The Cat's MLB Over/Under Bets & Detailed Writeups - May 23, 2012 - YTD: 122-118-10

Search
Joined
Apr 6, 2012
Messages
3,314
Tokens
2012 MLB O/U Record: 122-118-10, -$476
2011 MLB O/U Record: 366-270-42, +$1,104


Very nice 5-2 day yesterday, as while I didn’t make much money from accomplishing that, it’s the fact that I put on a performance like that just one day after my rare miserable Monday, a day that easily could have snowballed and significantly hurt me collectively over a few days, if not more. Instead, I kind of laid low and simply got back into my rhythm, which is a positive because it restores my confidence, especially heading into arguably my toughest day of the week, Wednesday. Luckily, there is some potential to cure my Wednesday woes (55-40-4 on Wednesdays last year but just 10-20-1 on Wednesdays this year. Yuck) so let’s move on to it…


(Posting this early because I have a 1 o’clock game. I will have a couple of more write-ups a bit later on.)


Toronto Blue Jays @ Tampa Bay Rays - $84 for $65 ($16 for $15 of this is on U7)
Ricky Romero vs James Shields
UNDER 7.5

Any time you get a vibe for an under on a Ricky Romero day game, especially at home or on any type of indoor turf like he’ll be playing on today, you run with it,and there’s easy reasoning for that. One, we all know of Romero’s emergence over recent years, even in the very competitive American League East, in which he has actually established himself as a legitimate ace. For those that question that sentiment, when you cap off an excellent two-year stretch with a 2.92 ERA and 1.14 WHIP, as he registered in the 2011 season, while regularly playing the competition that he plays, well, you’re an ace in my book, and it’s a role he can relish as that talented pitching staff continues to grow, while he serves as the veteran anchor of it. Most important of all, as I alluded to in my opening sentence, is that Romero’s split stats are as significant as anyone else’s out there, in that it’s CLEAR he loves pitching during the day and indoors on turf. Every year, his numbers have been much better at home at the Rogers Centre, but overall, when you consider his indoor stats compared to his outdoor stats, it’s like night and day. Take last year, for example, when he posted a 2.30 ERA and 1.01 WHIP in a closed setting, while finishing up with a 3.14 ERA and 1.18 WHIP outside. That’s no coincidence as it was even more glowing in 2010, when his indoor stats (1.94 ERA, 0.91 WHIP) easily bested his outdoor performance (4.23 ERA, 1.40 WHIP). Throw in the fact that Romero likes stepping up even more for big games and duels like this one, so him throwing a gem this afternoon seems very likely.

Opposingh im will be another fellow ace in James Shields, who is very similar to Romeroin terms of that indoors versus outdoors trend. While it hasn’t been as obvious this year, all you have to do is examine his career numbers as a WHOLE: 104 starts indoors, leading to a 3.42 ERA and 1.19 WHIP; 90 starts outdoors, leading to a 4.61 ERA and 1.31 WHIP. Uh, that’s pretty significant. Also throw in the fact that Shields has always pitched better at home (42-27, 3.39 ERA, and 1.18 WHIP) compared to on the road (36-38, 4.59 ERA, 1.30 WHIP). Again, another very significant trend, especially when it’s over a FULL run difference! I’ll add more to the fire: He’s also a proven better daytime pitcher (66 career starts, 3.49 ERA, 1.12 WHIP) than he is at night (127 career starts, 4.20 ERA, 1.30 WHIP). That’s three important scenarios where Shields clearly displays he’s a better pitcher. He’s obviously still an ace, especially after his all-star 2011campaign. This year, he’s 6-2 with a 3.77 ERA and 1.29 WHIP, to go along with 56 strikeouts in 59 innings. What’s not to like here? You have two aces dealing in their favorite settings matched up against one another, and their attitudes on the mound indicate they enjoy pitching in these big-time matchups. This has to go under.


I’ll be back a bit later with my other picks for today, but this one should start us out nicely.
 
Joined
Apr 6, 2012
Messages
3,314
Tokens
Got it last night at 7.5 in the most juice I've seen on an over/under all year (-135). Then I decided I wanted it for more this morning at 7 so I simply added another 11 for 10.

Trust me, if my site ever allows me to buy runs, I may just make a whole thread about it, as that would be the greatest thing of all-time. How many bigger-sized bets have I lost by a half-run or full run this year? It's been absurd
 

Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2007
Messages
47,388
Tokens
Got it last night at 7.5 in the most juice I've seen on an over/under all year (-135). Then I decided I wanted it for more this morning at 7 so I simply added another 11 for 10.

Trust me, if my site ever allows me to buy runs, I may just make a whole thread about it, as that would be the greatest thing of all-time. How many bigger-sized bets have I lost by a half-run or full run this year? It's been absurd

Simple solution. Why dont u just switch to 5dimes then??
 
Joined
Apr 6, 2012
Messages
3,314
Tokens
How many over/unders has Joel Peralta cost me this year? Isn't the 8th inning set-up reliever supposed to contribute to WINS? Ugh you've got to be kidding me, way to waste the brilliant gem from James Shields (1 earned run in 7+) you fucking scrub.

My final write-ups for today will be posted in a bit
 
Joined
Apr 6, 2012
Messages
3,314
Tokens
Minnesota Twins @ Chicago White Sox - $74 for $65
Scott Diamond vs Chris Sale
UNDER 8

As the day has gone on, I’ve been liking this pitching matchup more and more. First of all, if you remember, I jumped on Scott Diamond as soon as he entered the Minnesota Twins rotation this year, after showing me a little something in 2011. While I didn’t think he’d out-pitch DAN HAREN in his first ’12 start, I was on that under, and am not surprised to see him out to the successful run that he’s gone on. In case you haven’t heard, Diamond is 3-0 in three starts, owning a 1.40 ERA and 0.98 WHIP. His 13 strikeouts in 19 innings isn’t great or anything, but walking only two batters in those three starts certainly is something to be proud of. He had a couple of fine starts against the White Sox at the end of last year and I see him continuing his effectiveness here tonight.

Chris Sale, meanwhile, reminds me of this year’s Jeremy Hellickson. By that, I mean he’s a young pup who just pumps out quality start after quality start on a regular basis, despite his relatively freshman-type status. In fact, five of his seven starts have officially been just that. I detailed Sale’s unique journey before his last start, going from successful starter, to closer for a week, back to starter, and the thing that I admire about that is that it was him who lobbied to manager Robin Venturato get back into the pitching rotation. That tells me he has a passion for starting and does not want to relinquish his spot at all, meaning there’s that extra edge in him that he’s not taking any start for granted. This can especially be said for tonight’s affair, in which he’s scheduled for duty against a divisional rival at home. Sale is coming off a fantastic start on the road against the intimidating Angels so look for him to keep it going here tonight. I use MLB.com Mobile when I initially review each pitching matchup every night, so hopefully it’s extra encouraging that the words “Diamond Sale” were vibrant on top of each other, perhaps foreshadowing a shiny pitcher’s duel.


Other 5/23 MLB Over/Unders I’m Taking:
Jeff Suppan vs Lance Lynn OVER 7.5 - $50 for $40
Doug Fister vs Zach McAllister OVER 8.5 - $33 for $30 (More analysis below)
Edwin Jackson vs Cole Hamels OVER 6.5 - $22 for $20


Think about Fister vs McAllister for a minute. WHY is the line as high as 8.5? With those parameters, where you have a potentially dominant pitcher like Fister who had EXTREMELY significant success against the Indians last year (39 IP, 38 Ks, 1.62 ERA, 0.82 WHIP!) going up against a guy like Zach McAllister who has put up solid numbers thus far, the line SHOULD be 8, even at Progressive Field. But it’s 8.5 for a reason - Vegas cleverly set the line there because they want to bait people into taking the under, perhaps thinking people will want to ride Fister as much as possible, and casual fans/bettors will just assume that McAllister is fine (He's not that good) and will hold his end of the bargain. I, on the other hand, saw a weakened Doug Fister first-hand in his last start against Minnesota (Which was almost a week ago, by the way), and I think McAllister is due to get roughed up, especially by a Tiger offense capable of putting up a lot of runs. Hence, I’m going over, but it’d be for a lot more money IF the line was 8. 5-3 is worst-case scenario, so obviously go with over 8.5.

You could argue this SAME point for Hanson vs Arroyo over 8.5, although I’m going for the over primarily because I think it’s very unlikely they have three straight low-scoring games with good offenses at Great American Ballpark. Arroyo due to get hit a bit as well. Worst-case scenario in this one is also 5-3, so I’m not sure of my dollar amount on this one just yet.


**May Add More Over/Under(s) Throughout Day Leading Up To Gametime**
 

New member
Joined
Feb 12, 2009
Messages
4,368
Tokens
GL today Cat. Are you playing the Cincy over? It can be had for 8 now
 
Joined
Apr 6, 2012
Messages
3,314
Tokens
Not on my book, it's still +110 on the over of 8.5. But I'm taking it anyway...

Hanson vs Arroyo OVER 8.5 - $25 for $27
 
Joined
Apr 6, 2012
Messages
3,314
Tokens
Eh, about even today. I'll take that for a Wednesday, given my Wednesday struggles this year. Just disappointed I split my two top bets, as Romero vs Shields under SHOULD have won if not for... you guessed it... another bullpen collapse in the 8th. And no, you can't really predict that, as Joe Maddon is a very intelligent guy that you WOULD figure is smart enough to realize now that the Joel Peralta of this year is not the Joel Peralta of last year, and thus, should not be your set-up man when he's blown multiple games (Including multiple big unders of mine). It should not even have gotten to that point, as there's not one person in the country who took the over and thought, "Hmm, Ricky Romero is uncharacteristically going to walk a lot of guys today in his best setting as a pitcher. Actually, he's going to walk a CAREER HIGH." Yeah, this game was obviously a fluke given how it played out (Not to mention minor leaguer Drew Sutton, who was JUST TRADED FOR CASH CONSIDERATIONS FROM THE BRAVES, was batting clean up for the Rays).

My only disappointment was not pursuing the Smith vs Pettitte over. While I didn't mention it, I took the Yankee team total over 5 for a small amount (Did not mention it because it does not go on my record either way), and the reasoning is, well, too easy. Think about it, put yourself in the mind of Will Smith. You're making your Major League debut at hallowed Yankee Stadium in New York, the most controversial city in the entire world. You're not really good, as you're ranked the 15th "best" prospect on the team by MLB.com (And that's the ranking AFTER all their big guys started coming up like Hosmer, Duffy, Moustakas, etc.), so what do you think is going through your mind? Considering you weren't even successful at Double-A Arkansas last year, and not doing too well this year, obviously you're going to struggle against a Yankee team that was overdue. It's not his fault, it's human nature. As I emphasize all the time, if you completely figure out the human psychology of a given scenario, you will dominate that said scenario. No questions about it. That's why to be successful in this industry, you have to keep tabs on this stuff on every team every single day, just like I do reading up on every pitcher in the league and tracking them every day, taking note in my memory of their recent pattern. It's not as difficult as it sounds.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,257
Messages
13,449,952
Members
99,404
Latest member
byen17188
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com