Who wins this 5 on 5?

knuckleballah22 · Jun 15, 2012

Who wins this 5 on 5 in prime of each?

Jordan
Pippen
Ewing
Stockton
Malone

vs

Durant
James
Bryant
Rondo
Garnett

Assume 100% equal reserves on each team and the two best coaches

Jstack34 · Jun 15, 2012

I take the first team because of the size advantage

WorldNumberOne · Jun 15, 2012

jordan wouldnt let his team lose to those guys..

aceduecetrey · Jun 15, 2012

World Number One said:
jordan wouldnt let his team lose to those guys..

I agree, but would Ewing allow them to win?

gynecologist · Jun 15, 2012

I got a question?

If Jordan is on Kobe and Pippen is on James, who would guard Durant? Or vice versa?

Malone would have to guard Durant right?

Oh boy

WorldNumberOne · Jun 15, 2012

jordan would ask if he can sub akeem the dream for ewing... and magic for stockton..

Jaguara · Jun 15, 2012

World Number One said:
jordan would ask if he can sub akeem the dream for ewing... and magic for stockton..

I'd take Ewing over Hakeem but then I'm bias. #33 is my favorite player of all time. He was a beast of a center in his day.

HuskerFan1 · Jun 15, 2012

its the top 5 and its not even close IMO....jordan and pippen defensively unstopable....stockton at the point, one of the best ever....total mismatch...malone best power forward of all time behind duncan

HacheMan · Jun 15, 2012

HuskerFan1 said:
its the top 5 and its not even close IMO....jordan and pippen defensively unstopable....stockton at the point, one of the best ever....total mismatch...malone best power forward of all time behind duncan

Agree with this... Especially the point about Stockton not only being one of the best ever, but probably the best Point Guard ever...And those who argue that he's not doesn't realize this.... http://www.therxforum.com/showthread.php?t=790123&highlight=john+stockton

shdw01 · Jun 15, 2012

The second 5 haven't all reached their prime yet (Kobe and Garnett have passed it) so from what I know today i say top 5. But when it is said and done we may change our opinions.

what about the decade/generation you missed:

Shaq
Kobe
Duncan
JKidd/SNash (u choose)
Garnett/Nowitzki (u choose)

HuskerFan1 · Jun 15, 2012

another reason the top5 would be so dominate stockton and malone played together and know each others games inside and out, ditto for jordan and pippen...just having 2 sets of 2 guys who have played with each other is huge IMO

loomis41973 · Jun 15, 2012

Team 1...at least 9 outta 10 times

festeringZit · Jun 15, 2012

HuskerFan1 said:
its the top 5 and its not even close IMO....jordan and pippen defensively unstopable....stockton at the point, one of the best ever....total mismatch...malone best power forward of all time behind duncan

Duncan > Malone.

5teamparlay · Jun 15, 2012

Durant
James
Bryant
Rondo
Garnett

Who plays center??

5teamparlay · Jun 15, 2012

If team one gets their coach, PHIl

Team 2 gets???

I'll take Phil ...

gmenknicks · Jun 15, 2012

5teamparlay said:
Who plays center??

Whoever it is gets crushed by Ewing

loomis41973 · Jun 15, 2012

1 caveat..Durant hasn't hit his prime yet.

gynecologist · Jun 15, 2012

Can Malone guard Durant?

PatsFan1283 · Jun 15, 2012

Why those 10 guys? Just curious..

HuskerFan1 · Jun 15, 2012

positions, 1st team is lockdown other than putting in magic for stockton (in which case it would be an absolute joke) but the 2nd team really doesnt have a power forward (if you put garnett at center) and b/c its current players you have to include james and durant....

like someone mentioned way above the size of the 1st team over the current players is a joke....

Who wins this 5 on 5?

New member

Member

Self appointed RX World Champion Handicapper

Member

Banned

Self appointed RX World Champion Handicapper

Banned

Member

hacheman@therx.com

Rx Senior

Member

New member

Member

Member

Member

New member

New member

Banned

Member

Member

Forum statistics

Share this page