Top 10 golfers ever ?

kermit16 · Aug 9, 2011

Since there has been so much discussion regarding who is better... Tiger or Jack, it seem the right time to relive some of the greats from the past.
Let's just agree to put Nicklaus and Tiger at the top.
Who belongs in the top 10 all time ?

steaktartar · Aug 9, 2011

good thread

1 and 2 jack and tiger or tiger and jack
3 ben hogan
4 tom watson
5 sam snead
6 bobby jones
7 lee trevino
8 arnold palmer
9 gary player
10 payne stewart

Albatross · Aug 9, 2011

Phil deserves to be in the top 10. Maybe 10th, but on the list.

REDEYE · Aug 9, 2011

1-Jack
2-Tiger
3-Hogan
4-Hagen
5-Jones
6-Palmer
7-Player
8-Watson
9-Snead
10-Faldo

Betallsports · Aug 9, 2011

steak tartar said:
good thread

1 and 2 jack and tiger or tiger and jack
3 ben hogan
4 tom watson
5 sam snead
6 bobby jones
7 lee trevino
8 arnold palmer
9 gary player
10 payne stewart

somewhere in the middle I would throw in Harry Vardon. I know I'm going way back... and not much of a Golf fan... I had read a book once that he wrote... forget what the name was, but found it interesting.

C.P. · Aug 9, 2011

payne stewart ....Damn...what a HUGH loss to golf...

I'd say top 10...

taylor13 · Aug 9, 2011

Still yet to be determined between one and two

Hogan
Hagen
Jones
Player
Watson
Palmer
Snead
And ill put in Mickelson assuming he finishes his career strong....I'm not a Mickelson guy, but he's kinda like Tiger. When those two guys play well, they are tough to beat

CHOPTALK · Aug 9, 2011

No way Payne Stewart was top 10

steak tartar said:
good thread

1 and 2 jack and tiger or tiger and jack
3 ben hogan
4 tom watson
5 sam snead
6 bobby jones
7 lee trevino
8 arnold palmer
9 gary player
10 payne stewart

NickPappagiorgio · Aug 9, 2011

Jones
Hogan
Palmer
Watson
Player
Trevino
Faldo

#10 is very debatable, but I would say it would be an old timer like Varden, Snead or Hagen.

Mickelson or Stewart arent in the top 10.

kermit16 · Aug 9, 2011

No love for Byron Nelson ? Seems to me that He belongs in there somewhere ?

TheCommish · Aug 9, 2011

kermit16 said:
No love for Byron Nelson ? Seems to me that He belongs in there somewhere ?

I was thinking the same thing.

GoSooners · Aug 9, 2011

kermit16 said:
No love for Byron Nelson ? Seems to me that He belongs in there somewhere ?

He not only belongs in the top 10, he should be in the top 5. I can't believe nobody has listed him.

billhill999 · Aug 9, 2011

1 Jack Nicklaus
2 Tiger Woods
3 Ben Hogan
4 Bobby Jones
5 Sam Snead
6 Byron Nelson
7 Arnold Palmer
8 Gary Player
9 Walter Hagen
10 Gene Sarazen

TheCommish · Aug 9, 2011

Also I did see Seve Ballesteros on the list. Seve had an imagination for the game like no one else.

GoSooners · Aug 9, 2011

The 12 tournaments that Byron Nelson won in one year will never be topped.

TheCommish · Aug 9, 2011

GoSooners said:
The 12 tournaments that Byron Nelson won in one year will never be topped.

Correct. not in this day and age

texansfan · Aug 9, 2011

Ty Webb

kermit16 · Aug 9, 2011

GoSooners said:
The 12 tournaments that Byron Nelson won in one year will never be topped.

Byron Nelson won 18 Tournaments in 1945 including 11 in a row ! Nobody will ever approach that record !

steaktartar · Aug 10, 2011

CHOPTALK said:
No way Payne Stewart was top 10

maybe not to you..thats why its my list

also saw him the driving range hit laser beam long iron after long iron only guy who impressed me as much as him seeing hit balls live is davis love............the ball doesnt stray off course more than an inch in flight truely remarkable

TheCommish · Aug 10, 2011

steak tartar said:
maybe not to you..thats why its my list

also saw him the driving range hit laser beam long iron after long iron only guy who impressed me as much as him seeing hit balls live is davis love............the ball doesnt stray off course more than an inch in flight truely remarkable

I like Davis Love III but he's not great. he hits a good looking ball though

Top 10 golfers ever ?

J-Man Rx NFL Pick 4 Champion for 2005

powdered milkman

Member

Nirvana Shill

Member

Member

New member

Member

New member

J-Man Rx NFL Pick 4 Champion for 2005

RX Sunday Afternooner

Member

New member

RX Sunday Afternooner

Member

RX Sunday Afternooner

Member

J-Man Rx NFL Pick 4 Champion for 2005

powdered milkman

RX Sunday Afternooner

Forum statistics

Share this page