Was Phil Humber's game a perfect game?

quantumleap · Apr 21, 2012

What do you think?

@)

Doug · Apr 21, 2012

got video ?

michael777 · Apr 21, 2012

the batter should have ran to first instead of arguing,he would have been save easily

gynecologist · Apr 21, 2012

no video QL my man...

Derp · Apr 21, 2012

GRONK!!! We can't even enjoy the pleasure of witnessing a perfectly pitched game anymore without cynicism. ELECTION YEARS SUCK!!! Many witnesses at cbssports.com chimed in on the in game chat saying that it was a strike! Let the man have his moment in the sun 4F$%KsSake!

quantumleap · Apr 22, 2012

Looks like MLB is blocking Youtube videos. I'll try to post a video when one becomes available.

quantumleap · Apr 22, 2012

Jake T. said:
Do I have to do everything for you amateurs?

http://mlb.mlb.com/video/play.jsp?content_id=20809067&topic_id=&c_id=mlb&tcid=vpp_copy_20809067&v=3

Well played my good man.

It wasn't a swing and there will be blood.

gynecologist · Apr 22, 2012

reminds me of that situation last year with Galaraga..

1osubucks · Apr 22, 2012

The worse last year was Detroit getting screwed by umps for no hitter against cleveland

Hotpizza · Apr 22, 2012

Doesn't matter what we think. History books show it as Perfect Game #21.

thekeyman · Apr 22, 2012

i don't get what the problem is,the ump said he swung at it and thats all that matters,the play was completed by throwing to first and its complete

Enfuego · Apr 22, 2012

michael777 said:
the batter should have ran to first instead of arguing,he would have been save easily

The batter should have run to first instead of arguing. He easily would have been safe.

CHOPTALK · Apr 22, 2012

If the hitter would have ran to first instead of arguing it would have been the 1st no hitter(non perfect game) with no walks or errors.

It would have made a great trivia question.

Willie99 · Apr 22, 2012

looks like the batter may have swung at the pitch, probably did

the dimwit should have just run to 1st base

every no hitter / perfect game as some luck in it somewhere

Enfuego · Apr 22, 2012

CHOPTALK said:
If the hitter would have ran to first instead of arguing it would have been the 1st no hitter(non perfect game) with no walks or errors.

It would have made a great trivia question.

But if the next guy comes up and gets a hit then it's not a no hitter.

ParlaysStoleMyMoney · Apr 23, 2012

Pretty cool. Use to play fall ball with him. Just realized that I have connection with 3 pro athletes.

Went to school and am good friends with Jason Peters of the Eagles. Actually had the Philly newspaper (Inquirer I think) give me a call when he went to the Eagles.

Grew up with Drew Stubbs of the Reds (his mom and my mom were best friends).

Played fall ball with Humber.

Yeah, I am a pretty big deal.