Deep MLB Umpire Question

Search

Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2002
Messages
4,805
Tokens
Why do the umpires take the baseball out of play when it hits the ground on a pitched ball, but when a shortstop short hops the first baseman they keep the ball in play?

This has bothered me for many years. LOL
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
A pitch which hits the dirt often becomes discolored or has scuff marks on it due to the nature of the soil material around home plate. This happens at a fairly high rate of speed
A batted ball in the infield usually hits grass first and at an angle that these scuff marks do not occur. A ball that is chopped and hits the HP circle is taken out of play.
 

Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2002
Messages
4,805
Tokens
A pitch which hits the dirt often becomes discolored or has scuff marks on it due to the nature of the soil material around home plate. This happens at a fairly high rate of speed
A batted ball in the infield usually hits grass first and at an angle that these scuff marks do not occur. A ball that is chopped and hits the HP circle is taken out of play.

The ball hits the same dirt in front of first base than home plate. I am not talking about grass.
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
Here are two things I found, Not saying it's the answer but some of makes sense

In the professional game, sometimes an umpire will take a ball out of play - right after the pitch hits the dirt, so the ball has no IMMEDIATE
chance of having a foreign substance on, that is ... dirt. In addition, watch the plate umpire inspect the ball.
He's looking for any substance that might have been put on the ball by the pitcher because of the
ball's sudden drop, bite or other movement prior to diving in the dirt. Also, if a ball is "fouled" in the dirt
right in front of home plate - again, he'll inspect the ball.
If the ball is not fit for play - out it goes, usually a practice ball for the home club. BUT, if the only
thing that's on the ball is a tiny bit of soil after bouncing off the dirt, watch closely if the plate umpire
simply rubs his hands around the ball, then tucks it away in his ball bag.





When a pitch is thrown by a pitcher it has a certain spin to it. 4 seam, 2 seam, curve, whatever. When the ball hits the dirt with that certain spin it can leave marks or scuffs in the ball that may effect the way the ball reacts the next time it is thrown by the pitcher. Now when the ball is hit into play and hits the ground it has a different spin or reaction off the bat so that is why it stays in play.
 

New member
Joined
Dec 21, 2008
Messages
14,873
Tokens
Speaking of umpire questions , some umpires after foul balls throw the new ball to the pitcher , but others give it to the catcher to throw to the pitcher , how is this determined ? I bet catchers love the umps that throw it for them.
 

Rx God
Joined
Nov 1, 2002
Messages
39,226
Tokens
Speaking of umpire questions , some umpires after foul balls throw the new ball to the pitcher , but others give it to the catcher to throw to the pitcher , how is this determined ? I bet catchers love the umps that throw it for them.

If the ump can't throw for SHIT he probably uses the catcher.
 

Rx God
Joined
Nov 1, 2002
Messages
39,226
Tokens
It would be funny if the catcher refused to throw it, or bounced it to the pitcher or even rolled it to him.
 

Defender of the Faith
Joined
Aug 13, 2005
Messages
5,680
Tokens
I think it is tradition more than anything else. A ball can be hit, banged off the wall, thrown in to a base, short-hopped, and thrown around, and still be used on the next pitch, just like in the old days, because that is the tradition of the game.

Now, a new tradition is for the batter to complain about a ball that was pitched into the dirt and for the umpire to take it out of play. It used to require a batter to ask the ump to check the ball, but now that doesn't even happen anymore, the ump just does it automatically.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,594
Messages
13,452,834
Members
99,426
Latest member
bodyhealthtechofficia
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com