Better QB: Aaron Rodgers or Tom Brady

gynecologist · Oct 23, 2011

Who is the better quarterback?

or

bigtendominator · Oct 23, 2011

The one with only 1 ring. He will get his 2nd one this year.

cincy_ · Oct 23, 2011

When someone wins the MVP by a UNANIMOUS VOTE, it means nobody voted for the other guy ... or any other guy.

Unanimous MVP = better QB

Mr_Mark · Oct 23, 2011

My vote goes for Rodgers, Just based on this season alone.
So far, over the course of both their careers, no doubt Brady

DrunkenHorseplayer · Oct 23, 2011

No contest; give me Rodgers.

Gravy · Oct 23, 2011

For right now Rodgers

Career I Have to go with Brady for the time being

bigtendominator · Oct 23, 2011

Well, i think obviously, we would all pick TB for career, but AR is straight balling right now.

gijoe · Oct 23, 2011

Rogers going to need a few more good years to catch Brady but i saw something today in Roger i didnt like. Rogers was inside the 20 and was going to get sacked and instead of throwing out of end zone, he tookthe sack. i think he loves his stats. brady would of thrown it out of end zone. i will be watching. Green Bay is #1 and no other team is close to them

Fishhead · Oct 23, 2011

gijoe said:
Rogers going to need a few more good years to catch Brady but i saw something today in Roger i didnt like. Rogers was inside the 20 and was going to get sacked and instead of throwing out of end zone, he took the sack. i think he loves his stats. brady would of thrown it out of end zone. i will be watching. Green Bay is #1 and no other team is close to them

Oh c'mon GIJOE, re-evaluate this.............not true.

Yes, an out of the end zone pass would have been the wise choice, he simply didn't do it...........and the last thing he wanted was some silly INT with a 40 plus yard INT attched to it.

Rodgers is not conerned with a few incompletions................the last thing on his mind.

As far as the question posed....

BRADY the best career
BRADY/RODGERS equal for past 9 months and next 9 months.........any GM would take either in a heartbeat.

Fishhead · Oct 23, 2011

gijoe said:
Rogers going to need a few more good years to catch Brady but i saw something today in Roger i didnt like. Rogers was inside the 20 and was going to get sacked and instead of throwing out of end zone, he tookthe sack. i think he loves his stats. brady would of thrown it out of end zone. i will be watching. Green Bay is #1 and no other team is close to them

Right now, there is no better QB than RODGERS

Right now, there is no better QB than BRADY

gynecologist · Oct 23, 2011

gijoe said:
Rogers going to need a few more good years to catch Brady but i saw something today in Roger i didnt like. Rogers was inside the 20 and was going to get sacked and instead of throwing out of end zone, he tookthe sack. i think he loves his stats. brady would of thrown it out of end zone. i will be watching. Green Bay is #1 and no other team is close to them

rodgers is putting up some crazy fantasy #'s..

patswin · Oct 23, 2011

Brady

REDEYE · Oct 23, 2011

Rodgers !! They both are great but I like the fact you can add that Rodgers is mobile where Brady isn't..

jb777 · Oct 24, 2011

Gimme Brady 8 days a week

BettingFoodStamps · Oct 24, 2011

I voted brady simply on his clutch alone. Dude is money when its on the table. Rodgers is 1A to me but he is climbing fast.

ANOTHERDAY · Oct 24, 2011

changes

They both are great. Problem I have is that the rule changes regarding the defenses has made them look much better. Don't get me wrong, they are great with the system in place. If the rules on the defense were not changed, they would not come close to what they have been doing.

PatPatriot · Oct 24, 2011

They both are great. Problem I have is that the rule changes regarding the defenses has made them look much better. Don't get me wrong, they are great with the system in place. If the rules on the defense were not changed, they would not come close to what they have been doing.

Actually Brady got his championships under the old rules.His stats have gone up under the new rules but championships are down.
All I can say is what a great Super Bowl it would be Pack vs Pats. Pack would be favored and Brady would not want it any other way.

REDEYE · Oct 24, 2011

Pat Patriot said:
Actually Brady got his championships under the old rules.His stats have gone up under the new rules but championships are down.
All I can say is what a great Super Bowl it would be Pack vs Pats. Pack would be favored and Brady would not want it any other way.

Yea Tuck rule got him one he doesn't deserve.. One I don't recognize

PatPatriot · Oct 24, 2011

Yea Tuck rule got him one he doesn't deserve.. One I don't recognize

Actually it should have been a 15 yard blow to the head on Brady. Pats got fucked.
The only other time the tuck rule was called that year was against the Pats.Vinny Testeverde was the benificiary.
But rules are rules and it was a begining of a glorious dynasty.

wilheim · Oct 24, 2011

Better QB: Aaron Rodgers or Tom Brady

Better QB: Rodgers or Brady

Aaron Rodgers

Tom Brady

Banned

New member

New member

Member

Rx Member

Member

New member

New member

Active member

Active member

Banned

Member

Nirvana Shill

New member

New member

Member

New member

Nirvana Shill

New member

New member

Forum statistics

Share this page