member
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
75,154
Tokens
Mike Schmidt is right where he belongs on that list...

Schmidt is considered among the greatest third basemen in the history of major league baseball. Schmidt was voted National League MVP three times, an All-Star 12 times, and received more votes than any other third baseman in 1999's Major League Baseball All-Century Team. In 1995, he was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.

In 1980, Schmidt elevated his game, leading the league in home runs with 48 (by a margin of 13 over his nearest competitor), and winning the National League's Most Valuable Player Award in a unanimous vote. He broke his own team home run record, which stood for 26 years until first baseman and 2006 National League MVP Ryan Howard hit 58 home runs in 2006. The Phillies won the World Series for the first time in team history, defeating the Kansas City Royals. Schmidt, who hit two homers and drove in seven runs, was selected as World Series MVP.


In 1981, the Phillies again reached the postseason and Schmidt won his second MVP Award, setting personal highs in batting average, on-base average, and slugging average during the strike-shortened season. In 1983, in celebration of the team's 100th anniversary, Schmidt was voted by fans the greatest player in the history of the franchise. That year, he led the Phillies back to the World Series, but they were defeated by the Baltimore Orioles.


Mike Schmidt is only one of two players who hit at least 300 home runs in the 1980s. The other is Dale Murphy.

Over his career Schmidt set a vast array of hitting and fielding records. In addition to his MVP Awards, Schmidt won ten Gold Gloves, led the league in home runs eight times, in RBI four times, OPS five times, and walks four times. He was named to twelve All-Star teams. Schmidt finished his career with 548 home runs and 1,595 RBI, two of the many Phillies career records he holds.

In 1995, Schmidt was voted into the Baseball Hall of Fame with what was then the 4th-highest percentage ever, 96.52%.<sup id="cite_ref-9" class="reference">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_Schmidt#cite_note-9</sup>(Nolan Ryan and George Brett surpassed his percentage in 1999).

In 1999, he ranked number 28 on The Sporting News's list of the 100 Greatest Baseball Players, the highest-ranking third baseman, and the highest-ranking player whose career began after 1967. Later that year, he was elected to the Major League Baseball All-Century Team.

His uniform number 20 has been retired by the Phillies, and he has been honored with a statue outside the third-base gate at the team's home, Citizens Bank Park.

He is the Phillies all-time leader in games played, at-bats, plate appearances, runs scored, hits, home runs, RBI, walks, strikeouts, total bases, runs created, sacrifice flies, outs, Adj. Batting Runs, Adj. Batting Wins, Extra Base Hits, Times On Base, and Power-Speed number.

To say he is closer to the 190th than 19th best hitter of all time is ludicrous.

wil.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,302
Tokens
Im sorry but if you are going to be considered one of the 19 best hitters in the history of baseball you have to have a BA better then .267
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
34,790
Tokens
Dave Winfield best true athlete out of the Yankees would beat the crap outta and out run these 5 white blooded guys...
 

New member
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
75,154
Tokens
Mike Schmidt - sure he was 858th all time in Bat. Ave (one ahead of Johnny Bench) but consider these stats.

No but if you retire with stats that led the league in home runs eight times, in RBI four times, OPS five times, and walks four times.
Named to twelve All-Star teams. Schmidt also finished his career with 548 home runs and 1,595 RBI, two of the many Phillies career records he holds you do..


Batting average is just one stat that defines a hitter. Other areas where Schmidt is among the best:

Extra Base Hits: Mike Schmidt 1,015 29th all time.
Walks: Mike Schmidt 1,507 17th all time.
Home Runs: Mike Schmidt 548 15th all time.
Home Run %: Mike Schmidt 6.56 (6.5613) 17th all time.
Isolated Power: Mike Schmidt .260 (.25982) 19th all time.
Isolated Power is calculated by substracting batting average from slugging percentage.
On Base plus Slugging Ave.: Mike Schmidt 0.908 (.90755) 53rd all time.
RBI's: Mike Schmidt 1,595 33rd all time.
Runs produced: Mike Schmidt 2,553 63rd all time.
Runs produced was created during the 1970's and the way it is calculated
is adding runs to runs batted in then subtracting home runs.
Runs scored: Mike Schmidt 1,506 67th all time.
Sacrifice Flies: Mike Schmidt 108 15th all time.
Secondary batting average:Mike Schmidt .450 (.45007) 14th all time.
Secondary Average covers the three primary factors of an offensive contribution to a team outside of their batting average power (extra bases), eye (walks) and speed (stolen bases).
Slugging average: Mike Schmidt .527 (.52730) 48th all time.
Times on base: Mike Schmidt 3,820 58th all time.
Triples:George Brett 137 68th all time.

Compared to number of official at bats: Mike Schmidt 8,352 105th all time. Given the opportunities he had compared to the results at 105th all time in at bats, Mike Schmidt is easily one of the top 20 hitters of all time.

BTW: Babe Ruth blows away the field if broken down like this..

wil.
 

New member
Joined
Jun 2, 2006
Messages
29,253
Tokens
Lou and Babe tied at the top
Joe D way up there.
Mick gets top 5 mention.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,588
Messages
13,452,637
Members
99,423
Latest member
lbplayer
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com